Patton wasn't really played in his first year as he had knee issues that were being managed including going to sweden or somewhere for treatment. He did a knee in his 10th game but he's played so many you can just tell he's a GOP. Rooey was pretty crap after 10 games and Kos was a champ. I can't te...

He did a knee dude... That can happen to anyone, anytime.... He's what, 20? .... 6'6" So what, he played before he did his knee dude, he didn't look anywhere near as good as Cameron, the jury is still out. By the way dude, what does being 6'6" have to do with it, he hasn't proven anything...

perfectionist wrote:I once met Happy Hammond.

Was Joffaboy with him

Patton hasn't done anything since he was drafted, he may be a GOP, If he would stop injuring himself he could prove it.

I wonder how much he'll weigh when he gets back on the track, he' a BIG lump..

how depressing - pretty hard to make up for five years of poor recruiting - if that's what you'd call it - overnight. Guys like Ledger and White probably need to get a taste of top level footy sooner rather than later. Whatever happened to our state-of-the-art football academy? Who said the academy...

LTN16 wrote:It's true what he said about maxwell though.

One of the most overrated players in the AFL and I agree.

Jason Cloke the 2nd

Ultimately the forum has finally got what it wished for.... enjoy

Not wanting to make this a Cat lovefest but i just checked the 2009 draft after the grand final. We got Winmar Smith Pattison Johnson Dawson and Miles They got Podsiadly Menzel Duncan Vardy and Christensen Call me skeptical but when someone has been a member here for 2 years without posting, sudden...

It'll be public when it's done, that's the way good operators work..

Do we have good operators enlisted at the club....

I'll have a go at making all that happen , can you wait though whilst I ring Hogwarts and see if they''ll sell me a wand. Wow, been here for a month and SS is clearly already rubbing off on you with that comment. Try to resist the urge to sh.itcan geniune posts I know it is the popular thing to do ...

Good stuff Dragit. Cats time in the darkness will come, eventually. Might be sooner than people think. Cats darkness might not come at all either, they aren't as easy to predict as the Bulldogs and the Saints are. I think they'll stay there abouts, they just do it better, In spite of their recorded...

Does Wells know his own recruiting history, or does he choose not to correct the idiotic media who think he is the recruiting messiah ?

for those that didn't rate Gram (confession I am one), have a look at his value versus BJ or lennie for that matter! looks like he always got up when playing the cats. Gram was a really good player. Enormous to us for structure and run... Sorely missed now as is BJ... It was his own fault that his ...

Sacking coaches threads on footy forums pale into insignificance once the journos/media start running with that thought. Those farkers never stop until they get their man, then deny they helped cause it... Look at Neelds career, those farkers were relentless from the start until he was ousted. I hav...

Brown is a good player - fair amount of sour grapes in this thread ... but that said brown was not the be all to end all so him signing with WCE doesnt really hurt us that much as we now focus on another player I agree, I don't get the 'Brown is a spud anyway', he was on the way to being our next g...

St Kilda's defensive structure is not doomed just because it didn't get Brown, it means the focus is elsewhere, which it probably was anyway. The Pelican is just not silly enough to get on his soap box and tell everyone who wants to listen what their plans are, they would prefer to show us if and wh...

sunsaint wrote:

Wayne42 wrote: Hopefully in the next couple of years McEvoy will win a hit out and then we'll be glad we've kept him...

seriously, last week he got 34 and kicked three goals, perhaps you should start watching a game.

Got one...

i stand by my comment the Tassie comp isnt an ammos comp my bad but still i doubt if he wasnt originialy drafted as a early draft pick there would be a story writen about him... is he even the best in that tassie comp ? the artical doesnt sound like he is dominating hes just the best in a historica...

What it comes down to is how how highly do we rate McEvoy We have invested in him, everything we can to develop into an elite ruckman. Will he? He no doubt will be a good player for us, will he ever be a great one? Hopefully in the next couple of years McEvoy will win a hit out and then we'll be gl...

Dodged a bullet there, hopefully we can find a good defender, someone better than Brown .

Wow love the negative bitch comments. I'll have a crack, Yes Laidley has set our midfield on fire - can we get him to replace Watters please? And Melbourne interested in Laidley jeez we'd better follow their example coz they're carving it up at present. If your going to reply in the negative don't ...

ShanghaiSaint wrote:agree what a game what a fight back white winmar come on tell us all how shi.t we are u tool

It wasn't any one poster, there or is it their, are a few who want Watters sacked....

Was there an interchange infringement, it looked like 2 players on for 2 players off, or did only 1 come off ?

8856brother wrote:Wish we were going that bad.

I'm not sure you are going that well when you lose to the struggling Suns, especially when you are aiming for the top 4.....


But yes, we are bad...

There is a lot of covert cheating in the AFL nowadays, are we ever a victim of it ?