What are people's thoughts on how best to use the following players... Goddard Gilbert Johnson Ray What positions do they play? Goddard should have been traded to GWS for National Draft picks 5, 10 & 15. Gilbert should have been traded for a pick in the top 20. Johnson not sure. Ray not sure.

joffaboy wrote:

Dont feed mentally ill trolls

Hey Geoff, please read my signature!!!!!

We need to bottom out if we want to win a premiership. If you're happy with middle of the ladder finishes and treading water then keep trading like we are. :roll: :roll: In Pelchan we don't trust!! You are still a f***wit trouble making troll You just don't like it when people tell it how it is. We...

We need to bottom out if we want to win a premiership. If you're happy with middle of the ladder finishes and treading water then keep trading like we are. :roll: :roll: In Pelchan we don't trust!! You are still a f***wit trouble making troll You just don't like it when people tell it how it is. We...

We need to bottom out if we want to win a premiership. If you're happy with middle of the ladder finishes and treading water then keep trading like we are.

In Pelchan we don't trust!!

The inevitable slide will happen this year. At least the draft will only be partly compromised with compensation picks. Lets stay in the bottom 4 for 4 years and rebuild properly for our next assault on the flag. Thoughts? (keep it civil). I thought you had been Dempstered? I know you are a recogni...

I thought we finished 7th this year... In all seriousness, I think we will probably be sliders next year, but not bottom 4. You can assume Gold Coast and GWS will be bottom 2, then you still have Port and Brisbane who will remain cellar-dwellers....so I think bottom four is very unlikely with the t...

The inevitable slide will happen this year. At least the draft will only be partly compromised with compensation picks. Lets stay in the bottom 4 for 4 years and rebuild properly for our next assault on the flag.

Thoughts?
(keep it civil).

thejiggingsaint wrote:SO! Joffaboy, using the logic of your argument can we expect to see you and Barks nominating Butterss and Co for election to the board?

Typical of Geoff to just run away. Where the hell are you Joffagirl??

SEN are wrong on both fronts!!!!!!

I still believe that Gary Ayres will be announced coach of the Saints. If he is not I will gladly ban myself and NeXus _Nick will head back to Bigfooty fo good as NeXus _Helen.

The only thing our current board has done is spend more money which has caused our club to lose nearly $2million this season. :roll: :twisted: Well if that upsets you that much you should post this on your team's board :idea: I have barracked for St Kilda since I cried at losing the 1971 Grand Fina...

The only thing our current board has done is spend more money which has caused our club to lose nearly $2million this season. :roll: :twisted: Well if that upsets you that much you should post this on your team's board :idea: I have barracked for St Kilda since I cried at losing the 1971 Grand Fina...

Why cant the stars take a pay cut? Players like Reiwodlt Goddard & Montagna had pretty ordinary years yet they will still receive rudiculous payments next year whilst their mates are being forced out to other clubs. Time for these so called stars to get together and collectively take pay cuts f...

The only thing our current board has done is spend more money which has caused our club to lose nearly $2million this season. :roll: :twisted: Well if that upsets you that much you should post this on your team's board :idea: I have barracked for St Kilda since I cried at losing the 1971 Grand Fina...

Why cant the stars take a pay cut? Players like Reiwodlt Goddard & Montagna had pretty ordinary years yet they will still receive rudiculous payments next year whilst their mates are being forced out to other clubs. Time for these so called stars to get together and collectively take pay cuts f...

sent us from a position of Financial security to one of 1.5 mill loss during one of our most successful periods on field. Not bad. :roll: how did our on field first 8 weeks affect their targeted revenue for membership , reserved seats, merchandise and sponsorship? So how did the board cause that? E...

Ross who? wrote:Terry Wallet said on Trade Week Radio today, that when he interviewed all the assistatnt coaches this year, as part of job for AFL, that of Saints 3 candidates, 2 were in his top 2 most impressive.

And what would Wallet know!!!

The only thing our current board has done is spend more money which has caused our club to lose nearly $2million this season. :roll: :twisted: Well if that upsets you that much you should post this on your team's board :idea: I have barracked for St Kilda since I cried at losing the 1971 Grand Fina...

The only thing our current board has done is spend more money which has caused our club to lose nearly $2million this season.

Christiansen, Menzel, Duncan... They've drafted really well, and coached 'em up as well. Plenty more than F/S at work. I agree, they have drafted very well considering they have been in the top 4 for a long time. When you add good drafting to the father son rule loop hole you end up with a Super Te...

I don't believe in "full rebuilds" or rebuilds perse. A team refreshes its list. It's more or less a stocktake. Geelong do this every year. Geelong got away with murder (father son rule). The AFL has fixed this up now with the bidding process. Collingwood too did very well out of the old ...

GoTheTorp wrote:No r in debacle you flog

I know, I just fixed it up.

You got this from one deal? One that has other supporters reacting rather enviously? Yes I do. I'm not saying the deal isn't any good. What I am saying is that it's obvious from this deal that Pelchen and Nettlefold have decided to go the mini-build rather than the full on rebuild. IMHFO, this will...

MadSaintFan wrote:Hazell also says St Kilda's Raph Clarke, who is out of contract, and North's Ben Warren, who has a year to run on his, would be open to offers from other clubs.

haha see ya raphster

I like Raph, I admit he does make mistakes but who doesn't?