I know you again wont answer but why has 3 out of the 4 coaches played him nearly every game they can. Funnily the only one that didnt was SW. Where is he now compared to Cripps. Stupid thread but suits cerain people. No I dont think he is a player. I think he is a GOP. Why would a GOP have played ...

Dunno about that... But he's no loss. Since going to WC he's averaged about 10ppg last week 3 touches against Haw. Best thing about Cripps? He got us Newnes! While I dont like your constant carping on Cripps, your last sentence is spot on. Different players but Newnes is going to be a very good foo...

I hear Clint Jones gets on here after every match to read Redeemers comments religiously.

White Winmar wrote:How did we not win the flags in 2004-5?

Grant Thomas?

Training Services? Belief Clouds, farting at thunder, hitouts to advantage, whispers in the Sky, Barry Hall?

Billings is the only player in the teamthat can hit a target and people want him dropped?

Are we aiming at a new record in disposal inefficiency this weekend?

Not sad, two of our finest EVER champions. I remember people bemoaning the fact that Harvs was still our best midfielder in 2008. Lenny, Dal, bj and Joey stood up. In years to come it will be a key forward like Goddard (in this years draft), or Billings, Acres, Dunstan, otr players yet to be drafted...

We might even get bj back

Well Duh!!!! If the GWS can't get any support Hopefully the swans can convert the ingrained 95% Rugby market to stop following their sport and take on following the rival code.... Another flag will put Sydney on the back pages and maybe the Sydney siders will go out GF night and get pissed... Maybe...

Port only won 3 games in 2011 and 5 games in 2012. They were terrible for those two years. But Port fans will tell you their re build was 5-6 years in the making. 2011 and 12 were kind of end of an era years for us. So really 2013 was year 0. You would hope we could be half decent in 2016. So reall...

It's an idea that has won how many premierships? Trading, recruiting and drafting wins premierships... Not a mass exodus?! We lose three more core or better players.... The losing some of the young players will suffer... Will not be beneficial to their career. A 35yo Lenny (apparantly the only unto...

Posted in a different thread Shaw and Fine discussed Simpkin. Was impressed that he copped a serious hit early and came back on and tore in physically. Fine pointed out that this was good but he is just a bit too slow and just a bit to short for AFL. Shaw countered that he would rather watch Tom Sim...

When you recruit, you leave no stone unturned IMO. TAC cup (Billings, Gaff), VFL (Barlow, Podsiadly, Hibbert), WAFL (Hutchings, CJ), SANFL (Tippett, Callinan), AFL (Ball, Cross), Pre Season Draft (Powell, Lamb), Rookie Draft (Boyd, Grundy), ND, Delisted Free agent (Roberton), Unresstricted FA (Godd...

citywest wrote:......and neither would I. If we could get him by trading Gilbert plus our 3rd round pick then I would jump at that.

lol why not ask for both Jacks to be thrown in as well?

Really Gilbert and a third rounder for Reid????? Would be steal of the century.

Great, we now have Reid and Fyfe and Henderson in our pockets.

Things are looking up.

Not sure why she can't be a good coach? Not sure why it's a great appointment? Her ability should be judged after a period of time... When her level of success can be measured. No different to AR or any coach. She won the position, hopefully on merit... But then the test begins +1 Exactly correct. ...

How are we tanking?

You have to have a realistic chance of winning to tank.

We are by far the worst team in the comp at present and never once have looked like tanking, we dont need to

Shaw ad Fine discussed Simpkin. Was impressed that he copped a serious hit early and came back on and tore in physically. Fine pointed out that this was good but he is just a bit too slow and just a bit to short for AFL. Shaw countered that he would rather watch Tom Simpkin and his deficiencies than...

Fine and Shaw on SEN just gave Russell and Ricuitto an almighty spray. Basically saying they were biased and appalling.

Shaw chimed in and said Wingard was nowhere near the best player in the League.

So it wasn't just the people on here

Con Gorozidis wrote:BEST:
Sandringham: J. Webster, J. Gwilt, J. Holmes, D. Weickhardt, D. Roberton, K. Ong

Encouraging to see Holmes in the best.

That is a good result

We are IMO over the last 6 weeks the worst team by quite some margin! Deservedly last if that's the case!! Love to know our % (indicator of competitiveness) since our last win?! Easily the worst. In fact this is just about the worst Saint team since I have been living in Melbourne since 1988. Worse...

load poo ya log on to read match thread and just same old names arguing over schoolgirl rubbish, makes reading threw to find out wat happened pain full. Just kick these toss bags of no matter how much knowledge they think or do have What language are you conversing in? Vaguely like English, but not...

Simmo2 wrote:Dont intend to ever revisit the site anyway so may as well make it known that the way this site is run is shambolic and an indictment to the name of the St.Kilda football club

I love posters who announce they will never post on here again - like anyone cares

Just go.

Soft

you can have an opinion, but dont cry when it is challenged.

You want to not watch our footy team, fair enough, but dont expect fullsome support

I am almost done with this game too. Stopped going to the footy since I realised we didnt get a dime from the Etihad deal anyway. Comp is stuffed and finally the masses are speaking with their feet. Looking forward to David Villa joining Melbourne City FC. Gonna give the A league my coin instead Th...

Umpires unprofessional and incompetent. Commentators have bagged them all night, but not you, they are infallible according to you Please dont lie. Show me the post where i said that. this all started when I said they got the Murdoch wrong. Thats wrong which isnt right. i then pointed out at that s...