Has had a horror run with injury , on way back mid season and does a calf. No way could have played this year after that at afl level. Was a top 10 pick and top 5 in B & F so compensation would want to be reasonable. Be at pains to see him go before others . Just because another club enquirers d...

This will be a tough one. Probably a decision not expected to have to make 24 weeks ago.

Any guesses

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3Ddm6SsW4dhgc&ved=2ahUKEwiynceaiomBAxUBY94KHfOcCBUQwqsBegQIDBAF&usg=AOvVaw0YhtR3C1a2Y_PW1WG_M2wj 1. That first final in 1991 after a long drought in the 70's and '80's was memor...

We have enough fights on here about a team we all love!
Unlike the AFL ( thanks for the new stadium money) let's leave this forum to be about football and the Saints.. or we will see Lord of the Flies 2023 version begin

Agree with most. Stanley was a mistake - never really tried as a ruck properly at Stkilda. Made worse drafting Goddard at 21 who didn't work out at all. Names such as Steele, Touk Miller, Maynard, Mitch McGovern, Dougal Howard, Langdon drafted afterwards doesnt help - also that stanley is now a Pre...

Agree with most. Stanley was a mistake - never really tried as a ruck properly at Stkilda. Made worse drafting Goddard at 21 who didn't work out at all. Names such as Steele, Touk Miller, Maynard, Mitch McGovern, Dougal Howard, Langdon drafted afterwards doesnt help - also that stanley is now a Prem...

interesting in recent times this type of player and time line sees a similar pick to where they were originally selected.

My guess would cost a late first rounder ?

contracted so for once we hold the whip hand here.

Anyone else think we went in against Brisbane with too many talls? The game changed when a running player, Byrnes, came on for Battle. We had Cordy Wilkie, Battle down back, with Hayes, Membrey Sharman as the tall forwards. But we also have Owens and the Pou who are hybrid forwards who compete in t...

f*** resting King...I'd be giving him as much game time as possible. bad move. how long is Seb out ? we need him bad. Wouldn't be surprised if Max's shoulder is just hanging in there and they are afraid one big hit will be enough. I don't mind him skipping this game and being ok for the finals. I t...

shanegrambeau wrote: ↑Wed 23 Aug 2023 8:50pm Trivia question

Who were your favorite Mc (something) or Mac (Something) players over the years?

Mc Adam and Mc Conville for me

Media always looking for a pin up boy, especially in this society we currently have . It is no ones business but their own , and really who cares. Like ma y have said there are openly gay AFLW, Soccer Mne and Women, Netball and NBL & WNBL, but not openly AFL - and the only logical reason is the ...

longtimesaint wrote: ↑Wed 23 Aug 2023 4:49pm

older saint wrote: ↑Wed 23 Aug 2023 4:28pm Trivia question for the older people here - who remembers the name of the first Irish guy we recruited. Played 3 games off memory?

Dermot McNicholl in about 1988 -90

Love your work

Trivia question for the older people here - who remembers the name of the first Irish guy we recruited. Played 3 games off memory?

Says" I have been w..w..ww...wr.....w..rong....all season." What a f***wit. Caro stayed mute.......which you all have to admit, is a f****** improvement. not a fan but at least had the courage to admit he was wrong. King picked Geelong to win by 5 goals and now is all over us, Changes pos...

Hope he is retained, has something we lack in regard to elite foot skills and poise. Just needs some continuity of games. He will never be a superstar but what he could be is the cream to go along with Steele, Owens, Nasiah , King , which great teams have. Agree but I think the club are looking for...

Jack Hayes. Can give Roma a chop-out. Give us a big body up forward. Versatile and can play a number of roles. Good, competitive guy to have on the show. Or Coffield if he’s right Huge risk to go with any big as a sub. mid gets inj or concussion then too top heavy , where as if big goes down easier...

To me I would see this as a logical move and sub being one of Billings or if they want to potentially use him in finals Coffield.

So how much do you pay him to keep him? What's he worth to us (contract wise) to stay? If he was offered 600-700k by NM (or anybody else), would you match/beat that to keep him? Similar question re Gresham - how much are you prepared to offer to keep him? That is the big question, which really appl...

Interesting take on the list, and agree it isn't too bad, but a coach with a clear plan and players understanding their role and requirements helps . Def: So much of the AFL now days is systems and ability to help off ,however the ability to beat you man 1 on 1 if key to the top defence. Collingwood...

Hope he is retained, has something we lack in regard to elite foot skills and poise. Just needs some continuity of games.
He will never be a superstar but what he could be is the cream to go along with Steele, Owens, Nasiah , King , which great teams have.

No one, unless carrying an injury or really sore that 2 weeks not playing will significantly help. Reasons: - Don't mess with Form; - Week off before finals; - Ideally want to give yourself the best chance at a home final. - Have a real belief at the moment and sends a message that we don't believe ...

Melbourne weren't great yesterday so i would think they will be keen to keep momentum going , yes if guys sore rest but they have a pretty healthy list and guys are playing for spots. Oliver only just back so needs time. Syd- papley out McCartin out Or i am just being hopeful?? Easy beat Brisabne .....

Old fashion footballer, not tall, not athletic not overly quick but smart, uses body well and knows where the ball is going .
hopefully celebrates with a win

I mentioned in previous post - look to trade up most saying a top 10 strong draft (exc GC academy players) CG need points Potential free agency or trade provides additional second rounder. We have a good base but need more high level talent and if we can get that to 6 pick and finish somewhere 6-10 ...