nobody is going to swap goose for a quality backman think realisitic players who are 21/22 defenders out of sides because theyre are better players. why would we do that when goose is part of our best goal-to-goal line-up. if they want him imo they'd have to give us a player as good as him and they...

dont know but i mean as an example a quality young backman who is surplus to a team like graham we want a player as good as goose is now ... not someone who is surplus to requirements. goose isn't surplus to requirements anyway. you saw how our defence fared in the first part of the season without ...

The Hawks window is well & truly open for the next few years, Goose would make them instant contenders. Would absolutely effing hate that to happen though. I don't think we're that far off it either. we only just missed the finals despite having a first year coach and a club that was in turmoil...

lol u joking!!!!! frankling or roughead overrate much best we could hope for is 1st Round Pick No. 13 + 2nd Round Pick No. 30 for Maguire + 3rd Round Pick whatever ours is and id think that is really pushing it maybe a 1st rounder+ 3rd rounder is what we would get for him we want a player who is as...

potential champion chb.

we'd want a potential champion in return such as franklin or maybe roughhead and someone else thrown in.

tell 'em to p*ss off

cowboy18 wrote:Let get one of these. Don't think money will be the issue.




He only counts half to the salary cap so I imagine what you suggest is fair.

i reckon he'd settle for that

FACTS 1? So far this year we have not lost anyone. So why is the list falling to pieces. Even Harvey rather than being exited out is playing on. The only walk out was Sugar...and he was a dud. 2? GT never lost anyone???.....well apart from Hall, Black, Everitt you mean...??? Plus duds like Knoble t...

no the leadership began when dal, kosi and roo all resigned. if goose was to go it would appear that his whole good bloke 'matey' kind of image was infact a crock. let's not forget that loyalty is a two-way street. have our blokes been as diligent as they could have been in pursuing goose's signatu...

Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:he is part of the brotherhood of the young stars and for him to leave would be a disaster

i agree. gt would never have let the list fall to pieces like it appears to be. time for someone at the club to show some LEADERSHIP and hold it together. starts with signing goose

Goose is very important to us and would be on the best true CHB in the AFL so if he does go we must get what hes worth. would be loathe to let him go and the club must do everything it can to keep the core of this list together. but you are right. if he must go we must make sure we get full compens...

Animal Enclosure wrote:A bloke at work said that he heard Mick McGuane talking on Sport 927 about Goose & said that he wants to leave.

would mean more coming from goose. what would mcgaune know?

meher baba wrote:Trading away Pendlebury for Judd IMO would be almost as crazy as us trading Dal for him.

i'd have to think about that one mb. one is a proven champion, albiet injured. the other could be one of the all-time greats ... could be

if not for the RB/GT debacle we'd probably still be the best melbourne club and right in the running to grab judd's services.

imo this is why RB has to go.

Teflon wrote:Shouldve gone a year earlier for mine.........but your right Im now grateful hes gone...........well........he is gone...isnt he????

time will tell on that one

hey st.byron. your avatar is a bit big

MC Euro Gusto wrote:i have heard some bad stuff on rb from the inner sanctum. i trust the information.
he must stand down

won't matter. imo he is gawwwn anyway when the people have their say

Well someone's gotta be there to teach chris judd a few of the fundamentals. good news. let's hope the rest of the boys give him a fitting send-off with a premiership. the pre-season starts now

killa_gram wrote:It's on, Harves to WC for Judd.

no deal.

st.byron wrote:He's untouchable IMO unless it's a seriously good offer like Judd.

agree. that's one trade i would consider. but don't throw a potential champion like goose away for a GOP hack like Jolly

great news

this means judd will be able to learn some fundamentals such as gut running from the great man.

could also pick up some hints about those little chip kicks that always tend to find a leading forward's chest

he brings the ball to the ground and also contests and works hard true. if attitude were everything he'd be first picked ... but he hardly ever gets it. imo blake or even goose are better value as a second ruck despite their lack of cms. they can actually get the ball and do something with it, whic...

He's a good back up ruckman. He's a known commodity, and is an extremely hard worker. While I doubt the club has given him a 3 year contract i would not be disappointed to see him retained for another couple of years. I don't agree with the all the Rix bashing that goes on here, he given more to th...

think i stumbled on to it by typing st kilda football club into google. now i have an addiction that i can't shake

The key to all of this is getting Judd to nominate St.Kilda as his preferred club. WC will eventually accept a reasonable trade for him or else risk him going into the pre season draft & getting squat for him. very good observation there AE. the players who know judd should start lobbying him now

congratulations on a more than respectable career, vossy. one of the top, most courageous defenders in the league for a couple of seasons there.