Billings played a reasonable game.

Carlisle is a liability full stop, unless he can zone off and take intercept marks.

If he has to defend, or pick the ball up of the deck, he is terrible

Spinner

Armo
3 Brownlow votes
R19 2009

Highest StK player in Sandringham B&F 2009 he was 21 and in good form. But Ross did not show any faith in him.

Let’s face it, Ross botched selection and it may have been the difference between winning and losing. He also botched it in the box on GF day.

As a forward, you play your role in the group, sometimes you get on the end of them, sometimes not... forwards need to create goals as a collective and take their chances. Don’t think Lonie had a shot yesterday? But he clearly had a few assists. And one pass to Membrey where he kicked a point from 25m

Out over the 09/10 race period

X.Clarke, M.Maguire, L.Ball

Ins
A.Lovett, W.Johnson, J.Smith

And Newnes kicked a goal, which should be kicked 7/10 times or better at that level.

Just because others misses sodas doesn’t make his goal better than it was, it was not a difficult shot which he should have kicked.

Neutral venue?

Isn’t the G Carlton’s home ground?

He was outstanding, quality person.

Lonie

16 possessions and 2 goal assists

Reasonable output from a small forward

1 poor contest, where he positioned himself poorly at stoppage doesn’t define his game. That was a poor moment which will be highlighted on review, but he did some good stuff, especially early in the game.

This is your sporting life

Great interview, bit sad at times, but great fellow

So he can kick straight when he has one of his half a dozen set shots per year, good reason to play/keep him

He played ok. Not a huge influence, but found the footy a bit.

Not sure what’s happened to him?.... confidence or body? He was a solid B Grader for 3 years... now he is hopeless. I seriously think he is playing 5kg heavy, at his best he was a hard running wing/he with most of his possessions uncontested. He was in the top 3 of the club for 3k and used that run ...

He has always been lazy... just a lot easier to get away with it, if you’re playing as a seventh.

So today’s loss was Richo’s fault

Now I’ve heard it all

No, they didn’t want Selwood in the middle

Because they have a contested beast in there... Danger

And because he’s a bit banged up and they want to prolong his career.

5-Ross - Easily
4-Steele
3-Clarke
2-Hannebury
1-Hind

Marshall, great battle with Kruzer, but I’d give Kruzer the points, so no votes.
Although he played well, can’t give a vote to Membrey given his crucial misses

They have far more high end talent

He was very poor today

Again not enough of the footy for a mid, and used it poorly.

Poorly coached today.

The continual direction of the footy to Bruce v Casboult was ridiculous

Imo Casboult was BOG

He identified it eventually and shifted Carlisle (as useless a a dick in a gumboot!) but a really pathetic performance.

More of an issue than the chase... he was never going to catch him.

Was Lonies positioning at stoppage, he was 3 metres behind Simpson and a quick kick out of stoppage you should always be in front.

We deserve to lose

You don’t miss easy goals like we do and expect to win

Bruce is a work horse but he is so slow to get rid of the footy

He is the most tackled player in the act of disposal I have ever seen

Carlisle

Right now is the worst player I have ever seen below his knees. He is on train tracks, cannot turn and is a dead set liability

Long and Sinclair two easy misses

This is what stops us from being a decent team and has done for for 4 years