Think what you like bungiton. Nobody called you anything (unlike the personal insults I have had to endure because i had the temerity to ask a cuple of simple questions of the FFS). :shock: :shock: The insults that you have aimed at those supporting SFF and Greg Westaway are far more heinous thatn ...

Dan, how dare you? Surely you realise that the morally upstanding Heath Black has spoken on this. Worst thing you could ever do to come to the Saints apparently. The culture at West Coast and Freo must be so much better. You don't get away with partner swapping, drug taking or brawling in bars or ra...

Hail SKFF. United we stand. Burke's standing up for the club, that's good enough for me. It's high time this mob were run out of town. I feel a linchin' comin' on - yeee-haaaa!! St.Kilda, clap, clap, clap, St.Kilda, clap, clap, clap, St.Kilda, clap, clap, clap, St.Kilda, clap, clap, clap. Errr... s...

I can't really see WCE getting a player, as mostly only a WA boy would want to go and there aren't that many good 'uns at Vic clubs available AFAIA. I think they'll have to settle for two top ten picks. Which means that whichever club Judd picks as his preferred will have to come up with a 2nd top t...

While Butterss said last week that Levin and Gdanski would have to live with their consciences..... "Live with their consciences"!!!!!!!!!!!! This guy is unbelievable. Living with your conscience is objecting to going to war for your country when called up because you're a pacifist. Or al...

ausfatcat wrote:why does he look like he's constipated in all of those photo's

Wouldn't you feel like you'd been stuffed full of sh1t if you had to play for Carlscum?

Hell, I must be going crackers if I'm agreeing with you on something woooooooooo.

fonz_#15 wrote:see my views in the other thread.

Snap!

G'night all. Will be dreaming of Juddy in the red, white and black.....

Perhaps I might even change my vote to RB if he can get CJ to the Saints!!! He is the footy messiah after all.

I hear you Fonz. I don't really think that we'll seriously go for Judd either. On the other hand.......? - re salary: wherever he goes he will continue to get huge marketing dollars thrown at him outside his club contract so may not need to have too high a contract. - on order to play at his club of...

Montagna and R Clarke to Richmond for pick 2. Picks 2 and 9 to WCE for Judd. Heavily backended 5 year contract for Judd.

Boom. Done.

Teflon wrote:bad time to buy a house....hang tough juddy till you can......afford it...

I've got a few pals around St Kilda his age who could offer him a flatshare. Hell, if he comes to the Saints he can stay at my joint and I'll go kip at the Gatwick

god some people make me laugh :roll: we have waited for montagna to peak, underachieving for his first couple of seasons imo, he hits his straps in the last two seasons and people suggest we trade him, as well as another player AND a f**king draft pick as well. get a grip people, aint gonna happen ...

Seems to me that Judd will get to pick which club he'll end up at - i.e. present the WEagles with his preferred option. Then the Weagles might say, ok "Judd-preferred club", give us 2 picks + a player. "Judd-preferred club" would then need to get another 1st rounder - they'd be i...

Would make sense. Then the pies would get, say, Adelaide's pick 8 - half way to the Judd deal as far as they are concerned.

I am another person who finds himself right royally amazed to be in full agreement with you RF. You have made sense throughout the whole of this and reading your stuff is a real pleasure these days. As for insults, I think you need to grow a bit of a thicker hide jb - paradoxical when you so hastily...

Here we go again.....

Yes, it would be performance enhancing if used just before taking the field of play. Why do you think one of its street names is "speed"?

And that is why it is on WADA's list of prohibited substances. Check out their website if you don't believe me.

I like it for us, but reckon that Walker would command more than pick 9 (was pick 2 in 2003 draft).

Here's a list of who has gone at pick 9 in the last 10 years....... 1997 Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide) 1998 Mark McVeigh (Essendon) 1999 Cadyn Beetham (St Kilda) 2000 Kayne Pettifer (Richmond) 2001 Luke Molan (Melbourne) 2002 Hamish McIntosh (Kangaroos) 2003 David Trotter (Kangaroos) 2004 Jordan Russe...

plugger66 wrote:I would think for pick 9 we would get either Judd or Kerr ao both if we also gave them our second round. Lets get really tough at least Judd for pick 9.

Do you think if we give them our 3rd rounder they might throw in Benny too?

Good grief. I hardly see Westaway marketing himself as the great individual saviour. Yes, the ticket is using Nathan Burke's personage to try to...... what..... WIN! Is that so bad? I don't think so. No doubt most on here are praying that this new lot can bring us success, but most from what I can s...

Seem to remember he got into some trouble on King St not so long ago mind

Never trade a first round pick unless the deal is heavily in your favour. Exactly. Why would the other team involved do that trade then? You gotta give up something to get something in return. Pick 9 could be an absolute superstar, but it could also produce an absolute dud who doesn't play a game. ...

Having said already that I don't think we could afford to fit Judd under our cap, well, perhaps with some creativity we could........ - we may have some dough left over from this year's retirements/resignings - G-train, Thommo retiring vs new deals for Roo, Dal, Kosi, Sam. (+200k) - don't have to pa...

Given that the Weagles will want two top ten picks for Judd, our pick 9 becomes a valuable commodity. In a year when the draft is not said to be a particularly strong one mightn't we consider trading our first round round draft pick to a club looking to get Judd. (I don't believe that we can get Jud...

Whilst I would love to get Judd, the reality is that we would have to give up one of our premium players (Roo, Kosi, Dal, Lenny) just to fit him in under the salary cap. And those players are IMO untouchable.