I can't believe this. People are really suggesting trading Riewoldt to GWS? No matter what justifications anyone can provide, it's short sightedness and nothing more. We are playing badly, Riewoldt himself hasn't been in blistering form this season - people have short memories. Also Aside from the ...

bj is probably still the best player in the afl and clowns talk about trading him for unknown talent...ffs...glad you guys aren't running the club.... :roll: :roll: :roll: what a wank of a thread... :twisted: You wouldn't trade BJ for about five potentially great players? no...of course not....it w...

I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years Not hard to believe when you consider how other clubs won there flags with the help of money , for eg Collingwood and Carlton have always been involved with the criminal element and were awash with dirty money ...

bj is probably still the best player in the afl and clowns talk about trading him for unknown talent...ffs...glad you guys aren't running the club.... :roll: :roll: :roll: what a wank of a thread... :twisted: You wouldn't trade BJ for about five potentially great players? no...of course not....it w...

bj is probably still the best player in the afl and clowns talk about trading him for unknown talent...ffs...glad you guys aren't running the club.... :roll: :roll: :roll: what a wank of a thread... :twisted: You wouldn't trade BJ for about five potentially great players? no...of course not....it w...

stinger wrote:bj is probably still the best player in the afl and clowns talk about trading him for unknown talent...ffs...glad you guys aren't running the club....



what a wank of a thread...

You wouldn't trade BJ for about five potentially great players?

What percentage of top 5 players turn out to be greats? There are a lot of misses, some turn out to be adequate players. Goddard IMO is one of the top 10 players in the competition. I would also say that the probability of a top 5 draft pick being one of the top 10 players in 5 years is limited at ...

IF is a very small word with a very BIG meaning; IF BJ wants to go to GWS we would be better off dealing with them this year whilst he is still in contract. That way we miught be able to extract a very high 1st rounder AND one or two of their 17yo priority picks. If we wait until next year when he ...

Probably from that opposition fan website that has a dedicated thread to our forum, if you can believe it. Someone put a link on here recently, pages of it, all about what we say. That's right, all about what us fans think, not even about St Kilda as a club....a thread purely about Saintsational. T...

IF is a very small word with a very BIG meaning; IF BJ wants to go to GWS we would be better off dealing with them this year whilst he is still in contract. That way we miught be able to extract a very high 1st rounder AND one or two of their 17yo priority picks. If we wait until next year when he ...

I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years What about two teams then? Oh yeah forgot about Footscray. At least they don't have the record for most spoons. F*** Off troll. Troll? I'm just depressed how unsuccessful our club has been. Oh, get a life, you ...

I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years What about two teams then? Oh yeah forgot about Footscray. At least they don't have the record for most spoons. F*** Off troll. Troll? I'm just depressed how unsuccessful our club has been. Oh, get a life, you ...

saintspremiers wrote:

Tiprat44 wrote:

Dr Spaceman wrote:

Tiprat44 wrote:I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years

What about two teams then?

Oh yeah forgot about Footscray. At least they don't have the record for most spoons.

F*** Off troll.

Troll? I'm just depressed how unsuccessful our club has been.

Armoooo wrote:How about something like this.

Gilbert to GWS
Taylor Walker to st kilda
Top 15 pick to Adelaide

I consider this to be a win for everyone.

I would also target McIntosh from north Melbourne.

That way we could have McEvoy, walker and Roo all rotate, through the forward line.

+1000000000

Can someone please clarify? Is Goddard contracted to the end of 2012? If he is how would GWS get him next year? And if they could, what compensation would we receive? Goddard is contracted until end of 2012. GWS can get 1 uncontracted player from each club over a two year period (2011 & 2012) B...

Dr Spaceman wrote:

Tiprat44 wrote:I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years

What about two teams then?

Oh yeah forgot about Footscray. At least they don't have the record for most spoons.

I can't believe it's even possible a team has only won one premiership in over 100 years

Gary Lyon completely destroys his hypothesis by suggesting McEvoy be bracketed with Goddard in a deal with GWS - does he really seriously want to deprive St Kilda's of their developing No.1 ruckman, God knows the Saints ruck stocks are not over-abundant! On the other hand, I have long considered th...

gringo wrote:My left fields are Brogan from Port, Bate from the Dees, Miles Sewell fro Nth Balarat who is always in the best players in the vfl and has apparently gone to another level.

Please tell me this is a joke

I agree that midfielders are currently more of an urgent need than forwards. The one that springs to mind that is out of favour over here in Adelaide is Bernie Vince - club best and fairest so he's got runs on the board but seems a bit out of Craig's popular books at present. I think we have enough...

plugger66 wrote:

Tiprat44 wrote:Hasn't Walsh also stated that he really wants to play up forward?

If he has he is a fool. I would think he just wants a game. Pretty sure he wouldnt care where.

I think he meant for Sandringham....

Hasn't Walsh also stated that he really wants to play up forward?

The cost may have to involve a trade with someone on the list that has cache. I can't see anyone that other teams want that we could give up without being significantly weakened. Non negotiables with cache Roo , Lenny, BJ , Dal, Monty, Fish , Jimmy, Armo, Steven, Ben Middle tier - probably not enou...

Barry Hall (to go with Fev as twin spearheads?) :wink: :lol: :lol: WELL if someone can contemplate getting Fevola why not Hall? :roll: :roll: I've got a great idea. Let's bring Gehrig out of retirement! :roll: But why stop there? Plugger has now made his peace with the Saints. Just whack a Guerra h...

thejiggingsaint wrote:Barry Hall (to go with Fev as twin spearheads?) WELL if someone can contemplate getting Fevola why not Hall?

I've got a great idea. Let's bring Gehrig out of retirement!