I still don't see the issue either way. I don't watch them train anyway. I don't rate the Docklands at all. We should have taken the cash and ran to the Gold Coast when it was on offer! We'd probably be in the top 4 for the next decade if we did! Oh and hasn't it being a roaring success for Brisban...

He could actually play on the wing IMO

I've had a gutful of the constant attacks on Mark Fine. I know the man (he is a friend of a good friend) and he is a ferociously passionate Saints man. He attends most games and stands (no cushy free media seats in the Medallion Club, which he could avail himself of) barracking intensely. Firstly, h...

What I will do in future is not share information with our loyal supporters who can't handle the truth. The truth being that the club made a mistake 2 years ago, and it needs to be rectified before further damage is done. It is no shame making a mistake when you are having a go. The shame is acknow...

What I will do in future is not share information with our loyal supporters who can't handle the truth. The truth being that the club made a mistake 2 years ago, and it needs to be rectified before further damage is done. It is no shame making a mistake when you are having a go. The shame is acknow...

Grrrrr wrote:Welcome to Seaford Tom Boyd

How do you draw that conclusion?

Actually, the article is fair comment and I am starting to lean to the view that Watter's position is untenable.

The moment the players organised dwarfs at Mad Monday Watters position was untenable. For those smart enough to realize who the dwarfs were representative of shows how the coach is viewed by the playing group. We need to bite the bullet now and change things before 2014 becomes a waste of time. Ver...

I think that people forget a factor in Pelchen's motivation to come to StK was largely motivated by a request from Allan Jeans, "go and get my beloved Saints a Premiership" (or words to that effect). You could say he's on a mission for Yabbie. You could also do a lot worse than think, &quo...

If GWS keep Pick 1 and take Boyd with it, then they do not need Paton. It would be unfair of them to draft Boyd and keep Paton, it could potential stuff either player's development as one of them would have reduced opportunity. So if they keep Pick 1, Paton should be very gettable and we should go f...

There have been a lot of rumours circulating here and elsewhere about all these different fanciful trades in order to secure pick 1 from GWS. Ideas such as giving up picks 3, 17, Fisher. IMO we should not make any attempt to trade for Boyd for the following reasons: 1. Pick 3, notwithstanding a com...

There have been a lot of rumours circulating here and elsewhere about all these different fanciful trades in order to secure pick 1 from GWS. Ideas such as giving up picks 3, 17, Fisher. IMO we should not make any attempt to trade for Boyd for the following reasons: 1. Pick 3, notwithstanding a com...

Animal Enclosure wrote:

Moorabbin Man wrote:So does this mean we have traded McEvoy, pick 21 & our third round pick for Savage & Picks 17 & 18?

McEvoy & #23 for Savage, #18 & #19

(after compo picks- Collingwood Pick #11 for Thomas & Hawthorn #19 for Buddy (now St Kilda's)

What a cracking deal.

I reckon they need to keep Armo, unless it was a trade for pick 1.

So does this mean we have traded McEvoy, pick 21 & our third round pick for Savage & Picks 17 & 18?

For all of you going mad over the prospect of Mark Williams. Whilst I'm not suggesting Watters should be sacked (I don't have a view on the matter), in a hypothetical sense if we did need a new coach he would be an excellent choice. There is nothing better than a Premiership Coach in his second stint.

gringo wrote:SEN said Armo to Brissy for Longer?

That would be reckless insanity!

Well done to Pelchen & Co what a brilliant deal, McEvoy for Savage and pick 17. I'd also like thank Big Mac for his contribution to the club, best of luck for the future big fella. How about this for a potential trade that would do more than add cream on top. Pick 3, Fisher & Gilbert to GWS ...

Shrewd deal if true

Lay off the Viagra

Love it or hate it, I reckon Watters is gone. I do not believe Plympton was just joking, what on earth for? What was the punch line? So perhaps the topic of discussion should be, who replaces him?

So this is the guy who wanted to sell Stkilda to Carlton - Andrew Plympton back to destroy the club thru the media. Anybody with one ounce of brains given the current media circus would know Channel 7 just leading story because of this idiot. Should forthwith be banned from anything associated with...

Skildir wrote:http://www.smh.com.au/afl/afl-news/sain ... 2uzgq.html

Why on earth would Plympton joke about that? Something smells.

gringo wrote:Classy response from the little fella.

Hate crime!

dragit wrote:He should speak to Sydney...

Mumford + Everitt + their first pick for pick 1.

Don't joke about it, until yesterday their play for Buddy and a decade long deal would have sounded like science fiction.