Sheahan has always been a moron, nothing new here.

Not sure if we are going to enjoy this Friday though.

No, too old for us now.

Spinner wrote:What could have been if there was at minimum an uncorrupted process for selecting a coach.

Yep. We will never know.

What a c**k up that whole period of time was.

plugger66 wrote:Only Goldsack. The others cant get a game because of form, Goldsack is just because of the depth of the pies.

This.

Ellis is useless. When he was drafted, Collingwood were laughed at because they picked up Pendlebury at 5. Many thought Ellis was the better player. Leave this dud alone.

Can they cap football dept spending........? Pleaseeeeeeeee. Why? ARGH! Loser mentality strikes again. "Poor me, I'm on social security. It's not my fault, it's the fault of society!" There are so few competitive advantages in football, I would hate to think that we wouldn't be able to ha...

Very sad. RIP.

St Nick wrote:Go ahead and ask me any obsure question about St Kilda from say the year 1971 until current day. More than likely I will be able to answer it

Google.com.

But seriously, I think St Nick is telling the truth.

Collingwood were rebuilding throughout that period - not sure I clasify that as tanking. Do you think we tanked to pick up Roo and Kosi? Early draft picks help, but they are not the solution. A winning culture has a massive impact on a team. For instance, the Hawks are playing with a belief in thei...

SainterK wrote:He actually wasn't injured, had a clean bill of health from 2007 didn't he?

From my understanding OP takes a while to overcome, and his apparent lack of confidence in his recovery probably didn't help.

Tanking games should not be an option - EVER! Need to promote a winning culture, and "tanking" will not provide that. That is CRAP. Collingfilth TANKED in 2005 which netted them Dale Thomas and Scott Pendlebury. Even Collingfilth supporters admit that. you ought to know Do you think I'm a...

Collingwood were rebuilding throughout that period - not sure I clasify that as tanking. Do you think we tanked to pick up Roo and Kosi? Early draft picks help, but they are not the solution. A winning culture has a massive impact on a team. For instance, the Hawks are playing with a belief in their...

Tanking games should not be an option - EVER! Need to promote a winning culture, and "tanking" will not provide that.

Agree. Just a plodder. I rate him just above Mini. Solid player, tries hard. Doesn't win a lot of the ball. He isn't just a plodder. He is a essential ingredient to Collingwood's success. Unfortunately, because he was injured throughout the last few years, RL had dim view of what he could provide f...

Seriously, can we ignore this mental case?

If u consider Reid in their bottom 6 then u have NFI. Not sure about this concept of bottom 6 anymore as teams have more role players especially now with the sub. In fact having read the rest of the OP, u really do have NFI. ll: While this is probably a bit harsh, Reid is a very good player, and de...

I think what Dawson said is a bit funny. Walls is a knob.

Though Dawson should probably just shutup.

So, Collingwood plays at the MCG, and it is their home. So what? We can move from Etihad if we wanted to (down the track).

It is an embarrassment that this has come up as an issue for the football public to know. Agreed. Portrays us as a bunch of mentally weak sooks. This. Again...I've said this a couple of times..."loser mentality". The strong teams don't have it. That said, I think it's a stretch to base an...

But hey dont the facts in the way when trying to discuss this as you know 90% of people on here will just believe anything you say. . It astounds me. Seems like a lot of people are wearing tin foil hats. We need to rise above this sooky la la loser mentality, and just focus on improving ourselves. ...

Despite the request, it has to be neither.

Hawkins is an out and out dud. Soft as they come, really lacks any presence for a guy his size.

Fevola isn't worth the hassle, and is over 30. He won't be in our long term plans.

In reality, clubs should stop getting into so much debt and having to rely on Collingwood games for their financial windfall. Clubs can't ask for one thing on one hand, but then complain about it on the other. While it may not seem fair, unfortunately it's the economic reality of this competition. B...

Anyone that says yes to this should have their head read. This bloke has an average season and people don't support him, how pathetic.

Oh come on, what a cop out. What an absolute hypothetical. Did we play any interstate games in the finals? I hate the "what ifs", it feels like loser mentality to me.

Do people seriously think it makes any difference if Collingwood plays 4, instead of 5 or even 6 games interstate? Seriously? The Pies will win anywhere, it really doesn't make a difference. We need to stop worrying about opposition sides, and just worry about ourselves. There are too many sides ie....