All three are/were Key forwards... big guys who mark a ball for a living! He was pick one, that's a fact, we chose him as the best talent in Australia... he is a key forward with supposed elite talent? He is not athletically gifted, not physically gifted so he should be a gifted player... what is el...

Also seen him drop marks, in the infra club, in the VFL and in the AFL

Yes, he clunks the odd one, so did Kosi... he also double grabs the majority

That is a serious cop out

If our club mentions it, and we are that fragile... we are more f***ed than I thought!

So we've highlighted a couple of grabs in a season.... as a key forward. Yesterday he dropped 3 sodas that a local footballer would take! Hands of a god?! FFS Stewart Loewe and Nick Riewoldt - great hands - great forwards - from a young age - BTW Stewie a b&f by 22 Nick a b&f by 20 Paddy is ...

They are far better

Can we add 2/3 goals to Tony Locketts average or Stephen Milnes

Tony would have 2000 goals and Milney 1000

Wow.

Can I add some runs onto my career batting average, to say I am better than I am??

So in the heat of the battle, when after the footy... players are distracted and think about a media blow up? Truth is, footy is instinctual and events outside of what's required have little effect, unless it's that personal there is a preoccupation. Do you honestly think most of the players have 2 ...

How would having our own vfl team be any different? Can you explain that please??

McKlunkin should actually clunk a mark?!

I find it a bizarre concept moment to say that
"If he had cleaner hands he'd have played well"

He didn't/doesn't have clean hands, that's the issue?! Key forward generally do have good hands!

If we a lauding a one goal game

1/ it's patronising
2/ we really are in fairy land and dreaming
3/ we are clutching at straws

Up until 3 qtr time he was poor. He received ironic cheers in the third when he took a mark on the wing. Had a strong last q when the game was done.

Isn't it interesting that we are saying If he didn't drop marks, he'd have had a good game? Isn't that the point? Bit like saying, if he didn't get out he'd have scored more runs? He did drop marks and up until the last quarter was very average again. He was good in the last q. He ended up with ok n...

It's not as simple as that. All defender sets up exactly where you want it kicked... if you chose that option and turn it over, you will concede a goal Going laterally is designed to shift the defender to open up gaps in the defence and draw the press The hope is to get through and out the back What...

Newnes
Gilbert
Roberton
Carlisle
Membrey

Ok
Stevens, Seb, Joey,

Leadership - what the hell has that got to do with the performance? If another player was Captain WTF difference would that have made?? When you don't have Bruce or Riewoldt You lose a contest down the line after a gut busting lead McCartin Jogs around 65 metres (behind his opponent) from the footy ...

How was his defensive game

What? The 'Jerryn Geary' who was Runner Up in the best and fairest last year and top 6 in four of the last five years? Pretty sure he deserved the job? It is funny Mike Brearly averaged 18 in test cricket Luke averages 18 disposals Both are statistically below par... Brearly did have Botham to win h...

Haha, experts at our club have never made a mistake?!... seriously, StK history is littered with blunders, but it remains to be seen if Paddy is one? Luke got dropped, any comments on that one. Paddy must be good because he got a game, surely, if that's the case and we judge on weekly selections Luk...

If Luke Captains StK it will be a Mike Brearly situation

Well I stood a metre away from him the other week in the VFL and he is carrying weight. Around the gut, on the triceps, he has no muscle definition to speak of... I watched him closely in pre season running trials... he finished only in front of Pierce and Longer (last) ... his running is horrible. ...

I thought StoneCold was ignoring me?

Stevie Baker, Stevie Milne, Jason Blake, Luke Ball, Nick Dal Santo, Clint Jones, Sean Dempster

Did any of those have smooth exits from StK... from what I understand, all wanted to go on...

Not saying they should've but using the argument about being loyal to players is rubbish, it's a business

Whitfield... GWS need to be weakened, North and us to take some of their skill Let North overpay for Kelly We are not quite there, but need to hold the nucleus of the team but make some bold decisions Lose Roo, Joey, Armo (my fav) or Dunstan, Gilbo, Longer or Hickey, and a few other avg players. Inc...

not sure how there could be no changes after last week?

Should be at least 3

Nick and Joey would piss themselves laughing at this...

No one is suggesting he is fat... but he is clearly not fit enough and/or presented well enough. He is in an elite, professional sporting environment and is not as fit as he needs to be, its mind boggling?! This can be seen in his physique, in his running ability at training, in his game play... he ...