Think we made the right call. Can only wait until we see Goddard to know for sure. He struggled to get his body right, which is also happening at Geelong. He was also omitted from their side too so it hasn't be a clear "strength to strength" scenario where we let top-shelf quality walk. He...

If a GWS style package was on offer you would genuinely have to think seriously about it. The fact is the bigger Vic clubs are going to continue to pull further away. How do you compete against $50m training facilities and/or your own ground to collect gate-takings a la Symmonds Stadium? Given where...

The guy is on a one year contract, not performing and not even in the development side. My guess is the club will run out of patience before supporters do. Doesn't bode well. The odds must be shortening by the day that this is his last year with the Saints which is a shame. Another club will have a ...

Question is: Is he even training?

what irreparable damage will occur to St Kilda should we drop this weeks game to Melbourne EVEN if we didn't perhaps try as hard ????? none Is winning the most important thing for St Kilda right now? nope Winning is the end product of giving best effort. Sometimes you give best effort and don't win...

Speaking of ‘interesting’ South-East suburban land acquisitions, this is worth a look from our dear friends at Essendon. Strong industry rumours that the sale of Dairy Bell was not warranted, and that the sale was "forced" on them. Hmmm http://www.smh.com.au/business/capital-gain-dairy-be...

Hickey is getting played out of position and now looks like he has lost confidence. Remember this is the guy that ran Mumford off his feet and kicked three goals last year before getting injured. He was clearly our no.1 ruck option. He hasn't been able to get any continuity in his game since. Since ...

Just remember we played an exceptional skilled team today. They are what we strive for and eventually to be better. We will learn a lot from that game. The club had its own stationary camera as high as is possible to watch the player movement patterns. The experience will be invaluable. Minimal cha...

SainterK wrote:

Excellent grab. Must have been a contender for mark of the day.

You need to read the articles that have been cited that discuss the current thinking coming out of the AFL around the make up of zones. No point continuing to go over the same ground unless you are aware of how they are framing the issue. Read the one put up on here. I still don't understand your t...

Those first 2 points could stop the move. The saints as a club cant and wont because I doubt they really even care. The supporters have even less influence. Its 10 kilometres away. Its no where near us. You are living in genuine fantasyland if you think it will effect us even slightly. If we do hav...

Those first 2 points could stop the move. The saints as a club cant and wont because I doubt they really even care. The supporters have even less influence. Its 10 kilometres away. Its no where near us. You are living in genuine fantasyland if you think it will effect us even slightly. If we do hav...

Geez, I hope we get Darcy Parish. He is top-shelf quality.

Mitch Brown in best again. Think we need to have a serious look at this kid next year for rookie list. Seems to have found some consistency which was always a knock on him at Geelong. Kid can play and deserves a second shot at AFL. Noticed the same. He will definitely get a second chance somewhere....

Those first 2 points could stop the move. The saints as a club cant and wont because I doubt they really even care. The supporters have even less influence. Its 10 kilometres away. Its no where near us. You are living in genuine fantasyland if you think it will effect us even slightly. If we do hav...

stjay wrote:

Playon wrote:Hawks game on tomorrow guys. Same channel

Could u plz pm me? pretty plz?

You're a champion. Much appreciated

Playon wrote:Hawks game on tomorrow guys. Same channel

Could u plz pm me? pretty plz?

Im pretty sure my argument was also well reasoned but I do find people who try to say otherwise without logical reason are struggling. I gave my reasons. pity you either didn't read them or couldn't understand. Your reasons lack logic but that's ok. By the way most of the stuff you have written is ...

howlinwolf wrote:Just to lighten the mood a little. Tune in to this podcast at 35.01 for the couldabeens take on this subject

http://www.abc.net.au/coodabeens/featur ... abeens.xml

Would be keen to listen to it but I can't get that link to work.
Could you please repost it HW?

I was quite explicit with what I am saying. In regards to zoning. There is likely to be a very strong local component to it. And just as the Western Bulldogs nautral zone is likely to be a large chunk of Outer West North West Melb, our zone is the outer South of Melb from Bayside to the Pennisula. T...

Alright. Well we will have to agree to disagree. As I suspected, this is becoming more about your ego and using Ad hominems rather than a well informed, well reasoned point of view. Good on you. Even weaker. Why my ego but not yours? I will tell you why. because you have no logical response so it b...

Hi all, This is the time where you need to think like I did, for Mark Thompson and his dodgy property deal at Armstrong Creek, Geelong. This WILL Impact your club, as Hawthorn must have a relationship with the City of Kingston to have this section of land in Dingley. Hawthorn will now be lobbying t...

Hi all, This is the time where you need to think like I did, for Mark Thompson and his dodgy property deal at Armstrong Creek, Geelong. This WILL Impact your club, as Hawthorn must have a relationship with the City of Kingston to have this section of land in Dingley. Hawthorn will now be lobbying t...

Hi all, This is the time where you need to think like I did, for Mark Thompson and his dodgy property deal at Armstrong Creek, Geelong. This WILL Impact your club, as Hawthorn must have a relationship with the City of Kingston to have this section of land in Dingley. Hawthorn will now be lobbying t...

Hi all, This is the time where you need to think like I did, for Mark Thompson and his dodgy property deal at Armstrong Creek, Geelong. This WILL Impact your club, as Hawthorn must have a relationship with the City of Kingston to have this section of land in Dingley. Hawthorn will now be lobbying t...