Timmy W only suggested this, not the club.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/10/03/mumford-would-impact-saints-more-than-hannebery-says-watson/ Is this guy on drugs? More of an influence than Hannerbrey? He's comparing a 27 year old mid that will play for 5-6 more years to a 32 year old ruckman that didn't even play last year and might have 1...

Directed at his performance only? Really? Do you read some of the posts on here?

Complete lack of class on display, but...that are humans for you I guess.

The vitriol directed at Alan is unfair and below the belt. Very poor form. Sure, be critical of his performance in the correct manner if that is your opinion, but the vitriol and name calling is very ordinary and subpar. Alan is was one of the best humans you will ever meet. Great guy and family man.

We’re definitely not a laughing stock. Agreed we’re not the first choice for players who want the ultimate success soon. But it’s baby steps at the moment, and players from other clubs can see there is definitely upside coming to us. We’ll be mid table next year. Bookmark it. Thank you. Where its r...

Incorrect on every level.
And there is a reason professional AFL football clubs have competent and knowledgeable staff making decisions on players and the list...and not people like you and others.

Apologist? Mediocre? Yep. Righto...

Better off to be positive and see those in charge trying to change the course of the ship than sook, whinge and ramble on a St Kilda members forum every day. Good luck.

Not everyone we pick up needs to be an A grade gun. A list has to have pieces added to it. One by one. Amon could fit that bill.

Disagree. The club is having a go. What else can you ask for? Riewoldt has met Shiel to try entice him over. Ratten and Lade in. O'shaughnessy from Hawks. Hannerbrey and Kent in. Possibly more. If we don't get Shiel or Wingard then we go to the draft and get a very good kid like Coff and Hunter last...

Timmy Watson has heard he is coming to Saint s. I heard Timmy on the radio too this morning, and that is not what he actually said. It was more that he had heard rumours. He did not claim at all that he was going to the Saints. SEN also went onto say that they had contacted the Saints and were told...

Hawthorn can't get Shiel and Wingard. Surely not possible for starters. So if we miss out on Shiel, we should target Wingard big time.

Is Shiel mad? He would take 500k a year less at a number of years...really? Just to play at a club that is going better and is better run "at the moment."

Yep. Astute recruitment again. Only cost a 3rd or 4th rounder. Early days yet.

Dan and Dean seem the only 100% certainties thus far.

Timmy Watson has heard he is coming to Saint s. I heard Timmy on the radio too this morning, and that is not what he actually said. It was more that he had heard rumours. He did not claim at all that he was going to the Saints. SEN also went onto say that they had contacted the Saints and were told...

Not much. Originally drafted as a late pick and not a complete regular at Port.

Neither were Membrey, Bruce or Roberton. They turned out alright.

Hawks interested too. That gives me more confidence.

I had never heard of Roberton or Bruce before we picked them up also.

Young bloke from Port. Think he's aboriginal. Been there around 5 years. 42 games. Quick mid. Ex Sandringham Dragon.

Reports emerging Saints in the race. Wants to head back to Vic.

How about:
#Pick 4 and Dunstan to PA
#Pick 10 (Nth pick from Polec trade) and Wingard to Saints

If the club can't attract Shiel (seems Hawthorn is his preferred option), should they pay Wingard the reported 800k to 900k he wants on a long term deal?

Pick 4 and someone like Dunstan to Port in exchange. Hypothetical.

Correct. All the more reason to enjoy them from now on. We actually had a really good run in the 90's and 00's.

Yep. Massive offer. Biggest in club's history.

Timmy Watson has heard he is coming to Saint s. I heard Timmy on the radio too this morning, and that is not what he actually said. It was more that he had heard rumours. He did not claim at all that he was going to the Saints. SEN also went onto say that they had contacted the Saints and were told...

I guess some people will finally realise that there is more to life on a massive scale than your footy team making the 8 or GF every year.