Selecting Robert Eddie for both GF's in 2010 only to delist him at theme en of the seasom

No better time to pick the kid than this week. Would love for him to hold down Fishers spot for the remainder of the season and allow us to release Fish to play a more attacking role in the oppositions 3rd forward.

I don't understand all the love for Lee. The guy is undersized for KPD and too light. On top of that he's been a defender for a month. He's learning his craft as much as Goodard is. At least Goddard has the size and weight to play on the Hawks FWD's if required. IMO Lee's best shot at a long term po...

No for me. We have Delaney atm doing a good job stopping the opposition key fwd. We have Goddard in the 2's waiting for an opportunity and if you believe some on here Tom Lee as a tall 3rd backman. Carlisle would cost te earth to get and right now our immediate focus should be on line breaking midfi...

In : Roo, Goddard, Lonie, Geary,
Out : Hickey, Fisher, Shenton.

Delaney gets another week to recover from his hip

Longer plays. Out : Templeton, Fisher, Hickey, Shenton In : Lonie, Goddard, Roo, Ray I would be interested in your reasons why Longer is ahead of Hickey baring injury of course. Rightly or wrong I think Longer is seen as the first choice Ruck, therefore he plays and Hickey makes way for Roo as I th...

Longer plays.
Out : Templeton, Fisher, Hickey, Shenton
In : Lonie, Goddard, Roo, Ray

Fisher out for a month according to the papers. Seems like the right time to give Goddard an extended run and see how he performs.

Has butchered the footy a lot recently. Great servant, ripper of a bloke but we must look to elsewhere in the medium term of we are going to move forward. Is there really any hurry in getting rid of the older guys. it will happen soon anyway. He is still our best option down back in that type of ro...

Has butchered the footy a lot recently. Great servant, ripper of a bloke but we must look to elsewhere in the medium term of we are going to move forward.

Positives Bruce Our best football shows we can match it against anyone Negatives Our pressure was non existent for 3 qtrs Skills, horrendous at times Dempster, been a fantastic servant but his clangers are starting to become too common Selection, let's just not pick a full back even though Goddard h...

Less than 18K

Gone at seasons end. GOP and has a few in front of him moving forward.

Here's a thought. Our list strategy was to stockpile 10 first round picks over 3 years starting in 2012. By my calculations that means 2015 is the last year of that strategy. Let's stay the course ,stockpile the picks (or as close to as possible) and draft the best talent in the next couple of years...

I really hope he's just one of the "late developers" you hear of at other clubs. At this stage his future is certainly up in the air a bit. From a list management perspective I think there are 4 in front of him who will struggle to retain their place at the end of the year. In no particula...

Templeton might prove to be a flash in the pan,fumbled all day and applies no pressure in the forward half.

Basil Zemplas is the worlds biggest flog. Eddie gave Dempster the stick all day. Dempster was poor today

Slaughtered is again. Gave the crows first use all day.

So good last year. Been really poor so far this year. Is it time for a spell in the seconds to find some form?

Webster on Betts for mine. Fisher gets Jenkins, McKenzie gets Lynch and Delaney goes to Walker.

Tom Boyd had such an impact in his first season the Dogs paid him $1 mill a season for 7 years.

Pretty easy to judge kids after less than 20 games. We're a bottom 2 side, there is no silver bullet. Judge them after they've played 100 games

No change unless required by injury.

If Saad doesnt come up then;

Out : Saad
In: McKenzie

I think McKenzie will be first as I'd expect Lonie and Sinclair to have a rest at some point. Goddard will play later as the club may chose to manage Fish as well. McCartin will definitely get a go but Bruce and Membrey seem to be before him at the minute. Really good situation to be in at the momen...

In: Billings, White, Acres
Out: Saad, Templeton, Shenton

Newnes goes to HB
Spencer plays high HF
Acres plays FP
Billings goes to the wing