Whether it was a goal or not we will never know & an extremely unfortunate bounce has probably has cost us our first final in almost a decade. Oh FFS. WE buggered the game up. No one to blame but us. Accountability lies at our own doorstep.To quote OlderSaint from another thread : “ Last night ...

Isn't that the same contract as Haneberry only Jack is actually playing

Need to change something as we are way too predictable ATM. Coaches need to get better at a plan B & the players need to be more accountable as a group not leave it up to Steele to do it on his own

saynta wrote: ↑Sun 30 Aug 2020 4:02pm Good review. Bit harsh on long and gears though.

Ratts outcoached.

I know you rate Geary & I used to but the game has passed him by & was ordinary again last night IMO

Whether it was a goal or not we will never know & an extremely unfortunate bounce has probably has cost us our first final in almost a decade.

Holding on to faint hope but we need to start a lot better & get a bit of spark back, way too many passengers in the last 2 weeks leaving the work load to too few. Steele was fantastic Marshall good again Hill had his best game so far but not a real team effort. It has been a gruelling schedule ...

I wish Paddy all the best with whatever he chooses to do but I'm with Sainter_ Dad if he was my son I would not want him to be playing footy

Shane Grambeau’s expert scoring of your comments x/5. Finals on offer after goodness knows how long in the desert and the Club dishes that rubbish up against a mediocre opposition with one match winner. 3/5 we tried - Giving Hill the ball is not helping: there is a difference between a sweet style ...

We are still in the fight. Really in it. 3 games to go. All in Queensland. We have to beat Hawthorn next week or else we will need to win the last 2 games against West Coast and GWS to make finals. Shame we couldn't get over Melbourne. That would have made us definite finals contenders I reckon. Fo...

That Ball through his legs was rather comical in a tragic sort of way, almost a case of too much haste in spending it before he got it. To put it into perspective though I didn't see him in any acts of "self preservation" a la number 8 in the 2nd/3rd quarter? Probably his best game(8) for...

Small forward role is a tough gig but Lonie,Hine,Kent & Parker can only deliver 2 or 3 times a year not good enough. Hine & Kent were terrible tonight I'd give Parker another go . Lonie is a one trick pony been around long enough to show what he can do & has his moments but a list clogge...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sun 30 Aug 2020 12:11am I feel sorry for us.

Yeah me too mate but I think it's our role in the AFL / VFL makeup promise so much & deliver so little

Steele 5
Marshall 4
Jones 2
Hill 2
Ryder 1
Coffield 1

I'm as disappointed as everyone else but don't throw the baby out with the bath water. Yeah your right Max isn't ready & Billings was disappointing but so was Kent,Hine, Ross ,Battle,Geary & a few others that when it was their time to shine they didn't. I think we all got caught up in hype t...

SunnyErnest wrote: ↑Sat 29 Aug 2020 8:13pm He will kick 6 goals 2.

Big call & like your optimism had his chances tonight but not up to it ATM needs a rest

Max is not ready to be the match winner as we as supporters would have hoped.He will be good how good I don't know & as frustrating as it is to see him get his hands on the ball but fail to grab it is what we have to put up with until he gets the confidence to go to the next level. Tom Hawkins &...

Looked tired & jaded obviously showed in his performance tonight. Not desisting him just yet but gee he was disappointing tonight ,when you want some one to stand up & fly the flag he didn't

IMO just needed a different approach into the forward line Mayes was owning Max but they kept bombing there but there should have been other options Geelong have Hawkins but they don't go to him every single time they look for the best option

I do now agree with others on here who want Geary to be dropped.Looked very slow ,with ball in hand like a rabbit in the headlights.Tonight we really needed a captain to lead when the game was there to be won he didnt We are pretty much cooked this year let Geary get his 200 & thanks for the lo...

As frustrating as it is (I just want to kill something) I think it shows how far we have to go to be a serious threat. So many passengers Steele & Marshall very good but too many just didn't pull their weight . The game was there to win we just didn't have the balls to get it done.

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sat 29 Aug 2020 11:03pm said it earlier..if we can't beat the Demons we dont deserve to be in the 8.
Time to think about next season. Should we start to worry about the Coach ?

Yeah mate have to agree if we can't be Melbourne we don't deserve to be there

bangaulegend wrote: ↑Sat 29 Aug 2020 10:32pm Big last quarter if we give it everything I think we can get there but any thing less & we will be back in the pack. It really will be interesting to see how resilient we are

Obviously we weren't

Big last quarter if we give it everything I think we can get there but any thing less & we will be back in the pack. It really will be interesting to see how resilient we are

Marshall has so much composure for a big guy he & Steele is the main reason we are still in the hunt. Max just can't stick a pack mark gets the hands on it but not getting the job done ATM but one day he will . Lucky to be this close

Teflon wrote: ↑Sat 29 Aug 2020 9:35pm Membrey is a liability
Absolute joke his job is to kick goals ffs

Now just take a deep breath yeah he has missed a few soda's but he is a quality player he will play again next week win lose or draw IMO