Luke Ball was our fault as a club

In a heart beat

He is a tease

Talking about list management calls

2009 was a great year onfield

Then some pathetic decisions post season meant the end came quicker than it should have

Still need the Pillars in place

We have too many defenders and small forwards, it would make more sense to get rid of players we don’t need.

And if the argument is that we would get something for Bruce, well perhaps that is because he has value?

It’s so stupid

That it’s something StK will do

It’s a wonder we don’t try and convince Sandilands to come out of retirement?!

The only positions we don’t need are Ruck and Key Forward
We are recruiting in a has been Ruckman and trading out a good key forward

So he’s a tall, who’s not good enough to play as a tall?

This year he averaged 17ppg as a utility player

I hope the dogs get him and try him as their key back

So is it more important to have A reasonable Ruckman for 20% and poor forward for 60% Or a Poor Ruckman for 20% and reasonable forward for 60% Not withstanding the fact that Ryder is 32yo This will be the straw that breaks the camels back for me. Last time I was this disgruntled with the club was 20...

He’s a workhorse Forward

Absolutely required in 2020

If we trade him out the list management are inept

The highly rated football coach that just got sacked.

Whatever we do, it’ll be an almighty f*** up

And we will look upon this off season as the beginning of the end

So we recruit a guy who isn’t good enough to make a good team, in order to become a good team... yep, makes perfect sense

What age were Bruce and Steele when we recruited them?

So we recruit a guy who isn’t good enough to make a good team, in order to become a good team... yep, makes perfect sense

What age were Bruce and Steele when we recruited them?

Just ridiculous if true

Next year we needed Josh Bruce more than ever

2009 was a horror off season

This off season will be just as detrimental

St Kilda deserve what they get

Martin is not really a small forward

Carlton
Older
Murphy, Simpson, Kruzer
Us
Geary, Armitage, Brown

Not sure why things can’t be ‘pleasing’?

Seems a pretty normal way to describe something you’re happy with

I agree Myrion

But I think it’s more about his attitude which stinks

It says

He has failed to hold down a key post, despite being 194cm, he’s not an A Grade mid, he’s a bit of a utility, at best a Wing/Flanker

Would you like me to produce his numbers

I think the idea of Tomlinson is better than the output of Tomlinson. Hence, the Acres comparison.

So can’t nail down a position at 26yo

But does volunteer work

I think he’s a nothing player, who hasn’t achieved much... bit like Acres

Carlton are certainly superior as is Sydney

Not sure on Melbourne, they have better player, but glaring deficiencies

Freo similar

I don’t rate North

Not massive on Adelaide, but they get home games.

At least we are better than the AFL basket case, that is growing the game so well in Qld

None of those players kick 40 per year

Which Key Forward is going to protect Max King next year, so he doesn’t get the gorilla defender at 19yo

I’d like someone to tell me what position Tomlinson plays?

He’s not a Key Forward, or a Key back? What’s his deal.

If they trade Josh Bruce

They have zero idea

I do hate his attitude, you’re right there

He just wants to zone off and take uncontested intercept marks, like McGovern.

But gets burned by his opponent, but unlike Gov, he can’t defend one on one.