CarlosA wrote:This is pointless.

None of you will actually do anythign about it. You will still attend the game thsi weekend putting more money into the AFL coffers.

Try boycotting it first fools.

Doesnt that hurt the club more than the AFL?

Although he hasn't said it yet, I think that is the point Dan was trying to make in his OP. When confronted with clear indisputable vision/evidence, the AFL through its bodies the MRP and Tribunal make allowances for accidental head clashes but yet when they have not a single shred of evidence they...

lol I was thinking good money for the pies.

Josh Fraser is back, Adelaide have 2 players in doubt It's in victoria. Rocca didn't get suspended.

Spot on, read a few lines of the OP and posted no doubt about it. No problem admitting it. Though I was arguing that the hit was fair. Threads evolve as conversation develops. All I said was the the hit was fair. I didn't relate it to Bakes hit until you raised it to me. Though comparing the 2 is ri...

I dont see how the Baker incident has many similarities with the Ball incident. lol we'll I can't compare the 2... because unlike you I assume i didn't actaully see the hit(or was that the whole country as well?). Bakes is a mongrel and a dirty player. I love him to death and is a great plaer for ou...

So please explain what the circumstances were that were so different as to allow Baker to be given 4 weeks for his heinous crime? Sorry? bakes 4 weeks(got 7 didnt he?) You means Bakes hit on Farmer? Yeh we get hit and injured, so do others. Hamil made Aker injure his AC join by running off the line...

Probaby check live scores on AFL website until half time, and the watch the delayed telecast.

Blake probably did a good a job as anyone else we had aviliable.

read what I wrote again instead of being selective. The bump was malicious(well as all bumps in afl are mostly one would think). Thought the intention was not for the head. ''Both were collisions which they instigated. Both resulted in severe head injuries. '' well done, that's correct. Ball was unl...

lol from round 1? let it go. Fair bump, unlucky for ball. Fair? Since when are you allowed to bump someone in the head? They clashed heads, he wasn't going for balls skull. That was accidental. If he was going for balls head why didnt he just king hit him or something in that manner. Like Baker on ...

Retire Hamil (only if the news is bad from his december test) Question, Would it be pointless if he retired come december, because we would've possible missed out on getting a pick(as there is a deadline for list numbers, etc). Or if he retires in december is that enough time for us to get another ...

rodgerfox wrote:

Saint Corin wrote:lol from round 1? let it go. Fair bump, unlucky for ball.

Fair?

Since when are you allowed to bump someone in the head?

They clashed heads, he wasn't going for balls skull. That was accidental.

If he was going for balls head why didnt he just king hit him or something in that manner.

Not that sharpest tool in the shed, but has his spot in our best 22 at the moment anyways. In my ideal team he would be in our top 25. With Goddard inplace of Blake in the roles he takes.

should have added not signaling out harvey,gehrig just reckon its time to move on Agree. I love Harvs, and am a big fan of Fraser. Both I think would be an assest on 08 and have the ability to go on. Though i do agree it's time to move on(Fraser more so than Gherig). Harvs will continue to do his t...

lol from round 1? let it go. Fair bump, unlucky for ball.

Oh well, we dont have anyone who could've done much better than Clarke so it doesn't make much of a difference.

lol St Fid your probably one who would get upset when ppl bag Harvs as well.

Goddard and Sam Fisher would make awsome CHF's or big blokes in the middle I reckon.

Hard tag on foley, I think we should come out and be physical. Isolate Gherig in the aquare as well, Hopefully Kosi has a big game. Ferguson to play on Pettifer. Gonna miss Attard this game, he would've had a range of opponents we could've used him on. Mini should be brought into tag someone like De...

woooosaints wrote:priddis was 1st in the sandover medal last year clint jones was 3rd

We should've drafted the bloke who was 2nd

Wouldn't mind plaing Bendigo. Think we would beat them, last time they had the AFL players going for them.

The stats look pretty and all that but I don't really take them into that high reguard. Seaby aint as good as everyone thinks, but I think he is a bit better than what your selling him for. Looking at past games Seaby doesn't get that much of a go, it's really the Cox show. Seaby has stood up in gam...

His shoulder is the biggest worry, the rest of his body seems fine.

i have wanted to see roo play around the ground much more as his size and engine would suit In what role? Yeah I think Roo could roam around the ground, being a link man, getting 25 touches a game and so many marks. Though there is no way he could play a similar role to Goodes. Roo has the engine o...

Where is Mini at in comparison to Armitage, Eddy and Jones? Jones seems to be ahead of him, and Eddy is going alright for a rookie, Armo does well in scrops.