Given the imminent retirement of Gardiner and the fact that we need to chase a tall forward, why does everyone leave St Kilda out of calculations for Mitch Clarke?

He's having a can't of a year. Book him in for an operation now. He's a liability. This coming from a bloke who looks like a fat Muslim cab driver whose last attempt at sport was the Year 8 egg & spoon race? Try playing sport before you criticise,you knobhead !:-P Yep, everyone who criticizes h...

So Riewoldt playing for Sandy will magically play him into form? And meanwhile the young, up and coming players miss out on his inspiration (which we can't expect to see or appreciate from the sidelines/TV screens) while he misses goals for Sandy? Doesn't make sense to me. He's worth more than anot...

If t lynch doesnt offer a bit more than either of those muppets then I will go he for tiggy. Reputations/record only get you so far, we are 12/13 games in and both have been woeful, consistently. Surely it's time to give lynch and or walsh a go. Surely? On what basis do gram and Gilbert continue to...

Who is actually our skills coach? Is this up to the line coaches, or what?

The fact is that a captain shouldn't be immune from being dropped if his form is poor. The team has a vice captain and if a player - captain or not - isn't performing, then they need to be dropped. Aside from that, dropping Rooey might send a message to many other players. There are way too many pl...

The fact is that a captain shouldn't be immune from being dropped if his form is poor. The team has a vice captain and if a player - captain or not - isn't performing, then they need to be dropped. Aside from that, dropping Rooey might send a message to many other players. There are way too many pl...

Na guys. I made this comment last season or so, and everyone called me out on it. Oh, he's taken us to grand finals in 2 years. Just remember that. He's a top coach. Never made a mistake. Ever.

The fact is that a captain shouldn't be immune from being dropped if his form is poor. The team has a vice captain and if a player - captain or not - isn't performing, then they need to be dropped. Aside from that, dropping Rooey might send a message to many other players. There are way too many pla...

...it's players diving forward and sucking the umpire into paying in the back. eg Swan about 3 minutes into the 2nd quarter. It's starting to take our game one step closer to the diving jessies in soccer. Thought this was something that umpires were meant to be cracking down on. The umpiring tonigh...

Thought Dempster was good today, I wouldn't be stamping his papers anytime soon. Are you serious... Watch the match again... Especially the last quarter... EVERY single possession in the last resulted in a Hawk score... Probably the worst individual peformance of the year... Joke of a player, joke ...

Listening to Matthew Knights on the ABC he says St Kilda doesn't have the offensive game to take on the press that teams now employ, a style of game that the Saints started. Knights also said players like Baker, Dumpster ,Steven and Mini have NO offensive side and aren't going to give much trying t...

Listening to Matthew Knights on the ABC he says St Kilda doesn't have the offensive game to take on the press that teams now employ, a style of game that the Saints started. Knights also said players like Baker, Dumpster ,Steven and Mini have NO offensive side and aren't going to give much trying t...

I am going to make a hard call and say we need to let this kid go. If he can't get us first use of the ball and I think from memory is last in the competition for ruckman in hitouts then whats the point keeping him? Hale had 12 hitouts in what 1 and a bit quarters, yet McEvoy can only get 20 agains...

Although it pains me to say this there is one man out there who has made a habit over the last 10 years or so of turning sub par players into super men. In 2004 until 2009 I heard many say that Malthouse should be sacked. They went through the exact thing we are going through now and they didn't au...

Although it pains me to say this there is one man out there who has made a habit over the last 10 years or so of turning sub par players into super men. In 2004 until 2009 I heard many say that Malthouse should be sacked. They went through the exact thing we are going through now and they didn't au...

Glad to see he's getting a game. Capable of being a 10 year player and would have been taken much higher in the draft if it wasn't for injuries. Found a bargain priced gem here.

Players woul wont be prominent in our challenge for next year, like Dempster, and Gwilt, and Raph, maybe Kosi, and even Stve Milne need to be pensioned off into the reserves. Dunno if Gwilt and Milne are two to get rid of. We'd be far worse than we are this year without Milne, and Gwilt is never go...

undecided wrote:everyone who cant kick

We can't trade the whole team.

Agreed, been our most consistent for the season and easily our best today.

Thought Dempster was good today, I wouldn't be stamping his papers anytime soon.

Watcing the pre-game today, I saw a bit of a replay of RL's "On the Couch" interview, and he mentioned he doesn't coach skill errors. I'm not sure if thats actually normal for an AFL coach, or who its up to within the St Kilda coaching staff to do this. But it seems like we are making alot...

There were so many clangers tonight by so many players, why highlight just the one?! Yep, thats the typical response to a raph critique. Look ,he makes continual critical turnovers with the odd ridiculous free given away. I mean, he has no place in the future side. He has had EIGHT years to get it ...

Schneider can keep them company as well. Simpkin has to come in. Lynch has to come in Siposs would be worth a try Why? Because he can ACTUALLY KICK STRAIGHT !!!!!!!! Ray needs to come back. Time for Ross to make a big statement. (Just as long as it doesn't involve a Gamble). Ridiculous post- unders...

Schnieder missed chances but still played well. Dal had a good secon dhalf