So nobody agrees that Walsh should come in? WTF is wrong with you guys?

Then Westaway needs to take immediate action on the coaching situation. As the president of the club he needs to finally stand up and show the league that we will not stand for this blatant incompetence within our club. Lyon's contract should immediately be terminated and Grant Thomas re-instated. I...

I've found the link Helen has in question and I 100% agree with her. I'm sorry helen, here is the link and evidence you required. Sack Kosi now... based on this I'm surprised Kosi is still with us. I can't believe I missed this :( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ Seriously have a good har...

Dan Warna wrote:Please find my formal apology to Helen here, especially the kosi one

Very funny.

gringo wrote:maybe you should have done more to keep Matty Knights?

I have barracked for St Kilda since 1971 and was a member for 22 consecutive years. That ended though after Lyon's first year as coach.

saintspremiers wrote:Lynch is not good enough.

A bit player only.

Completely agree with the above.

Maybe we should have done more to keep Luke Ball?

Geary reminds me of ex Swans Skipper Paul Kelly.

it's not unlinke at the dome, "come on saints fans, make some noise for your team, BOUNCE THE BALL UMPIRE - LET'S GO" Wish they'd get rid of that. Shocking. We dont need feigned excitement. The culture of AFL football has the game generating excitement. Next we will have advertisements fr...

anyone else anoyed by that horn going off everytime the gold coast scores I find it very annoying, and the music as well. Just makes me think of American basketball, I was expecting everytime time it went into our forward fifty to hear "defence defence defence" coiming from the crowd Stop...

I hope he gets off because he is the most important player in our side. Apart from taking the best forward every week, he also plays 100% of game time allowing our mids to rest on the interchange bench.

Sainternist wrote:Why do people respond to these moronic troll threads?

...oops! I should be asking myself the same question

So you reckon its a moronic troll thread?? I dare you to go and have a close look at what Kosi did in the dieing stages of the drawn Grand Final.

Kosi tried to be a hero and cost us a premiership.

Con Gorozidis wrote:Assuming we turn over 6 players at years end.
Who do people think will go?

Gardi (retire)
Bakes (retire)
Heyne (in trouble)
McQualter (i have no idea what is contract says but could be in trouble)

Kosi (retire)

If Geelong accepted our third pick and West Coast accepted our fourth pick, then yes.

I have a feeling though that Geelong would want a pick somewhere between 15 - 20 and West Coast would want somewhere between 35 - 40.

Dr Spaceman wrote:Not happy with the plethora of anti Kosi threads over the years, some posters can't help coming onto this generally positive thread and having a crack at the guy

If the shoe fits?

Dr Spaceman wrote the following dribble..... Don't worry, your forward line won't have Riewoldt this week, or any other week for that matter! Do you have proof that I follow Essendon? Or are you just going by what Geoff (Joffaboy) keeps going on about? Actually Geoff has been very quiet lately. Are...

Dr Spaceman wrote the following dribble..... Don't worry, your forward line won't have Riewoldt this week, or any other week for that matter! Do you have proof that I follow Essendon? Or are you just going by what Geoff (Joffaboy) keeps going on about? Actually Geoff has been very quiet lately. Are ...

Do people agree that our unpredictable forward line this weekend should be more potent than with Roo around?. Only complete morons or supporters of other clubs. EXCUSE ME perfectionist!! Who the hell are you?? I happen to agree that our forward line will function infinitely better without Riewoldt....

Maybe rest Kosi this week and bring Gardiner in. Let Gardiner do the bulk of the ruck work (say 70%), and McEvoy can do the other 30% and spend a lot of time on the bench. Does that sound better?? What did Essendon pay for Mark Williams again? Hey ausfatcat, your stupid comment above is something J...

Maybe rest Kosi this week and bring Gardiner in. Let Gardiner do the bulk of the ruck work (say 70%), and McEvoy can do the other 30% and spend a lot of time on the bench.

Does that sound better??

hungry for a premiership wrote:I feel that for once, the planets may be aligning in our favour. We could pull the biggest premiership bunny out of a hat ever this year.

It's time to roll out 2 of my favourite lines.
1. Delusions of Granduer
2. Rose-Coloured-Glasses

I don't think so. I would drop him and play Stanley or if he is injured then Archer.

Thoughts??

joffaboy wrote:NO.

Too hard to win from the bottom eight.

If we recruit well and have a quiet preseason in the bloody papers ,we may have one last shot before we reboot.

We need luck which we have missed out on, but it could come together in 2012.

I don't think we will make the top 8 in 2012 Geoff.

What should Ross Lyon do with this list? Does he make the hard decisions and totally re-build? Or does he just make small tweaks to the list and go again in 2012? Discuss!!!!! My option would be to bring back Grant Thomas as the Coaches Director to cull the list over a 4 year period and to just kee...