Bartel is on the Giants Board Correct - as per the original post - a club staffer doing the commentary for the local (home) team - amateur hour Yeah. When commentating you really have to show no bias. Unprofessional if you can’t. I blame the commentator for that, not the broadcast team though. But ...

In addition to the unbalanced and unfair free kick count, Eleni paid 3 very doubtful marks to GWS which were never held for sufficient time. My absolute nightmare game would be one in which Eleni and Nick Foot are umpiring together against us. Plus that "mark"of the round given to that li...

In addition to the unbalanced and unfair free kick count, Eleni paid 3 very doubtful marks to GWS which were never held for sufficient time. My absolute nightmare game would be one in which Eleni and Nick Foot are umpiring together against us. Plus that "mark"of the round given to that li...

Membrey looked like the only guy in the back half of the field who wanted the ball when he took the big chest mark at CHB late in the last - he ran off the top of square and you could see no one was going to impact his run, jump mark- made everyone else look like a witches hat - it was great to watch

mcadam05 wrote: ↑Mon 22 Mar 2021 2:44pm Bartel is on the Giants Board

Correct - as per the original post - a club staffer doing the commentary for the local (home) team - amateur hour

Bartels comment at 3/4 time was stunning. When asked what he thought would happen in the last 1/4 he commented. "I would like the Giants to win but I think St.Kilda will win". Well that's really quite insightful and relevant to the game - what he really wanted to say was ' I really need t...

If The AFL are going to encourage teams like GWS to be in the competition they've got to at least support some kind of professional telecast of their matches. That was a Club Football TV Broadcast AT BEST I was at the ground and then watched when I got home - they captured none of the atmosphere at ...

i thought he was about to explode as player going into last season - he has showed signs but last night was very underwhelming i thought

i would say he needs to lift

Cant say I love it -I would have preferred to rip the band aid off and be decisive - Steele captain for mine

Have to feel for the bloke - I don't know how long a fibula puts you out for, but he may be another early retirement ? He's had a bad run with this legs the last few seasons

I hope his operation goes well for him

Geary needs to stand down Riewoldt who holds the record for longest serving captain and was without question or need for debate best 22 in his final year - stood down and let someone else take the reigns whilst he played on I would be shocked if Geary was made captain this year - and that is not in ...

Thanks 8blogs for the update - nothing to get excited about just yet by the sounds of it

Any updates on him from the training track this year ? - any training watchers seen him ?

Any training watchers got any info on how this guy's looking ? Size, speed etc I think right now he is the most important bloke on the list in terms of needing to come good. Why I think this is Ben King - I know plenty reckon its a pipe dream - But I'm from the camp the thinks we will throw the kitc...

Good Call Tony - thanks for staying involved with your posting

Butler, Jake play

Geary bytel out

Sinclair no 1 on emergency list for me

Wilkie - Howard - Paton Coffield - Carlisle - Long Hill - Crouch - Billings Gresham - Membrey - Higgins Marshall - King - Butler Ryder - Steele - Z.Jones Ross - Clark - Hannebery - Battle E: Geary - Sinclair - Lonie - Dunstan - Webster Yep - I like your team - no real weak links - would hope that te...

As with all these decisions, we have to rely on the coaches and list managers to decide what is best for the club, and as much as we may have liked what few games we saw Ed Phillips play this year, they are in a far better position to make these judgments than armchair critics. Yes he could be rook...

I dont like posting negatively about saints players - but I would be moving Mckenenzie on and just paying his wage - we will need the $$ in two years to keep the kids together

Rhys didn’t look any better last night than when he played for us. Exactly the same flaws. Will always be a player with unrealised potential. I thought he did some good things - but he will be immortalized for his dropped mark that resulted in a brilliant goal from Dusty in the dying minutes of the...

The need is for a strong bodied tall defender that can compete physically one on one with the key forwards like Lynch and Hawkins...needs to fit the right age demographic so McStay or Payne from Brisbane would be a good fit! I like the idea of turning Schache into a defender - may be dreaming that ...

Probably expect a player to nominate us this week. :lol: :roll: If you actually have any information, post it. Don’t just keep using vague weasel-words to try make yourself look like an ITK. How many trolling bans do you need before you learn your lesson? How about I do what I want and post how I w...

Sinclair also in best 22 for me I would be looking for a Carlisle replacement- I would have no idea if Clavarino is on track to do that soon but the club should know - if not find someone else ASAP Apparently Bell tracking well for the Ryder replacement but he only has 16 months probably to be ready...

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/afl/tigers-defend-lynch-as-mro-verdict-on-knee-drop-looms-20201010-p563uv.html Cotchin’s head high tackle and sling to the ground ‘just a part of the game”. Michael Christian you are a joke. What a f#cken disgrace - but a hip and shoulder is not part and parcel of the g...

The Cotchin incident was far worse - after the whistle stopped play and 100% had the potential to cause injury - by the tribunals own reasoning that action must get a 1 week Suspension