Finnis certainly needs replacing The recruiting has been pretty good since mcartin, most who chose him have lost their jobs. Letherlan, ratten and Bassed can stay We do need some better assistants though, more focus on the mental stuff and leadership onfield. Lenny Hayes and Robert Harvey might be i...

Football department is fine, probably the best we have ever had.

We have 10-15guys on our list that are just not great players or not even playing. Makes it tough.

Thank God we didn't trade our first rounder....could be pick 2 or 3 Maybe the club knows where we r at?? Good players that will play in our finals team Marshall King Battle Gresham Coffield Bytel Crouch Hill Byrnes Howard Clark Steele Billings Higgins Wilkie Long Membry Sinclair We need to build on...

Lloyd seemed keen to help Max with his kicking. Has had experience in coaching kicking and ‘turned his goal kicking around’ through coaching. Why on earth wouldn’t we engage Lloyd with King when they have a past relationship and he was an excellent shot at goal and he has had experience in coaching ...

Chol is a much better player than Hunter
Hunter is the definition of dud, I have never been more embarrassed watching a Saints player run around than I did with him in the middle. Wow.

We need a young ruckman
Chol 200cm
Can play and would get plenty of games next year and almost the whole year in 2023

Nankervis 26 and Soldo 25 still young

Is out of contract this year.
4yrs surly tigers can’t match..!
Knows butler and Higgins..? Good fit I rekon

Look no further than this thread for proof that the forum is largely inhabited by keyboard haters masquerading as St Kilda Football Club supporters. There was much speculation on this forum as to why Jack left St Kilda, the only confirmed fact being he stood out of the game due to his mental health...

Enrico_Misso wrote: ↑Sat 15 May 2021 9:35am I missed his lap.
Was he sober?
It must have been scary for him travelling all that way?

Everyone missed the lap, barely anyone turned up for it. Which says a lot about most supporters feelings toward Jack, not just Saintational posters.

Matthew loyd has a strong relation with the kings. Him an roughy should be enough. He will improve as his belief improves but it’s hard to watch. Members needed to be better though. No reason he can’t spend half a day a week with our old number 12, Hoping he still knows where Moorabbin is. sometimes...

All our new guys will need time to gel, better to have too many small forwards than not enough, we will get the mix right. Long is talented and should be given time. We can’t delist them all we are already playing 5 short. Let’s try to avoid the hysteria, we beat the cats last night and thais a mass...

All our new guys will need time to gel, better to have too many small forwards than not enough, we will get the mix right. Long is talented and should be given time. We can’t delist them all we are already playing 5 short. Let’s try to avoid the hysteria, we beat the cats last night and thais a mass...

Never underestimate leadershIp and a level head in defence. Onfield coaches are worth more than in the box coaches. Our backline looked the best it has for ages and no coincidence he was part of it. We won’t challenge for top four until we have more leaders across all positions. (28-30yr olds)

Seriously

So Jeremy Cameron and Hawkins together doesn’t work..?
Get it done Saints, a pair of Kings beats most hands

No thanks

If Ben returns to melb and we don't land him we may as well pack up. He should be a lock and about time something like this went our way.....

4th youngest list 2020
We will certainly need some youth to compliment our 21-26 year olds over the next 5 years.
Unfortunately our 27-32 year olds currently playing are just terrible (apart from Seb)

Our recruiting over the next 2-3 years needs to be spot on

Hill out
Had enough and faked an injury

Hanners Dunstan Webster On good coin Must be moved on If hill is in a incentive based ‘games played’ contract, every s*** game he plays he should miss one. Playing like he doesn’t want to get hurt. Exactly the type of player I laugh at when they play for other teams..fml what a squib Ryder let us do...

Would be happy to trade to soft marshmallow

He is just utter crap, if he was on 500k I could take it but to pay him 900k makes me vomit when Steele is on less

I prefer to look at the players as a whole than singling one player out...there are many we can talk about, Sinclair, Buttler, Lonie...etc etc. Hill performs well when the "TEAM" performs well. Those guys you have mentioned not getting paid anywhere near Hills salary. You put your hand ou...

Wow Not worth anywhere near his salary Soft Can’t defend Not a leader for his age Terrible body language Just not someone I can continue to pretend to like as a player Seems a new whipping boy is developing I would very much consider a trade to GWS for Kelly and unfortunately a pick (due to his inab...

Absolutely none Our defence is the worst in the league They have 3 great talls Our rucks are pathetic, they have one of the best maybe of all time in the ruck. Our forwards are either 20yrs old bean poles or midgets, their backline are proper men. We have nooooooooooo chance Just hope no one gets in...

Anyone that defends this loss in anyway is a f****** idiot

Not sure what the confusion is here

Pies pay 200k a year for the next 5 years
We pay 600k

It is cheaper than Dylan Roberton

If Adam nominates is he is ours.

Big chance he comes now we have our first pick

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 02 Nov 2020 4:39pm Treloar won't be in a good space next year. As good as he is I'd prefer Higgins.

Mate we are getting both