citywest wrote:I reckon we should cut our losses at the end of this season and trade him. If Geelong are prepared to give us a pick in the 20's take it.

+1

bigcarl wrote:Out: Webster (hand), Riewoldt (knee), Dunstan
In: Savage/Dmac, McCartin, Stevens

Yep

Murphy is a bigger tosser than I thought, he has effectively broadcast to the country that a certain someone has been bonking his Mrs.
I didn't know about it before this weekend and now everybody does, not too clever this Carlton captain

silverhalo wrote:

whiskers3614 wrote:Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Please explain?

Ah got it..... Carey and the Mrs

silverhalo wrote:

whiskers3614 wrote:Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Please explain?

Ah got it..... Carey and the Mrs

whiskers3614 wrote:Murphy sick of copping sledging re his damsel and the King?

Please explain?

Can all the doubters please lay off the kid now and stop all the comparisons with Bontempelli. He is an absolute class act and just as valuable as Bontempelli, just a different type of player. He's obviously taking longer to reach that champion status but there's no doubt he'll get there.

I thought it was PLEASING

The big guy needs a spell. He really struggled for a lot of the game - used to his class to do a few nice things but is not covering the ground well at all and is struggling below his knees big time. We have a no. 1 pick power forward desperate for some senior game time. Richo has tendency to overp...

In: Weller, Lonie
Out: Wright, Stevens

Can't wait to see Marshall upgraded and played at this level but might be a bit early - his time is coming soon though

No Change

Maybe it's just me but I sense that JB is emerging. The natives have been getting restless over Jack Billings not performing at the standard expected given that he was such a high draft pick but I think he's starting to put it together. The kid is a class act and I've got no doubt he'll be the champ...

I know it's still early days but Roberton is in career best form, he has been an absolute revelation down back and would be a certainty for All Australian if he keeps playing the way he is. I think he's thriving on the responsibility of being in the leadership group and with the support now of Brown...

BigMart wrote:Sinclair and Minchington are a long way above VFL

Sinclair should be playing seniors, no doubt about it.

Ladies and gentlemen! If we choose not to trade, we will have the opportunity to grab two of these lads. Early days, I know, and there are always bolters as the year goes on, but these twenty are considered the cream ATM. Who would you choose? Let's have a nearest the pin/time capsule comp. The Jad...

As for Billings. No one (that I read anyway) on here called for Nicky Dal's cuz. I also heard (read?) that the Poodles have said that they'd have taken Billings ahead of Bontempelli. That said, Billings looks like one of those types who will improve as the team improves around him . He also seems t...

As for Billings. No one (that I read anyway) on here called for Nicky Dal's cuz. I also heard (read?) that the Poodles have said that they'd have taken Billings ahead of Bontempelli. That said, Billings looks like one of those types who will improve as the team improves around him . He also seems t...

maverick wrote:That hit was far from tough
Hitting an open bloke as he is kicking is gutless
Does it all the time

+1

He hasn't even been reported for it, if he's not cited as part of match review, travesty of justice. Wouldn't surprise me if he gets off to be honest, there is so much inconsistency in how they assess this stuff, it's not funny.

I'm sure we'd all love him if he played for us and praise his hardness. That hit on Cloke was very hamillesque... it was a bit late, but didn't get him high. I know that the suspensions handed down take into account whether the hit was high or not. This incident illustrates that you can cause just ...

ausfatcat wrote:

That's the one.....it's actually worse than I remembered; he's going to kill someone.

Seeing what Ziebell did to poor old Clokey today reminded me of a very similar incident involving Rooey a few years ago when he jumped off the ground and hurled himself at him knocking the absolute bejesus out of him. Well it looks like Cloke has broken ribs and this guy is still up to his old trick...

Sinclair must be confused? First emergency last week Got to play a half of BFL as a result Dominated that half in atrocious conditions Not even on the emergency list? My thoughts exactly. I have zero idea what match committee is doing to this kid. He makes good decisions, is clean by foot and hand ...

Can't wait to see Ben Long play, looks VERY exciting. Just needs to temper his aggression a bit, been suspended a number of times already in his short career in NT and again in the VFL Grand Final last year. Love those guys that have the fire in the belly but he's no good to us sitting in the stands.

Thanks Shinner for the fantastic service you have given this club, one of the most selfless and courageous players I've ever seen, you've been a ripper. For any aspiring young players, this guy is your ultimate role model; he may not have been the most talented player that's gone around but did EVER...