I love the Problem of too many ruckmen to early to tell who is the better and come on guys the are both not up to scratch yet . I think both will be great ruckman . Stanley should not play in the ruck when Reiwolt retires I think he will be used else where. In short keep both longer & Hickey if ...

Just wishing Lenny Hayes all the best when his playing career ends. I can not help but admire the effort that he has put in to playing for the stkilda football club . He has never been the most skilled player on the list but he is certainly right up there if not # 1 when it comes to courage , endeav...

bring in simpkin they said he played forward in the 2s for a bit & looked good but they had to move him down back to stop a forward . So have a look at him this guy was great for us two seasons ago but seems to have lost his way . Anyone know why.

Its great that armo was good today it has always been his consistancy thats a worry

can anybody tell me what dradt pics stkilda had as soon as the season ended ,I think we always had #3 #21 & # 40

Does anybody agree that the lack of goals kicked buy our midfeilders in the last 10 years has been a major problem

does any one no who sydney are tagging today also I think dalsanto gets the tag the majority of the time does anyone agree with this.

dal is a quality player hope we dont trade him while we wait for the young guys to come on we need quality like him around .

Great to see simkin back this guy was good last year and will be a gun player in the future interesting how Roberton and simkin work together wraped to see kosi back twice the player if he can string 6 or so games together than any other big forward we've got bar roo at this point in time

Well done to Dempster not sure how old he is but lets hope he can stay injury free & we get a few more years from him because when he stays injury free he plays at the level of an "elite backman" as he proved in 2012.

ayres had 2 cracks a senior coaching and was ok at both clubs but not great, dean laidley had one crack at senior coaching and excelled at it I would rather keep laidley

tom simpkin may sound insane but i reckon max hudgton like

I thought simkin played most of last year at full back and did realy well , personly dont think there would be any problem with simpkin more of a stay at home backman, Roberton more of a rebounding defender, gwilt, fisher, dempster, geary as our back six. & put stanley back in the forward line.

harvey
reivolt
locket
hayes
milne
bourke
lowe
frawley
winmar
hudgton

Does anybody no why tom simpkin has not played many games this year, after last years good form, I thought he was for sure in our best 22.

I think mcevoy will be a gun in the last three weeks he has come up against statistically the four best ruckmen in the comp Minson, Nic Nat, Cox, & Goldstein thats the same as a up and coming midfeilder having to play on ablett, swan, watson, & griffen 4 weeks in a row added to that the guy ...

Rhys Stanley - 31 games Jack Newnes - 16 games Nathan Wright - 6 games Seb Ross - 8 games Jimmy Webster- 5 games Arryn Siposs - 23 games Daniel Markworth yet to debut Take your pick, i think we have a few coming through I like that group however we need to double that and then some if we want to re...

I don't know what the Undisciplined acts were but his decision to bang it into F50 to a pack of 20 players with WC outnumbering 2:1 was poor, but worse was his decision to leave his man and enter a kick out ariel contest, even then not kill the ball and allow it to get over the back, resulting in g...

8856brother wrote:

wotever1 wrote:oh joey two undisciplined acts in two minutes.

I have more faith in our youngsters than joey.

You have no idea. He was our best player.

He is statisticall in the top 20 midfeilders in the afl this year "are you a fool the best youngster we have is robert harveys son if he has one .

sack him along with Milne :? milne is statisically the best small forward in the afl the last 20 years problem now is the coaching staff at stkilda elect to play him out of the forward line for a big percentage of each match to try and develop someone else in a small forward position if you want yo...

Stanley will be a gun forward if given the time there sack relidge to use him as fodder in the ruck ,

mc evoy came up against the best ruckman in the comp at the moment goldstein is on fire if he keeps inproving at the rate he has the past couple of years he will be a gun sooner than later. not 25 yo yet i think most ruckmen hit straps late 204 to early 30s. dal 25 poss,12 kicks , 13 hballs, 80% eff...

I go and watch the saints and over and over again see basic skill errors I think that a few of the young guys we have will be good, but it seems to me they are this years new guys eg roberton, ross and that they have jumped ahead of last years new guys eg. saad , sippos .The main problem I see is to...

An acceptiable lose is not the mindset that the players are going over there with I hope. Sydney are not in great form, and if our coach can stop playing favorites and acctually make a few changes in the game when needed (his coaching is as bad as my spelling) we should be in good shape.

I would love for the coaching staff to give geary some quality time in the middle The biggest problem at the saints is for a lot of the players statistically they are brilliant against the the bottom teams but fall away dramatically against quality opposition we have a great void now between our bes...