Sandringham 18 port Melbourne 8
21 minute mark of the first quarter

Told you all it was a dumb idea. Our club is dumb. Coach not bright. Assistants all low intelligence. Oh Con. Why are you such a Saints hater. Give it away son and seek some peace. Well I hate he Bombers more. Losing to them is hard to swallow. I share your pain. Still love the Saints though. Bombe...

Only noticed his crap in the first quarter, after that he didn't effect us in anyway. The rest was all on us

Roberton Carlisle Savage Steven Newnes Not sure how Sinclair could get votes - our mids got smashed and he did absolutely nothing (like Stevens and Steele) until Essendon began easing up after the game was won. Every week Sinclair gets overrated on votes. Needs to win his own ball. Haven't given hi...

At the end day, guys who step up today should be given an opportunity, simple as that!!!!!!! Webster for Gilbert Longer for Hickey Guys who stand up today earn a trip to Sydney, plenty of spots on offer, but must be demanded by today's performance!!!!!!! I agree with minimal changes, can't throw ev...

I think that a ruckmans job isn't to accumulate possessions We don't need Longer to get possessions because he.gives our mids 4 or 5 extra possessions. That being said will not count out Hickey as I still think he has potential, just not as our number 1 ruckman. Maybe he could reinvent himself as a ...

Some tough but fair calls there

5. Carlisle
4. Savage
3. Roberton
2. Steven
1. Sinclair

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well. The boys got worked over and will learn from it. Also we need speed...lets try Freezer. Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense Long...

I liken longer to Mumford, as his presence makes our mids better, and he does a lot of bullokong at stoppages. He'll never be all Australian, but he fills a role and helps our clearances. I have no doubt hickey would have still been our number 1 had third man up still been a thing, but I'm afraid th...

Go support GWS if youre tired of mediocrity, it's part of the deal for going for St Kilda.

We all knew that going in

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt Should get another one. Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him? What do you by perservere? Like keep playing through a slump, or delist him soon? He's been very solid al...

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well. The boys got worked over and will learn from it. Also we need speed...lets try Freezer. Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense Gear...

fugazi wrote:Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well.
The boys got worked over and will learn from it.
Also we need speed...lets try Freezer.

Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense

No point playing Freeman right now in my opinion webster gets in next week for McKenzie. If gilbo stays out for the rest of the year, maybe McKenzie stays on purely for structural reasons, can play the same role as Gilbo

Deserves to be on the team with form like that. Back to his best in my opinion

Hahahaha, nice melt.

Always funny after a loss

Carlisle is a great player, and Savage has found his place back in the team

Haven't done enough to shut down the Don's elite ball users, and has cost us The Dons are ninth. Let's not exaggerate how good they are please. thats what hurts, they are a hell of a lot better than us. Merret, Kelly and McGrath loved that game, don't underestimate how good some of their players ac...

The loss of third man up killed every chance he had at being number 1 ruck, it used to cover his deficiency as a ruckman and let him pinch in here and there around the ground

Haven't done enough to shut down the Don's elite ball users, and has cost us The Dons are ninth. Let's not exaggerate how good they are please. thats what hurts, they are a hell of a lot better than us. Merret, Kelly and McGrath loved that game, don't underestimate how good some of their players ac...

Haven't done enough to shut down the Don's elite ball users, and has cost us

Jeez Carlisle is an absolute weopon though, isn't he?

Sigh In true SS style we've identified the next scapegoat and in the same breath, Longer who very few rated a fortnight ago has now become the saviour. The reality is that we have been garbage across the board... Mids not working hard enough, forwards missing U15 grade goals. We've been garbage acr...

Hickey is useless, should have brought in Holmes, he'd actually compete