Saintsational Fan Forum

Scollop

The problem with Ross Lyon is that he doesn't listen to his own rhetoric. He wants to micro manage and he wants control over areas that aren't his domain E.g. player development Took him a while to listen to what people were telling him about Phillipou Let's hope he listens to the advice from DC, L...

Scollop

Interesting NAS not in the votes Voted 2nd bog by both coaches Steele 15 tackles Enormous David King on the broadcast said at the end of the match that Windhager won us the game. I suppose people here on Saintsational agreed with that Luke Hodge or Jobe Watson often do the same thing as David King....

Scollop

What did Higgins do to warrant votes? He's winning contested footy and that is important when you look at the way we kick goals and our messy entries inside 50. He is winning loose ground ball gets (which are highly rated by coaches) He kicked the goal that got us going in the last quarter, plus he...

Scollop

Could have been: ROSS 5 wood 4 nas 3 Duggan 2 Yeo 1. Dow SIMPKIN 5 Wilkie 4. Nas 3. Yeo 2. Wood 1. Ryan Then top 2 from each coach are saints. I could see the oppo coach rating Wilkie game as he thwarted so many of their attacks Or... Saints Coach Wilkie 5 Nas 4 Yeo 3 Wood 2 Dow 1 Eagles Coach Wood...

Scollop

Vortex is sometimes stubborn. He makes early BIG calls and sometimes he changes his mind Like the time he said he'd put $10K on the bar :oops: :lol: :lol: He made a call on Hannebery from the moment the trade was made and stuck to his guns saying it was a wise move...right up until the time of Hanna...

Scollop

"abacus"... that's good Stick to the humour and try not to post when numbers are involved Oh...and combinations need justification Problem is there is no way to prove your "justification", it is just your view, others may think otherwise, and it doesn't really matter anyway. Bit...

Scollop

The problem with Ross Lyon is that he doesn't listen to his own rhetoric. He wants to micro manage and he wants control over areas that aren't his domain E.g. player development Took him a while to listen to what people were telling him about Phillipou Let's hope he listens to the advice from DC, L...

Scollop

This isn't going to be popular but I wonder if trading Max King to bring in midfield recruits is the answer and put the development into Caminiti as out number one banana. Sometimes you have to be ruthless, Clarko did it when he first got to Hawthorn and it looks like Mitchell is doing it again at ...

Scollop

The best player from his era, ahead of Riewoldt, Dal, Goddard. We was our Michael Voss. I disagree that Hayes was the 'best player'. If I had to rate best player, I think early years it was Banger, later it was mainly Roo, other years Dal or BJ and some years it was Lenny. He was easily the best le...

Scollop

As illustrated by Super Duper Have a look at Duggan's stats versus Wilkie and Sinclair. Are you really saying that Duggan deserves votes ahead of Wilkie and Sinclair? That's the only way those 'illustrated' numbers work Also...dingbat...antogoniser...what you're trying to argue is that the WCE Eagl...

Scollop

As illustrated by Super Duper Have a look at Duggan's stats versus Wilkie and Sinclair. Are you really saying that Duggan deserves votes ahead of Wilkie and Sinclair? That's the only way those 'illustrated' numbers work Also...dingbat...antogoniser...what you're trying to argue is that the WCE Eagl...

Scollop

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Tue 04 Jun 2024 10:17am Chill out, man! I didn't mention Duggan at all!
Surprised he got votes to be honest...cheap kicks from full back.

Thank you

Cool man

Scollop

Clearly Lyon and Simpson no nothing about football Cheers mate Superduper says ' top 2 from each coach are saints. I could see the oppo coach rating Wilkie game ' ...thats the only part that makes sense. He even called him SIMPKIN Easy to critique when you isolate stuff...not so easy when you try a...

Scollop

The problem with Ross Lyon is that he doesn't listen to his own rhetoric. He wants to micro manage and he wants control over areas that aren't his domain E.g. player development Took him a while to listen to what people were telling him about Phillipou Let's hope he listens to the advice from DC, L...

Scollop

Aside from the two late goals just before half time from the Eagles, the first half was pretty even. The Eagles kicked late goals in both the first and second quarters to take a small lead into the breaks. From half time, the Saints were clearly the better team. Stands to reason, then that both coa...

Scollop

As illustrated by Super Duper Have a look at Duggan's stats versus Wilkie and Sinclair. Are you really saying that Duggan deserves votes ahead of Wilkie and Sinclair? That's the only way those 'illustrated' numbers work Also...dingbat...antogoniser...what you're trying to argue is that the WCE Eagl...

Scollop

Could have been: ROSS 5 wood 4 nas 3 Duggan 2 Yeo 1. Dow SIMPKIN 5 Wilkie 4. Nas 3. Yeo 2. Wood 1. Ryan Then top 2 from each coach are saints. I could see the oppo coach rating Wilkie game as he thwarted so many of their attacks Yes. 'could' have been. Possible. Yes. But highly unlikely...because a...

Scollop

Stian wrote: ↑Thu 30 May 2024 7:50pm You're only supposed .... to blow ... the bl**dy doors off.

Scollop

The problem with Ross Lyon is that he doesn't listen to his own rhetoric. He wants to micro manage and he wants control over areas that aren't his domain E.g. player development Took him a while to listen to what people were telling him about Phillipou Let's hope he listens to the advice from DC, Le...

Scollop

We're normally chasing to catch up on the scoreboard, so haven't had a chance to close out anything. We haven't been comfortably in front except maybe the North match and also in the game against Collingwood we got 5 goals up early in the last. We have the talent to play an exciting brand. Just need...

Scollop

If we get close to finals ..or if we make finals, that gives us a better chance of landing LDU

Why would he come to a club just for money? He'll get decent money if he stays at North or if he goes to another bottom 6 club...but does he want to be in rebuild mode for the next 3 years?

Scollop

Saints Coach/winning team 5 Wood 4 Nasiah 3 Wilkie 2 Yeo (the best player from the opposition) 1 Dow WCE coach/losing team 5 Yeo (his own player was arguably best o g. Highest disposals. 14 contested. 8 clearances. He wants to keep Yeo or ...pump up his value if there's any offer that's too good to ...

Scollop

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Mon 03 Jun 2024 9:30pm Wasn't it going around that BA was annoyingly juvenile and the group were not unhappy to see him off. Had to tidy up his act at Carlton?

They paid him an adult wage. That helps

Scollop

FoxFooty show 'On the Coach' just highlighted the top 4 rated wingers in the game...this year

Big Surprises

#1. Massimo D'Ambrosio

No. 2 obvious Errol Gulden

No 3 ..Sam Clohesy

And Blake Acres at number 4

Scollop

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 03 Jun 2024 7:01pm Because they were playing poorly

So was Billings (hardly ever dropped). So was Gresham (was he ever dropped?)

What about Weller and Newnes. I don't think they were ever dropped either...and they had poor games

Search found 10179 matches

Re: Still effing pathetic

Re: Votes v Eagles

Re: Votes v Eagles

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: ..at the risk of positivity ..

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Still effing pathetic

Re: ..at the risk of positivity ..

Re: Pendelbury on Hayes

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Still effing pathetic

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Channel 7 News

Re: Still effing pathetic

Re: ..at the risk of positivity ..

Re: ..at the risk of positivity ..

Re: Coaches votes Round 12 vs WCE

Re: Crab watch

Re: Crab watch

Re: Crab watch