glad you are the other one who thinks it was a great decision (at the time) to pick him up and to keep him (at the time of it) - not just another one of these bandwagoner's who attempt to state that they thought it was a great idea to begin to come across as a typical saintsationalist know it all H...

glad you are the other one who thinks it was a great decision (at the time) to pick him up and to keep him (at the time of it) - not just another one of these bandwagoner's who attempt to state that they thought it was a great idea to begin to come across as a typical saintsationalist know it all H...

Here's a question for those wanting Max straight in. Apart from stopping the full forward from kicking goals,what else does Max offer? I love Max's stopping abilitities,but right now as I see it,I'd have Zac in the side over Max. Dawson is better in the air,a better decision maker,and better by foo...

How about having a Saintsational "Hall of Infamy" with the top ten suspended contributors in order. As to SP2008's comments on page one Dawson just seems to be improving each game and looks to have his spot locked in at the moment and SP was not the only one to think Gardi was worth the p...

Yes, but being a Brisbane-ite, hopefully you will actually see his worth live this week. He has been a gun down back and deserves his spot every week. Let's have a beer and discuss his success after he rips another scalp this week. but i don't want to have a beer with you Are you old enough to drin...

Your criticism of Zac is based on how many games you have seen him live? Cabbage!!! FFS give it up before you completely embarrass yourself with your complete lack of knowledge of the game What do you mean before he embarrasses himself. The kid is clueless. But what do you expect from someone who h...

Iceman234 wrote:Yes, but being a Brisbane-ite, hopefully you will actually see his worth live this week.

He has been a gun down back and deserves his spot every week.

Let's have a beer and discuss his success after he rips another scalp this week.

but i don't want to have a beer with you

if zac performed the exact same way and we were 3-6, 4-5 etc most on here would label him as the first out saying he is crapola blah blah blah he isnt doing much however we are winning Hysterically PMSL. You have not yet seen one game live you cabbage.... He has played the way he has played and we ...

Iceman234 wrote:LOL just looked it up and it was your mate Plugger66 who actually started the thread to ask where you were....

hey plugger let's go for a beer tomorrow after work

what do you think?

if zac performed the exact same way and we were 3-6, 4-5 etc most on here would label him as the first out saying he is crapola blah blah blah he isnt doing much however we are winning Hysterically PMSL. You have not yet seen one game live you cabbage.... He has played the way he has played and we ...

if zac performed the exact same way and we were 3-6, 4-5 etc most on here would label him as the first out saying he is crapola blah blah blah he isnt doing much however we are winning Hysterically PMSL. You have not yet seen one game live you cabbage.... He has played the way he has played and we ...

if zac performed the exact same way and we were 3-6, 4-5 etc most on here would label him as the first out saying he is crapola blah blah blah he isnt doing much however we are winning Hysterically PMSL. You have not yet seen one game live you cabbage.... He has played the way he has played and we ...

...Max Hudghton just missed AA selection last year. He's bled St.Kilda throughout his career. It's one thing to have an opinion that he's past his use by date, which I strongly disagree with, but can understand your POV as he's more than likely in his last year, but you should have your nuts roaste...

Nobody is simply making up the numbers like in previous years. All 22 are contributing. its a bit of a cliche to say that all 22 are contributing fact is our stars are playing super footy and a few young one have come good that doesnt make 22 leigh matthews said one that there are 6 average players...

...Max Hudghton just missed AA selection last year. He's bled St.Kilda throughout his career. It's one thing to have an opinion that he's past his use by date, which I strongly disagree with, but can understand your POV as he's more than likely in his last year, but you should have your nuts roaste...

he wouldnt be doing too badly, actually i would see him doing a similar job apart from the odd spoil and the bump on hall against the swans

out entire defence has done very well, all 18 and have assisted each other and zac is benefitting greatly

for mine dempster is an automatic in, he can play both tall and small and has a booming kick maximus is obviously in goose to play in the forward line so the three outs of our best 22 would be gwilt, raph, somebody else as im not sure i currently don't see how we can play both max and zac in our bac...

fingers wrote:Leigh Tudor missed again - 2 weeks in a row.

We might be missing him in the box. 2 weeks out. 2 ordinary weeks. Coincidence?

Do you think we are missing him in the box?

no as if it was the case he would be head coach

Zac was fantastic... SP2008, you picked me up way back at round one, when I thought that Zac's youthful enthusiasm and eagerness to prove everyone wrong, would not benefit him against the gun forwards. Surely now, you can admit that he is making a steady improvement as he grows in confidence? grown...

we won everywhere around the ground except in front of goals. THATS what cost us the game. Didn't we win? aye wrong choice of words. basically im rapt we won, and i thought as a team we played well. brisbane threw everything they had against us, including the kitchen sink. i noticed every time we t...

i too can use little emoticion things...but why bother...im not a douche dont be so confident about that bradshaw went back due to our forward being potent...no other choice..and hey he stiched up roey in a marking contest or two but we won't mention that will we?? so he kicked two goals from a HBF...

Zac played his best game for us today. He was excellent. Put another 20-50 games into him and I think we will all very very happy. I take it when you say "we" you mean supporters who actually see game live and dont depend on what a TV screen shows them? :D :wink: i would love to be you an...

im not criticising the selection committee... yes you are im criticising formuities opinions as after 9-0 they belive zac is doing a good job much like jon browns role in the 01-03 flags sides... as it could have been fulfilled by someone in a wheelchair...same result...flag after flag... you mean ...

i was there in row 43e dj12 and i have watched 47 games this year... why else would i give an opinion without watching the game??? oh wait 48 games i have watched the saints play max cannot back soon enough mabye you should actually get to a game before making you pissweak arguments.... but then ag...

zacariah is still average.... still not decent enough to shove him at fb without anyone giving him a good old hand He beat Bradshaw one-out twice that I noticed Isnt that what a good defence does though? Gets back to help out? Tries to avoid having a one-out contest? no what we have found with zac ...