CHF for NAB Cup....

[borderbarry]

Who will be used at CHF in Roo's absense in the NAB cup?
Give Lynch a try"
Maybe Kosi?
B.J.?
Raf Clarke?
And who at FF?

[goodie]

[Saints Premiers 2008]

Who will be used at CHF in Roo's absense in the NAB cup?
Give Lynch a try"
Maybe Kosi?
B.J.?
Raf Clarke?
And who at FF?

rotate it

not raph however i would like to see a few of the new guys play a lead up goal kicking forward to partner kosi who should play in the square

the fact is if kosi plays full forward for the year and plays a bit of ruck he wont have the massive goal kicking output much like last year

hoever if one considers roo down for 50+ same with milne, it would be illogical to think that kosi could match considering the emphasis both get going forward

[Solar]

would like them to try chips there wit cahill and lynch to work the forward line with him. Give raph clarke CHB and goose/dawson FB and rest max.

Just in the NAB cup so we can add a string or two to our bow. Raph clarke has played CHB for the scorps against players 10 cms and 15 kg's bigger them him.

[Batnoe]

i think they will either play Gwilt. Maguire or Gilbert there

Lynch, Cahill arent quite ready to play the 'main role' just yet

[saintspremiers]

Doesn't really matter....they are all practice matches, with no hardness or meaning.

[Moorabbin Saints]

Play Kosi right at the 50 line. As a true CHF leading up to the wings and taking the ruck around 30-60m from goal.

[PJ]

It'd be good if the coaching staff thought outside the box for NAB. Don't see the benefit of over rehearsing what we always do.

Get game and push some players out of their comfort zone. If any of the youngens are available play'em - now. You can't experiment once the really McCoy starts.

[Saints Premiers 2008]

i think they will either play Gwilt. Maguire or Gilbert there

Lynch, Cahill arent quite ready to play the 'main role' just yet

depending on who can play well down back i wouldn be against goose becoming a quality third tall, even a swingman if need be

adam hunter...except better and lasting longer than one year...

[bigcarl]

i'd like to see the following players tried in the key forward positions in riewoldt's absence: bj, r. clarke, s. fisher, s. gilbert.

if one of them shows he has what it takes to play key forward this could be very important to us later in 2009.

lynch, no doubt, will be looked at but unless he is a complete bolter he's a longer term prospect.

with kosi playing as second ruck (resting forward) we will effectively need a chf and a ff until riewoldt is back and a chf or a ff once he is back.

obviously you'd rather have riewoldt fully fit at this stage of the year, but there is a plus side to it. it will force us to find other avenues to goal.

[Eastern]

Play Kosi right at the 50 line. As a true CHF leading up to the wings and taking the ruck around 30-60m from goal.

I seem to remember a bloke wearing #23 doing exactly that some years ago !!

[LTN16]

Who will be used at CHF in Roo's absense in the NAB cup?
Give Lynch a try"
Maybe Kosi?
B.J.?
Raf Clarke?
And who at FF?

Ben McEvoy !!
Some will say he is to slow but he is a great mark and got a good tank. He is quicker than most think.

[jays]

hope bj

[older saint]

Why is everyone so set on moving our best rebound defender to the forward line. He reads play well but not a great contested mark and HB is easier to play running forwardthan HF where you have to turn on a sixpence

CHF for pre season perhaps try one of the young blokes or Gwilt. Really menas nothing anyway

[saintsRrising]

We have Kosi..and we have Lynch and Cahill...

We also have Zac asa key forward too..
For the NAB Cup that is ample.

[WayneJudson42]

Would like to see Kosi (if fit) play at CHF and Roo @ FF.

Then if we can find a good 3rd, Roo could easily kick 100 for the year IMO.

Lance played his best footy with Hamill at his side, as did Gtrain.

Depending on who plays back, I reckon Goose might be that 3rd option that can block and give a bit of argy bargy.

Apart from Mc Evoy as a possible fwd, I can't see anyone being "ready" to play full time.

Noce to have options

[Bernard Shakey]

Roo aint doing nuffink in the NAB Cup. He just had his knee scraped.

[BallBanger]

Roo aint doing nuffink in the NAB Cup. He just had his knee scraped.

What did you think of the concert at the bowl wed night?

The bowl aint what it used to be

[saintsRrising]

Would like to see Kosi (if fit) play at CHF and Roo @ FF.

You might want to re-read the OP.

[bobmurray]

Would like to see Kosi (if fit) play at CHF and Roo @ FF.

Roo is out of the NAB cup

[WayneJudson42]

Would like to see Kosi (if fit) play at CHF and Roo @ FF.

Roo is out of the NAB cup

Big picture Bob.. big picture

[borderbarry]

Err Wayne, check the thread.... CHF for NAB Cup.

[SaintHomer]

its a shame allen got injured late last year. would have been a great opportunity for him. i'm sure more will come (but hopefully not this way)

kosi out of the square. blake (our stop gap) to get some time there. maybe even get mcevoy in the fwd line.

BJ in the centre i reckon. time to produce. the apprenticeship is over.

[Dan Warna]

before his knee injury Goddard shown some real form as a CHF.

IMO he is a very exciting player and given his work rate, endurance, courage and skill, as well as his booming kick, he can be a real threat.

IMO goddard at CHF and roo at FF.

[saintsRrising]

Once again....Roo can't be at FF...he will in the stands most likely.