Carlisle is not 203cm

I am sure AR and Ratts just picked the best players available at the time. Of course he didn’t want blowouts, he probably wanted to win?! Coffield has taken a little time, and he’s still not there Clark was a little unfit year one, and still played Billings and Gresham have hardly missed since they ...

And whilst Roo moved to Qld as a teen, his extended family are still all in Tassie

As a kid, I used to watch big Chris Riewoldt play CHF for Clarence.

Plus

A big Con would be the fact we just spent 30M on a training facility at Moorabbin

Rooey left Tassie at 12yo

He played juniors at Sandy Bay in Hobart.

Went to HS in Qld.

Is it really?

Wait and see

On the Carlisle trade

Seperate issues

Are you saying he was not happy because he didn’t get traded, and stopped playing?
Even though he is on a 600k contract.

Players can’t just move when they want, there is mechanisms that don’t allow that.

Drafting, trading, contracts.

We don’t have a second round dp

If we go Bennell

We really can compare to the 09 trade period

We’ve got NFI

Goro was no small forward.

He was a mark - kick player

Membrey without all the running

Needs to tidy up his disposal, it is poor.

It’s dumb

But hey, it’s StKilda

No idea how to build a team.... already one failed attempt this decade, trying a different approach (wonder who they are copying this time?)

They’ve got no idea

He is contracted

We hold all of the bargaining power this year

Acres is our most overrated player

The fact he is being called a match winner proves it

And he’s not 194cm, that’s taller than Nick Reiwoldt.

He’s around 190cm

Because he’s played Forward generally... because he’s not good enough to play as a mid

Longer gone

Hickledick a finals bound ruckman

Where is StoneCold now? Probably embarrassed

Do you know we got Billy with the Compo pick for NDS

Steven, fully fit would be a top 5 player at most clubs, top 3 player at some. He is a gun, who has been in the best 2 players at StK since 2013. Why would we need a salary dump As it stands we have no good players outside of Hannebury who deserve big coin. Not even AA squad of 40 players. Other clu...

What happened in 09

We made a GF... and in a desperate bid to win it the following year, made some mind boggling list changes.

When and where has Ryder played well forward? He averages under half a goal a game, and played Forward in much of his time at Essendon, as Hille and Bellchambers rucked also in his time there. He left Essendon, and wanted to play ruck at Port Two rucks That didn’t work at all at Port this season. Th...

How do you improve a list by getting rid of important players? Steven is already gone. Another top ten player on the list (Bruce) with perhaps Carlisle? How is that making the list better? Even if we get some quality, isn’t that only going to replace the quality going out? Surely you’d just want to ...

The Longer it takes, the more it may be a different person.

If it’s Ross Lyon

I’m out

I wouldn’t say Marshall is developing, he was a top 6 ruckman in the league this year.