B.M wrote: ↑Fri 10 May 2024 4:41pm No one

Because he was taking the big cheque

Ha Ha

We had the Superannuation brigade lining up - Now with the talent coming through we may stand a chance.

Would you be ok for a permanent name change? No. We are the St Kilda Football Club... But I don't have the issue with the name change for the SDNR. I wonder if other clubs are having these discussions? Imagine the chardonnay and cheese platter brigade at Naarm. What outrage. LOL - Maybe years ago w...

I totally agree with you saintkid about Billings what did our recruiters see in Billings only holding his spot at Melb until Spargo and Melksham return. No where near good enough to tie Petracca or Bontempelli boot laces who we missed out on. BOOM BOOM Billings was rated top 3 by all. And then WE d...

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 10 May 2024 12:15pm Why is he compared to two of the greatest players in this generation?

Why isn’t he just compared to other HFs

Ie, compare him to ours?!

As well as considering the lack of advancement that Bont and Trac would most likely have made at St Kilda

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 10 May 2024 9:34am Sainter Dad

LDU

Is fair square in our sights

Okay - but Brad will now be on a lot lower $$$ than it took to get him over - which Super Star was Banging Down the door to be a RW&B whilst Brad was being paid the big bucks??

Bump - Calling it tonight

Avid
Bernard

If I don't hear - I can't put you in.

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 09 May 2024 7:31pm Because it takes a % of your cap

Which you want for power players

Sorry - which Power Players are banging down the door to come to us????

..... Crickets .....

1. Would you like to go back to the days when Muir and Winmar were vilified and abused for the colour of their skin? 2. If we accept indigenous players in our team, should we not respect their culture? 3. If you acknowledge Indigenous Round and the contribution that indigenous players have made in ...

108 Sinclair
101 Wilson
42 Hill
31 Wanganeen-Milera
29 Hayes
28 Windhager
5 Howard
5 Marshall
4 Battle
3 Owens
1 Steele
1 Wood

Therefore:
5 Sinclair
4 Wilson
3 Hill
2 Wanganeen-Milera
1 Hayes

Waiting on:
- Avid
- Bernard Shakey
- thefatdork

Dis Believer wrote: ↑Wed 08 May 2024 1:26pm Is there an update as to what the outcome is to this event?

Will be based on The Hawthorn game - St Kilda's score

Surprise Sandi bombing it long into F50 and wasting dominant period. North out marked them on most occasions, the Sandi forwards are all one out none of them work to block for a team mate. Its something that we are really poor at at AFL in our F50, so shouldn't expect any difference here. Put a lin...

I reckon he would have gotten the shots that Wilson and Hastie got. Would he have converted as many as they did? Some days he would. It's a good question. Are those goals 'team goals' that Higgins just gets on the end of and gets his name against, or are they genuinely created by Higgins? Are there...

Weren't we having the same discussion about Pou 12 months ago??? Before Ross started 'teaching' him a new role?? https://www.saintsational.net/viewtopic.php?t=106013 Now some people want Pou gone Weren't we having the same discussion about Owens 12 months ago??? Before Ross started 'teaching' him a ...

Tim Membrey also gets most shots that are expected to be kicked. It would be good to compare his stats. He has endured some wayward periods in his career, but also some "sharpshooter" periods. This year Members is travelling at 72% 13 from 18 - Highest goal tally and most accurate for any...

Bump

Higgins and King are 50/50 bets even when 30m out directly in front The only players I have a lot of faith with when going for set shots are Sharman, Butler, Wood, Cordy, and Sinclair I cover my eyes when King, Owens, and Higgins are lining up This season King is 54% - 7 from 13 that scored Higgins...

Some good performances, but pretty uninspiring all round. Barely kicked 100 against North, only outscored them by a goal in the second half. Darcy Wilson very good. Dougal had a good first half then turned back into Dougal in the second. King is constantly in a wrestle. Maybe you are just too hard ...

therabbitinthehat wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2024 5:02pm

Dis Believer wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2024 9:20am

therabbitinthehat wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2024 12:44am I don't think I own anything but runners, so not in for this one

Surely you own a pair of thongs? It would be un-Australian not to!!

Do Crocs count?

They do in our world!

As the Dullbogs game was a weird time for some I made an executive decision to leave the tix and do the Freo Game. The St Kilda Football Club is delighted to host you at The Lounge for our Round 10 Sir Doug Nicholls match against Fremantle in the Horizon Room. Soak in the Saints game day in style wi...

There's no issue here. The AFL suspends anyone if their tackle causes a concussion. Don't they? https://www.afl.com.au/news/735442/match-review-tiger-docker-fined-ralphsmith-higgins-tackle-explained Jack Higgins has been subbed out of the game with concussion following this tackle by Hugo Ralphsmit...

LOL at the persecution complex 😂😂😂 We have no voice because we are perennial cellar dwellers and other than make up the numbers for broadcasting rights are only of importance to our fans. We are irrelevant, not because of the AFL, we are irrelevant because we are mediocre and other than a few spike...

St Kilda should play a game and take tribunal decisions to their logical conclusion. Do not tackle at all. Not once. Or go the other way and concuss every Norf player in the first 15 minutes /s And - with the level of our tackle efficiency in the past couple of games - how would anyone know??? Do y...

spert wrote: ↑Wed 01 May 2024 11:59am Maybe a quantum computer might be the only answer.

Not entering the fight on any other topic - but to point out that Maybe a Quantum Computer is the only answer to determining a path through the clusterfook that is the MRO and Tribunal

No - we are the AFL's example puppet