We definitely shouldn’t be entertaining bringing Max king back - get him on the operating table now - if he needs it - and ready to start preseason
Guys like coffield and Hayes to be brought back only when 100% ready
Play a few more kids

Good on the Tiges. Made all the right decisions and cleaned up with three flags. Meanwhile we dicked around at Seaford with half-arsed draft picks and clueless nice guy coaches. Those were not half arse draft picks. Petracca & Bontempelli together would have won this game. When you have low dra...

One of my major criticisms of Byrnes - cannot get the ball through the big sticks - has 2.4 this year which sounds better than my perception of it Yestarday a really good example - the game was over - we had won, there was a crowd of about 9000 in the house - mostly pretty quiet - and he misses from...

Lynch has history - accidently on purpose is how I saw it

Looks like he’s safe then! But the way the team is playing right now ( including saints players at Sandy) and with so many young promising guys on the list- there are going to be some tough decisions to be made at seasons end you would think There’s going to have to be a couple of good players let g...

He was pretty good pretty often last year - he’s just very good this year -I hope his injury isn’t too bad

- Campbell very good in the air and covers the ground.

Was that a typo or is cambell back out there and moving freely ?

I’m pretty sure that all supporters will at the end of the day want the same thing as I do re Hunter Clark - we want him to be a champion of the game and help the saints become the dominant team of the competition for years to come And as much as I’m loving the talk and the images about guys like Ma...

Good thread - if it keeps the cr#p off the training reports thread and leaves the training reports thread to training reports

Has King?? Who’s more effective already King or Schache ? Let’s not be silly I don’t think ‘has to be more effective than King’ would have been the criteria Maybe Ben king might come close to fulfilling that - maybe not - but he wasn’t being given away for a draft pick we wouldn’t need to use

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 18 Dec 2022 10:14am I have no idea why we didn’t chase Schache or Weideman

It was obvious to me

Same - and I posted it a number of times - would have got Schache for a throw away draft pick - I don't know why they didn't get him ?!?

Brisbane & Richmond both twice in the second half of the season !

Must have run out of ideas ?

Sharman, Battle and Membrey as the mobile taller forward options - teach those up the field to deliver the ball to those presenting options not just bomb it in

This might actually be a beneficial excercise to change habits going forward when Max returns

What's the story with Adams ?
Anyone know if he's a chance to show something - even at VFL level - next year ?

That sounds pretty underwhelming - I had taken it that more players had been there

Does anyone know if his training with the saints has involved any training yet ?

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 18 Nov 2022 4:38pm I’d pick him and RCD

And 4 DPs

same

Spoke to my Carlton supporter relative who has contacts at the club. Carlton wanted to use Stocker in midfield but he didn't have the tank so they played him at half back. Couldn't keep up during preseason practice matches when played on ball. Fatigued too quickly. They lost patience with him becau...

Banger9798 wrote: ↑Fri 18 Nov 2022 1:58pm Any chance we take RCD as well?

I hope we take them both

Some ump - Pell ? Has been named

For those who don’t remember- no one was more invested than him on the day- playing for his brother who was in prison- HEART ON SLEEVE

Never have I seen a better mark than Goddards in the GF in the goal square in the GF in the last - right in front of me !!! At that point I thought we had it - BRING HIM DOWN

The kid could play- wiil be 50 possessions a week

Is there a link to the photos ? Go into the club’s saints.com site or go into the Saints App and click on Photo or Gallery. The photos were posted on 21 October. Coffield looks the most defined & chiseled I’ve seen. Even tho he had improved his body def last pre-season he still had more work to...

Is there a link to the photos ?