The idea that Jon Ralph, or any other media commentator for that matter, is not entitled to express his opinion on teams is absolute rubbish, that's a legitimate part of their job and love or loathe him, Ralph has vast experience in the industry. Whether or not supporters agree with his views is nei...

Nothing to see here, fact is that Geoff Walsh is one of the highest regarded AFL officials in the business. He did what he was required to do in the massive overhaul of St Kilda football operations last October which resulted in the termination of Brett Ratten and return of Ross Lyon to the love of ...

Definitely a prudent move to give another year to Tom Campbell, he's dedicated to the club and as someone else pointed out, he is a cheap ruck coach. All will be revealed whether or not Max Heath is AFL standard round about February next year when the squad is full steam into pre-season training an...

Definitely a prudent move to give another year to Tom Campbell, he's dedicated to the club and as someone else pointed out, he is a cheap ruck coach. All will be revealed whether or not Max Heath is AFL standard round about February next year when the squad is full steam into pre-season training and...

Following article comes from SEN website, written by Andrew Slevison. I wonder if it accords with AFL rules because I had a feeling that this practice was prohibited. It's a double-edged sword, especially in regard to players who move interstate when drafted. I guess that it would be nigh impossible...

One thing I think some might agree about , is that infield leadership was bad after Geary left. That's true Shane and reflects adversely on Jack Steele who succeeded Geary as skipper. It goes to prove that even one of the team's best players does not necessarily possess the attributes to be a stron...

I'm being unfairly harsh on Geary, I take it back. He gave his all, never backed down and gave outstanding service under incredibly difficult and perhaps unlucky times in terms of draft, trading, medical decisions and career ending injuries. All of that may be true CQS but so are the comments you p...

I'm sure that he would have had to do a lot of persuading to get the other directors behind him. You are still making it sound like Bassett started concocting his cunning plan when he first walked into the joint and all that he needed to do was to convince other board members, how long had he been ...

Kicking someone who's down is a mongrel act....bloody disgusting and shameful!

Reading an article on The Roar about Jack Billings' move to Melbourne, Finn Arrowsmith noted a very interesting fact about St Kilda during the Alan Richardson era: " Player development was non-existent under new coach Alan Richardson; from the four drafts after Ross Lyon left in 2011, exactly ...

Reading an article on The Roar about Jack Billings' move to Melbourne, Finn Arrowsmith noted a very interesting fact about St Kilda during the Alan Richardson era: " Player development was non-existent under new coach Alan Richardson; from the four drafts after Ross Lyon left in 2011, exactly o...

I'm surprised to see a young ruck prospect being suggested in the forthcoming draft. Max Heath was recruited in the mid-season draft in 2021, he's 21 today and has shown good form in the seconds. It's more than likely he will debut in 2024. On the subject of ruckmen, it's noteworthy that Tom Campbel...

Very grateful for starting this thread Tony74, hope that you're able to give us a weekly report of what's happening at Moorabbin during the off-season, it'll help to deal with withdrawal symptoms when it all ends on the last Saturday in September. Maybe there are other supporters who attend training...

Don't agree with the negative opinion about Jack Billings being traded to Melbourne. For a start, JB is entering the twilight zone of his career, one that has never achieved his #3 draft pick promise while playing for St Kilda. His form in the 11 games he was selected since 2021 were nothing to writ...

Following link rates the 2023 NAB AFL Draft prospects:

https://central.rookieme.com/afl/power- ... prospects/

Following article reveals the reason Liam Henry chose to come to Moorabbin:

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2023/10/17/ ... to-saints/

I don't lack a sense of humour at all Vortex, it's just that most times when you attempt to be funny it falls flat, but you've once again reminded me why I should ignore your observations, I should've known better...

Yet more balderdash from the resident SS provocateur

As much as this appeals, I can't imagine Footscray parting ways with a key and elite playmaker like Jackson Macrae who still has 3 years left on his contract.

But stranger things have happened...

Max Heath turns 21 next week so he's still only what Ross Lyon termed "a baby" in the AFL. Ross Lyon's teams have always featured strong ruck combinations and I think he will give Heath plenty of opportuties when the young bloke is ready to play on the big stage. When that happens St Kilda...

If Liam Henry can perform much like Melbourne's Kysaiah Pickett or Collingwood's Bobby Hill both of who are not as tall as Henry (180cm), which seems to me is quite likely, than he will be a decisive improvement on Gresham. On another note I was interested to read today that commentators are raving ...

Good deal but I fear that future second might be a decent pick. That very much depends on where St Kilda finish in 2024. Assuming Fremantle continue to slip down the ladder future 4th could well favour the Saints. Considering Henry's potential this was definitely a very good deal by the club. Gain ...

Good deal but I fear that future second might be a decent pick. That very much depends on where St Kilda finish in 2024. Assuming Fremantle continue to slip down the ladder future 4th could well favour the Saints. Considering Henry's potential this was definitely a very good deal by the club. Gain ...

I thought Lyon was brought in because the review suggested THIS list was under performing Not to do a rebuild Just a little bit of both actually, Lyon came in and stated that 2023 would be a year of exploration where he would be able to assess the players on the list and determine who in his opinio...

The good thing is that Stocker has only been given another year to cement his place in the team on a regular basis. It's well known that Ross Lyon holds his players to account so I would think Stocker will bust his arse to improve his fitness and endurance in the off-season because he certainly has ...