Worth keeping I reckon perfect player as a sub less game time able to make an impact

I say do the deal with Gresh if it ends up pick 33 so be it.
If we want Shiel then maybe 33 or lower.
Why would we manipulate the deal to give an apposition team pick 13 ?
If the AFL allowed it I bet they wouldn’t if it was the other way around.

Maybe the injury to Callum Mills has sweetened the deal

It’s voted on by the coaches so it’s probably more authentic than is suggested.
Apparently Kingsley was crap at the saints must have fast tracked improvement

You would think if he came to us must be considered better than Caminiti and Sharman

Is there anything on the Membrey statement if it was on here I must have missed it

Someone in the media suggested he try to get to bulldogs or west coast as the coaches were on shaky ground but it might end up same as Richmond , maybe he’s best coaching his own side at a lower level then go for a top job

Last year it was joked on here that Windhager’s effort on Neale cost him the Brownlow .

What a fall from grace for Sheil.
He’s going to be better than whoever we would choose at pick 50.
Free agency opens before trade period doesn’t it ? so the “gentleman’s agreement” only comes into effect after that?
Would we last year taken pick 7 and Bowes?

I agree with that , I thought that Rayner going into the middle for a short burst and bash & crash seemed to put Carlton off and Lions got going ala Owens & Windy could do.

The story behind the songs being played at the Gabba is that the players have all nominated a song that gets played after that person kicks a goal.
More tolerable than Metricon where they play loud annoying trumpets

I m not sure we had the right environment to get him on the straight and narrow had we drafted him he may well not still be around by now.. Apparantly he was fairly serious about us last year if he came over would have been great.

I’d be happy with the same as this year. Competitive in all games I think the only flogging was the Adelaide game. Recruit a couple more goood players I’d like to see us easily beat the teams we should NM & W C this year) Don’t think we know who our best 23 are yet. yes some others will improve ...

9 goals 17 behinds 10 goals 16 wins it. Don’t know if Ross can fix that we aren’t as accurate as I’d like

I think the other disappointing thing is that he was I think pick 18 and Dunstan 17 both no longer at the club these are the ones we need to get at least decent guys who play 150 games+

So on afl.com they say he’s unlikely to end up at Richmond that leaves Ess and Carlton.After watching the game last night with Martin & McKay to come back in ,does he fit in? I read somewhere their salary cap is tight so that’s another question. Really only leaves Essendon or us, apparently ther...

I think Dow might be a starter at the saints though

Are we still looking at Dow? He’s not going to be a starting 22 unless injuries to others, be interesting if he resigns at blues

I just looked up GWS paid pick 44 for Toby Bedford seems a good player be nice if we could snare some trades like that

Interestingly last night Ross was on Fox 360 and said if they had more time to deal with Membrey out / hindsight they should have brought Dougal back in and put Cordy forward

Funny I remember Kingsley copping alot of flak / criticism when he was an assistant at the saints on here

Funny I remember Kingsley copping alot of flak / criticism when he was an assistant at the saints.

Meant to be Richo not Richie

One other thing that annoys me is the expert commentators never call it out or don’t explain how they come at that decision they just rattle of their self gratifying dribble ..Although I think Richie does quietly and get talked over

Maynard is lucky he plays for Collingwood he has the best chance of getting off, the media love him same as Selwood .
Imagine if it was a Saint hardnut who done it ( actually do we have a hardnut?).
Steven Baker 6 weeks