Good to see that Newnes has been rewarded for his ONE tackle last week.

We lost two forwards and have brought in two midfielders. I feel a 10 goal thumping coming our way, but one thing’s for sure, come Monday, Richo will find lots of positives and will be pleased with the effort.

Like others, I’m a bit stunned that Jack Newnes has once again retained his spot in the side. Not quite sure what his perceived value is amongst the coaching group, or whether it’s one coach in particular (AR) who cannot see his obvious flaws. It must be quite disheartening for guys like Sinclair an...

Truth is. We mere supporters will never know if Richo is the main problem at the moment relating to the Saints poor form. Its probably a combination of alot of things so lets be truthful and honest about it. I still always reckon the majority of the blame has to lie with the players this year. Thei...

Truth is. We mere supporters will never know if Richo is the main problem at the moment relating to the Saints poor form. Its probably a combination of alot of things so lets be truthful and honest about it. I still always reckon the majority of the blame has to lie with the players this year. Thei...

This is bad, really bad, and we’ve got another two years of this to look forward to. Thank you Matt Finnis.

Great post. Recruiting has almost become the single most important part of football these days, and I question our recruitment department. It's fair to say that there are serious question marks over Tony Elshaug's performance over the last few years, and the fact that Wayne Hughes is our "Pro S...

Wow! Scathing, but absolutely on the money. A more spineless and insipid management team I have not seen. They have filled the football department with plodders, so it’s no wonder we are so easy to play against. If this club had any ambition they would do what Freo did to us, and go out and poach a ...

Lucky we signed Ricoh for an extra 2 years.


This re-build has been a failure. Carlton started long way behind us and have already gone past us.

Memo to the St Kilda Board. please do not be in any hurry to re-sign Richo.
Let's wait until the end of the season and then assess.
We have become a one trick pony. Other clubs have worked us out, and we do not have a Plan B.

What an embarrassment. No system, just play on at all costs.

Structure in the first quarter was disgraceful. Richo has well and truly been out coached. Where is plan B?

What the hell is Roberton doing? He's butchered every single kick, and his decision making is horrible.

Another wasted year.

With the passing of time, the disappointment of BJ leaving our club has subsided to the point that today, I wish Brendon nothing but the best for the remainder of his footballing career. What a wonderful player he was (and is), and what a truly remarkable career he has had. One played at a consisten...

O.k. Let's get real here. We were poor on Saturday and the previous Saturday. Adelaide was poor against North and Melbourne in fact. Sydney was poor in the first few rounds. Hawthorn were poor against us and the GC. You know if anyone thought we were certainties for the Grand Final before the seaso...

I think folks need to give Paddy a break. The delivery to him yesterday was appalling. In fact the delivery into our forward line overall was shocking. So many times our midfield just kicked long bombs iinto our forwards, that they never stood a chance. So many times Paddy would lead out for the bal...

I must admit I am a little underwhelmed with our lack of involvement so far in the trade period. Steele will give us depth in the midfield but not the explosive outside run we so desperately need. As far as Kobi Stevens is concerned, I'm not sure why we would be chasing him. Can't see him as being i...

Seems like things have gone very quiet in this thread of late. All of our ITK's have gone to ground, and a number of posters both on here and big footy are 'taking breaks' from posting. Most recently, BS who is copping a bit of heat (allegedly). I just hope that our club is working on something big,...

magnifisaint wrote:Holmes is clueless. Why play him. How do you expect an American who hasn't been brought up on the game to play it. Longer would have been so much better.

+1

Does a bear sh!t in the woods?

Our midfield has been smashed.

We are shallow down back and there really is not that much there to bring in. Delaney is having an average few weeks in the magoos, as is Goddard truth be told. You have to ask the question though, would it have been any worse if one had of come up to do a job? This game was three steps backwards f...

The Blues have only just started their rebuild are way ahead of us. This is embarrassing

This game was lost at the selection table. No backline. Roberton straight back in aft a long injury lay off WTF

I have been sitting tight for the last couple of years acknowledging that we are going through a rebuild. I have come to grips with the fact that this will take time. Last year provided glimpses of the potential and I was encouraged by the effort and pressure displayed during games. It resulted in o...

Any chance we might actually get involved in trade period? It started with a bang with three players committing to us, and everyone talking about how we have become a 'destination' club, but one week in and still nothing. I hope we aren't investing all our efforts in the Carlsisle trade and we run o...

Thanks Jaxons.

Thanks Jaxons.