Gwilt having a horrendous game. Surely there's nothing he offers anymore.

Yes me too. Anyone have one?

I liked Lee and Billings. Dunnel I wasn't sure about, will have to watch the replay

Billings is one of the only players we have who can actually hit a target by foot. He delivered it nicely into the F50 a few times.

Apart from the fact that we're dropping like flies, we're doing okay.

I want to re-visit this thread in a couple of years. Reckon he showed a fair bit this week and still getting to know new game plan and teammates. This will be really interesting- both short term in if he's selected for this Saturday and in the mid-to-long term where he is in around 3-5 years (altho...

We were favourites for the 2010 premiereship at the beginning of the year.

If you wanna blame anyone for anything, blame the entire teams effort in the first half. Yeah, Ray should have kicked that, but Brisbane shouldn't have been so far in front in the first place.

At least it wasn't a GF this time.

We're gonna be up and down this season, everyone accepts that. If losing a game by 3 points to a side who were hungry and rarely fumbled in slippery conditions is "down" - I'll take it.

We can and will improve.

There was one far worse against Jack Steven, and the umpires said play on there. Who knows what the rules are to this game anymore. If I had to explain them to someone I couldn't.

You make a valid point but if this game wasn't played in NZ I would argue that Milera's form in the VFL has been better than Savage's 1 game. Hence why I think its gifted. Maybe so but you feel if Savage can't perform in this game in particular, he'd have a heap of work to do in order to get back. ...

Me also. Can't seem to find one but if anyone has one I would hugely appreciate it!

Suited to the sub role = someone who is amazing for 1 quarter and horrible for the rest of the game, all the time, every time. And he can choose which quarter to be amazing in. That's sounding pretty specific and doesn't really make sense at all. Ergo, no one is suited to the role, it's just a posit...

I wish he stopped getting the sarcastic cheers from the crowd. He was handy to have today, crashing packs, etc. He did more than Kosi in his later years.

Good marks from the big guys. Maister, Stanley and Hickey all playing well.

Kicking not all that great though. I'm worried about Delaney.

It's true he didn't get much of it this game, but I whenever he did he did something good, and did some creative things at some stages to keep the ball in our posession. Some poor kicking in some parts of the game, but over the next few weeks I think he'll turn out ok.

Turned the ball over more than anyone else I noticed - that's the unfortunate thing about being a defender. Did okay in later parts of the game. But this is Melbourne, and they did have many forwards out anyway. So, we'll have to wait and see if we can ultimately sit back and watch him play comforta...

Signed up for my first ever membership this year (first of many to come also). My girlfriend is also planning to even though we are interstate and sometimes even overseas. I really wanted to support the Saints this year, so hopefully there are also others who take pride in either signing up or stick...

Cats out on the full not paid. And I sware that goal hit the post.

The age-old question.

13,000 views. This will go viral.

We've been able to match it with top four sides this year, albeit never for four quarters. I've never thought our ladder position told the story and I'm liking the look of that 22.

My personal favourite was his final goal of the 2010 qualifying final against the Cats.

Watch all three here:

Listen to the roar!

Thank you Milney for the many years of excitement I've been privileged enough to witness. You've such a unique player, and one that has kicked some of the best goals I've ever seen in Australian Rules Football.