There is some discussion Carlisle wants a big 4 Melb club and is waiting on Carlton to see if they will offer a 5yr deal.
Low probability he will be a Saint.
moveon.com

First St. Kilda's 1st & 2nd picks in the Nat. draft should be kept I believe unless an outstanding deal is being offered & then I would only be comfortable with the involvement in the 2nd pick. Nathan F. is not an outstanding deal ingredient I believe simply because of his troublesome hamst...

FQF wrote:Why wouldn't Carlton just offer him 5 years and be done with it?

Reckon that is in the works right now.

Is it an O'meara / Bennell double play jaxons??? We are absolutely not interested in Bennell. What's your take on O'Meara's knee?? Any information forthcoming?? Nothing to suggest he won't return to full fitness. Do u think we'll get Carlisle? If he chooses us then yes. So.... Do u think he will ch...

Its the PreSeason Draft not the National Draft. Different. Much different. In the draft there is other young talent that would be picked first...as with Ball. In the PSD you would imagine that teams below us would all be keen. So trick will be trying to have a contract that they do not have room fo...

Its the PreSeason Draft not the National Draft. Different.

Anyone heard anything about Lonie being a possible trade bait? Hope its not true No inside info but I am trying to keep across all the trade discussion from the various forums and I have never heard Lonie's name mentioned. At best he may have been mentioned by an opposition poster as part of a prop...

Its Jaeger O'Meara ladies and gents.
By God I hope his knees are OK - from those who know far more than me say the patella tendon issues like he's had usually mean "game over".

BTW - Thanks Jaxons - alway appreciate your efforts.

LMFAO - He's posting on BF now already causing a stir responding to a post that was bagging him although more restrained so far.

Pity cos he is a loyal supporter but I have read many BF posters say they left the SS forum coz of the off-topic petty personalised squabbling and even there P66 is notorious even though not a BF poster. Leads me to the conclusion that in aggregate he did damage. Hopefully he rejoins with a differen...

Footy may be fickle but it is not unrealistic. The "I'll bag you until you prove me wrong" attitude is so cynical and quite immature. The guy played as a stay at home forward for Vic Country where they play one-on-one footy which is totally different from the demands of senior footy. Not ...

Footy may be fickle but it is not unrealistic. The "I'll bag you until you prove me wrong" attitude is so cynical and quite immature. The guy played as a stay at home forward for Vic Country where they play one-on-one footy which is totally different from the demands of senior footy. Not ...

Footy may be fickle but it is not unrealistic. The "I'll bag you until you prove me wrong" attitude is so cynical and quite immature. The guy played as a stay at home forward for Vic Country where they play one-on-one footy which is totally different from the demands of senior footy. Not e...

Expecting anything from an 18-19y.o KPP in his first year regardless of whether he was pick 1 or not is totally unrealistic. As sure as night comes day, unrealistic expectation turns to failure - no surprises there. The kid will be fine, he has shown true glimpses of quality which indicate its there...

The common view is that his kicking skills are highly questionable which is not what we need.
Gets plenty of the footy, genuine inside mid but we have plenty of the same sort.
May be wrong but seems surplus to requirements.

I don't think there is any chance we will be drafting a 30yr old delisted player. Shenton is contracted and we need the list space for a youngster if Ray finds another club who will give him two years.

The odds are slipping on us get Carlisle IMO. Met with him last week, apparently. Tabled a very generous offer, apparently. And he still hasn't nominated us as his preferred destination. I think we are getting used as leverage here. Big rumours that he'll be a dog or a blue. Might be time to move o...

The odds are slipping on us get Carlisle IMO. Met with him last week, apparently. Tabled a very generous offer, apparently. And he still hasn't nominated us as his preferred destination. I think we are getting used as leverage here. Big rumours that he'll be a dog or a blue. Might be time to move on.

Richo gave us the equation in his B&F speech. To play finals we need to stop 12 points against and kick 7 points more on average. To win a flag we need to kick 100 points and restrict the oppoisition to 60 points. This is very much a "Moneyball" view of the world and within reason I su...

A bloke on Big Footy who claims to have inside knowledge said trade would involve a popular player and fans won't be happy. With that in mind, and with the presumption that it would have to be a decent player, posters started throwing names about. Newnes was one suggestion and it's grown from that....

I'm missing something with Newnes I think? I see he gets a bit of ball these days, but does he impact games? Given how they vote for the B&F, I don't think his coaches think he does much either. He is the sort of guy who may bite us on the butt if we traded him, or he could be like Ben, where h...

Been reading the mail from Brian on BF and he has suggested that we need to get ready for a trade of a well liked player. He is suggesting the Carlisle trade will be 2nd round pick & a player - he mentioned Ross but I don't think he meant him as the "well liked player" that's others' i...

@theafloffseason Essendon has held discussions with Carlton about a possible trade deal for Jake Carlisle. The 23 year old told the Bombers this week of his desire to seek a fresh start elsewhere. “I’ve met with Carlton, haven’t met with St Kilda yet, I’m meeting with them this week,” Essendon List ...

Was keen to get this guy and give him a second chance but I have changed my thoughts.
https://youtu.be/vXbe9vgS3yw

I have never complained about umpires on here before but that was so totally, balatantly bias to one side. And I thought it was just me being one-eyed until I saw the total stats for the game.
Utterly disgraceful. WTF???