https://www.saints.com.au/news/1281637/injury-update-coffield-membrey-among-round-1-absentees Faqk. 14 players on the injury list and we haven't fired a shot in anger Has to be the surface at Moorabbin. Too hard and no give I reckon. Absolute joke. Simply put questions must be asked Effectively 1/3...

Geez, It's light hearted, he has players on side, past and current. Relax will you. Of course it’s light hearted, that’s one of the issues From 1974-1990 the St K FC won a total of 103 games of football An average of a touch over 6 per season over 17 seasons!!! Unbelievable And if you want to take ...

I am not against people having a good time but are we a serious football club To celebrate our 150th do we want to glorify a past that just adds to the perception of us as a joke Never mind that during the late 70s and 80s our record was pretty much disgraceful, but hell we could put on a party Blok...

Interesting


are there restrictions for each column

Otherwise wouldn’t you put everyone in the max point column

Ridiculous negativity

He is 19 years old, I repeat 19. Born 2003

Played 7 games last year and some time yesterday. Such a huge body of work!!

Enough apparently for the “good” judges on here to write him off


FQF

What was the verdict on here on Higgo and Butler? SaintsTV’s Jake muttered something like, ‘a lot to be desired’, and he’s usually super optimist/ Sunnyside Up. Oh.. and Bytel? The most disappointing aspect to 16 and 22 is their lack of defensive pressure. The amount of times that Bowey was allowed...

How f***ed is that. Windy kicks a long goal and the clueless female commentating the match says 'the dees put through another one. Thankfully her male mate corrected her. I thought you had the mute button on In fact neither of them knew until the replay as they were watching the Heath injury But he...

It seems that everyone is giving our playing list an absolute caning. You could swear we're destined for the wooden spoon for the next couple of years, based on what so many idiots in the footy media have been saying. As usual, they love to stick the boots into us, because that's what you do, isn't...

I find this OP extremely offensive And not very factual Robbie Neill played 23 games over 2 seasons and Ricky Nixon 41 over 5, so hardly handed games on a platter As for Zac Dawson , can we once and for all just let it go Facts he played 63 games for St K over 3 seasons Including awards for Player o...

Given the circus that we have become

Plan B is probably Richo

I’ve said it before in another thread and I’ll say it again

Oskar Bakker from Melbourne is quick, Stocker is slow

And just could not break into a very good Melbourne side

Definitely worth a look

Oh so this tired old pearl of wisdom gets trotted out…. AGAIN In 2009, we won what 19 in a row, and with minimal injuries, so not much room for a change Of the youngsters Jack Steven at 19 got 1 game late in season Begley (who?) 1 game Armitage 3 (from memory never looked fit enough as a youngster) ...

Given the timing of all this

Did Walsh tell the club “I’m not coming unless you sack Ratten”?

Walsh starts Nov 1

It fits his narrative

Melbourne also delisted Oskar Bakker

Could not get a look in this year, but is hard, fast and I believe could be worth a look

Way better than his number of games demonstrates

No my feelings are not hurt (do you have to make a personal comment?) As I said many of us here agree with the sentiment, I certainly do. My point (again) is that as an employee is he entitled to air those thoughts publically. Would you start a new job and on your first day say“excited to join an o...

How did his comments impact on our ability to attract players during this trade period? Pretty negatively, I suspect. Throw in Goddard and Riewoldt having a crack at the club and it's culture and it makes Gallagher's job nigh impossible. I agree with Terry Smith Rules. It has a bit of Malbom Blight...

How did his comments impact on our ability to attract players during this trade period? Pretty negatively, I suspect. Throw in Goddard and Riewoldt having a crack at the club and it's culture and it makes Gallagher's job nigh impossible. I agree with Terry Smith Rules. It has a bit of Malbom Blight...

It’s not because it might be right (many of us here suspect it) It’s because what gives him right to come out in public and say it. He said it as an employee of the StK FC. We have the right .. long suffering members and employees Joey, Nick etc have the right, they have earnt that. Employees of the...

kosifantutti wrote: ↑Sat 01 Oct 2022 9:35pm

terry smith rules wrote: ↑Sat 01 Oct 2022 7:51pm Well Daniel Wulf will be relieved

As his miss drops to #2 as the worst St K miss in recent times

Josh Bruce and Tim Membrey say hi.

Sure but Wulf’s was for the game, those two didn’t mean anything

Well Daniel Wulf will be relieved

As his miss drops to #2 as the worst St K miss in recent times

kosifantutti wrote: ↑Fri 30 Sep 2022 9:25pm

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Fri 30 Sep 2022 8:44pm

Rubyjo wrote: ↑Fri 30 Sep 2022 8:38pm It's very good money . 850 for Hill or Bowes is farking stupid ..

Why?? At best they have a 20 year earning window - have you heard J Cameron talk - after football he will probably apply for a job as a post

Goal or behind?

You win the internet…. Gold right there

Wow there are some short sighted views on this thread Bowes is not a bad player (certainly no list clogger as some have said), between 2018 and 2021 played 67/88 possible games) what staggers me is all those who say they don’t watch other teams, then suddenly have an opinion on a player they don’t k...

The verbatim reporting of allegations/stories from one side in an extract from a third party report does not provide balance. Particularly given the shock/horror slant the ABC is giving. The stories/scenarios outlined could easily be depicted completely differently by an objective assessment of pla...

Sainternist wrote: ↑Wed 21 Sep 2022 1:55pm Russell Jackson is one of the best AFL journalists going. He’s also a St.Kilda supporter.

He wrote the Robbie Muir and Rod Owen stories in the last couple of years, both also harrowing exposés

Realistically how many player’s names out there are ones that we would really want?

De Gooey, still in running?

Taranto… yes

Hopper .. possibly

Lobb… too inconsistent

In my opinion the best player getting mentioned is Dunkley, very consistent

The rest … no