Great OP, Vazelos ( yes, I did read it...), and I agree with cwrcyn's assessment of the list. I think the 2024 timeline is unrealistic as we are essentially rebuilding (again) and are behind others like NM and even the Hawks, particularly given our position going into this draft and the lack of trad...

Because sometimes the only way you can feel good about yourself is by making someone else look bad. And I'm tired of making other people feel good about themselves! (Homer Simpson)

Thank you for your comment banga. It is clear we are all on the same side. That article on the AFL site on the morning of the game against Sydney was like... " sorry to hear that car I sold you turn out to be a pile cr#p..but thats why I sold it. By the way I bought into BitC at 50c with the mo...

Not old news. Published on the AFL website today, albeit this morning. Topical given we played Sydney today.

DH's recruitment was poorly executed and managed. StK now pay the price ( and history keeps repeating itself )

Doubtless, DH will be cheering for his boys to roll us over today!

We are a laughing stock ....What a joke!

If it was a "nothing trade" hows about we pay him ( Hannerbery) nothing ??? Sorry ausfatcat not persuaded by that spin. Our prospects of a premiership have been set back years by this trade....and others. The damage is broad and significant. Fans are walking away from the club and the game...

https://www.afl.com.au/news/625095/bloods-money-how-the-hannebery-trade-helped-fast-track-sydney-s-rebuildWhat a joke Up there with the worst trade of all time! We are poorly served ! My blood boils. I concluded some time ago St Kilda FC club simply operates to fill out the bottom of the ladder and ...

The legacy of Lyon primarily shapes the club's present culture. His treatment of Ball, Hudghton and their treatment of StK in the 2010 GF.....and the way Lyon departed the club. What values remain from that legacy? No great loyalty. No bond or pact between player. What message does the current circu...

Glad to see Fraser Gehrig smiling and happy at the footy. One of the most entertaining players of all time. He brought out the best and worst in others. Who could forget Wanganeen's "Olympic standard backward pike". The G Train often got the rough end from attention seeking umpires. (eg &q...

I suspect there is a real chance teams in an unsustainable circumstance will amalgamate with more sustainable teams eg Roos/Carlton, Saints/Hawks

The Saints will not be relocated to Tasmania as such a move would in my opinion be inconsistent with the AFL's mission. Won't happen.

at least the AFL is consistent

https://thewest.com.au/sport/i-should-h ... b88513392z

Cameron Ling and Adam Ramanauskasascus talking on Grandstand ABC suggesting "its a tough game", "great clubs" "push the envelope"and as such the MRO are not going to rub Cotchin or Lynch out leading into a final. This attitude and view is troubling and disappointing on ...

Sorry ... I use dictation software


JARRYN GEARY

I much admire Jarrad Geary. I’m not suggesting he should retire or relinquish the captaincy. I think his last two games have been magnificent. However, an eye to the future, there is one player with maturity and composure that stands out. He has the evasive skills of Robert Harvey, the composure of ...

My reading of the rules https://resources.afl.com.au/afl/document/2019/12/04/68a18e95-713c-4408-a269-06b2aef6db34/2019-Tribunal-Guidelines.pdf Ref page 6 In my view (conservative) the incidents below should be assessed by the MRO Lynch - Punch to the back of Paton's head. Striking + Careless + High ...

Difficult to quantify Yorkeys. Notwithstanding, I am simply suggesting that as fellow Saint's supporters we would be better served being civil and polite to our coaches, players and fellow supporters and acknowledge that we are only passengers on the journey.

Yes, my apologises!..."other" 16 clubs!

A lot of the posts appearing on this forum at the moment are quite frankly embarrassing. I am referring in particular to those calling for the coach to be sacked and describing players as useless etc...Can I respectfully suggest that those responsible direct their emotionally energy towards more pos...

Appalling incident. Unforgivable. Do NOT want him at the Saints !!!! I would would rather forego seeing the Saints win a Premiership than sell our soul to Gaff. Memories of Barry Hall to Sydney. The flag the Swans with him is tainted and worthless. Gaff should hang his boots up and retire now. The s...

My opinion is based on the team's performance this year and the scope and prospect for list change. We continue to be unable to convert in front of the goals. A few posters have suggested if we had converted a few more opportunities we would have been in front. Unfortunately we didn't. Furthermore, ...

Looking at the current crop of cellar dwellers there upside for Brisbane, Gold Coast and Carlton. The same can't be said for the Saints. In this context there is a real risk the Saints will be heading for another wooden spoon in 2019. It is difficult to imagine even with an early draft pick that the...

I will probably get flamed for this but I was disappointed by Armo's performance and would not be upset if he was dropped.

BH is clearly struggling for relevance after football. We will now have the PR departments working overtime. Cue the Mea Culpa... " I'm sorry......shame to my family and women blah blah I've got a mother and she is female....blah blah But that doesn't make it right...blah blah I'm going to coun...

Thanks but No thanks... if you are not convinced listen to the rubbish Thomo, Shehan and Newman dish up on their podcast. Breathtaking..... better still don't waste your time.