Ross Lyon now has half the season to retool for next year. If he continues down the path of sending our players out with the same negative redundant game plan for the rest of the year then no I don't want him there next year. tell me how does lyons gameplan help with our inside 50's tackles be laid...

Listening to Matthew Knights on the ABC he says St Kilda doesn't have the offensive game to take on the press that teams now employ, a style of game that the Saints started. Knights also said players like Baker, Dumpster ,Steven and Mini have NO offensive side and aren't going to give much trying t...

Ross Lyon now has half the season to retool for next year. If he continues down the path of sending our players out with the same negative redundant game plan for the rest of the year then no I don't want him there next year. Now is the time for him to reach into his bag of tricks and find something...

In 2005 I think we beat Melbourne 176-88, I may be wrong, and probably am, but that is the most recent example of a huge score for us.

as 12 years of being a stkilda supporter, 5 years a member, And you are whinging? FFS there are some here that saw the Saitns win one game a season. 4 wooden spoons in a row. You have been privileged so stop you whining. :roll: I remember in the 1980's following the Saints and Subiaco when they bot...

Although it pains me to say this there is one man out there who has made a habit over the last 10 years or so of turning sub par players into super men. In 2004 until 2009 I heard many say that Malthouse should be sacked. They went through the exact thing we are going through now and they didn't au...

Dwayne Russell was a dog of a commentator today. He sure enjoyed sticking the boots in to the Saints. I agree it was a poor effort today by the Saints. A few Saints should be in the two's next week. Looking on the bright side - at least the only way is up. On another bright side the media and most ...

Although it pains me to say this there is one man out there who has made a habit over the last 10 years or so of turning sub par players into super men. Mick Malthouse. If he can take a group of for the most part, mediocre players into 3/4 grand finals I have no doubt he would have an influence on t...

On the plus side Dal will at least remember his 200th game more fondly then his first.....I think we all will

Personally, I don't think the game plan is the worst thing in the world, if we were able to go the other way just as hard. In the NRL, the league leaders St George have made their game plan as such, grind the other team into submission, then put the points on the board. We try to do the first half o...

Nick definitely needs to spend less time on waxing his pills and more time on improving his skills

Oops was just a bit too eager to get away on my holiday up there, apologies for the over eagerness

I hope our coach does get his fair share of the blame for this. He is definitely a glass half empty kind of guy :? In essence "ensuring our opponents score less then us" is no different from his predecessors philosophy of "we will score more then you" but it kinda is. We will be ...

Bring back the G Train.....I mean Banger....oops I mean Raph

Actually I have no idea

Useless is a good word to use in the title of this thread, all supporters could make a list just as damning on their clubs. After all, everyone makes mistakes, and hindsight is just that

Surely is not coincidence that those with the most passion today like Siposs are the guys who have not had our game plan drilled into them hardcore yet, so feel the freedom to still play openly. Everyone else seems to have had the game plan drilled into them so hard that they seem to be simply going...

If these guys were not following the coaches orders they would have been dropped already, so clearly they are. False logic... in spite of their poor performances they may still be playing better than the other options on the list. I just wanna know why this is entirely the playing lists fault and R...

If these guys were not following the coaches orders they would have been dropped already, so clearly they are.

Alves, Thomas, Blight, Watson all got sacked on the spur of the moment, why is it suddenly the players fault and on this occasion not the coaches?

I don't see any difference between 04-05 and 09-10 results apart from some Wanganeen ass magic and a skinhead cry baby named Bazza. Is this a serious post..? 04-05 we were no where near the level we were in 09-10. Brisbane and port had our measure easily. Pretty sure we got smashed in the first fin...

I don't see any difference between 04-05 and 09-10 results apart from some Wanganeen ass magic and a skinhead cry baby named Bazza.

And apart from one Wanganeen kick out of his ass in 2004 we would have made the GF then also

I may be wrong about this, but seems to me it is time to go back to basics. Time to free the arms, cut the shackles and run again. GT may not have been a rocket scientist but he had the right idea. Free flowing positive football, and record scores rather then trying to restrict our opposition to sco...

Adam Goodes punches people in the nuts, Chris Judd eye gouges people......no penalty.

Joey shoulders a man who kept coming back on to the ground after injury and surprise surprise suspension.

Do we have any chosen ones in our team? Or are all St Kilda players guilty by association?

Pretty Boy Lloyd, so one eyed he thinks the Bombers won last years GF, that he never missed a shot at goal, and even had the most handballs in the history of the game too.
Way worse then One Eyed Christian for sure.

Not a bad idea, but a better solution would be to throw the world at Jack, even though he is contracted. When Gehrig was with us teams could not triple team Roo cause G would cut them up instead if they did. Wonder how many teams would triple team Roo if Jack was down there at FF waiting for the bal...