Thank God he did. But surely an X factor should perform better than one in ten? I hope he gets the fattest of contracts so both parties can benefit.

I suspect that thread has been reported. I also suspect the initial post was out weighed with unwavering support for said player...probably not because many felt let down. Threads regarding players have been going on since Milan Faletic dreamed of kicking goals from the centre of Moorabbin. If you h...

Goose X man Bally From the 2001 draft We had 6 picks inside the top 50 in that draft 2-Ball 5-Clarke 13-Dal Santo 21-Maguire 37-Montagna 49-Houlihan Plus Rookie picks 2-Josh Dickey’s 18-Ben Schwarze In 2009 At 25/26 yo We delisted 3 of them Brought in with those picks we got from those players Jess...

Depends on who you lose I’ve already named the players that will leave My theory You never get better by losing talent And trading good players for speculative picks is a gamble, which rarely pays off! What a crock of sh!t! We are always going to lose players. It's apparent we are not going anywher...

St Kilda haven't lost too many successful players to other clubs in the last few years. Blake Acres is the exception He wasn't that great at Freo! His form at Carlton is now Freo's blunder, not ours. Barring injury in the last half of his last season he was on track for AA. 100% the worst "ste...

Still hoping for an answer to my question but I guess it's my bad for quoting.

Who's the popular player being given the lemon & sarse?

shanegrambeau wrote: ↑Sat 12 Aug 2023 4:37pm Hickey, McEvoy and Stanley all blunders.. but we were blessed with Paddy. Briefly…far too briefly.

Blessed with Paddy??? Like the Titanic was blessed with a bottle of champagne.

Is this mass exodus because the players have no where left to hide? If they don't like being held to account for their performance then, thanks for your service however good, bad or indifferent it was. Lyon is there for another 3 years after enduring a list and standard not of his making. The spotli...

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 12 Aug 2023 12:08pm

And there will be at least one big surprise - and unpopular

I am sure I heard this somewhere before, l don't think you were the original poster.

Can you elaborate on who this player is?

Yes bob, a small forward cheating out the back is not new and certainly not an excuse for a defender being lit up. It's their craft to do that, a defender's craft is to stop that materialising into 6 goals. Another who can have all their B&F votes, I want a flag contending team. I don't want to ...

I think Raphael Clarke was considered worse Yeah, I heard a lot of the crap directed to him at the footy including some racist slurs from one individual. i still regret not reporting him. But hey, this forum has always needed a whipping boy or two. Seriously? If you genuinely heard that it has to b...

I think Raphael Clarke was considered worse Yeah, I heard a lot of the crap directed to him at the footy including some racist slurs from one individual. i still regret not reporting him. But hey, this forum has always needed a whipping boy or two. Seriously? If you genuinely heard that it has to b...

WTAF, Paton added to the squad surely Lyon has seen enough of him Really? It sounds like you think he was on Breust. I prefer my defenders to be able to defend. I prefer my defenders to be able to think for themselves, not freeze under pressure and actually use the ball. He’s NFG and he won’t be at...

I think Raphael Clarke was considered worse Yeah, I heard a lot of the crap directed to him at the footy including some racist slurs from one individual. i still regret not reporting him. But hey, this forum has always needed a whipping boy or two. Seriously? If you genuinely heard that it has to b...

WTAF, Paton added to the squad surely Lyon has seen enough of him Really? It sounds like you think he was on Breust. I prefer my defenders to be able to defend. I prefer my defenders to be able to think for themselves, not freeze under pressure and actually use the ball. He’s NFG and he won’t be at...

saintbob wrote: ↑Thu 10 Aug 2023 7:51pm WTAF, Paton added to the squad surely Lyon has seen enough of him

Really? It sounds like you think he was on Breust. I prefer my defenders to be able to defend.

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Sun 06 Aug 2023 6:49pm What this has proven, we will NEVER win a flag

The OP is a cop out. Enough is enough???

They are a flog. Apparently cannot spare the time for one game a year. A limp d!ck of the greatest order, a troll.

I think Raphael Clarke was considered worse Yeah, I heard a lot of the crap directed to him at the footy including some racist slurs from one individual. i still regret not reporting him. But hey, this forum has always needed a whipping boy or two. Seriously? If you genuinely heard that it has to b...

This worries me BF Anyone hear the rumour about Flanders being part of the package that brings Dusty to GC? If we can't get Flanders, I'd hope Richmond get him if it means Dusty to GC. There goes the GC wiggle room in the salary cap and "ambassadorial" roles. A lot more players will spill...

How was the preparation between GF’s in 2010? we were cooked. Spot on! We fired out shot Actually Pies were best side in 2010 (borrowed our defensive game plan) We were done Agree, cooked! But I still have trouble believing they were the better side. The IP from Ball & Max was massive. Finally ...

I am amazed that if you lead at half time you should be guaranteed the win. I guess that means if we are ever behind at half time, we should just go home. In terms of Hawthorn v Carlton and their respective form lines, I think we were pretty close in terms of result. We jump out of the blocks, got r...

Get him! I like the idea of Ross being his Homer. A very successful pairing.

So "they say" is your proof?

He's a spud we'll have to pay to get rid of. The only thing getting torn up is Gresham's future contract. The most over rated of all St Kilda's alleged mids. Surely this mythical X factor bullsh!t has been put to bed, he's a fraud.

SydneySainter is a flog, a tool, a troll. Someone refusing to attend Sydney games unless a win is guaranteed. A wanker, who would not even meet, in Sydney, to discuss St Kilda. A fraud!