Some say Carlisle is our most important player, even our best player. Poor footy judges.

Some say Carlisle is overrated and is lazy. They actually watch the footy.

Poor entries, poor conversion

I blame Richo

Bruce misses two easy goals

Tex kicks a harder one

Explain how having our own side would make a bit of difference considering 14 players are unavailable?

The fact we were competitive for a half is astonishing

You do realise 2/3rds of their best team was not playing. Hamill May or may not be able to coach... you’d never know this season.

Was down there recently and the surface is ordinary at best! Heavy, patchy and uneven. I’ve played on suburban grounds that are better. The facilities are obviously great, and obviously being back at Moorabbin is good but the ground surface is nowhere near as good as Seaford, which is still like car...

I’d rather McKenzie on Betts than Coffield.

Fact is, if he was that good, he’d be playing. Do you think AR, fighting for his career would leave out a ‘gun’ for an average player? Or that Ratten would do the same? He is trying to impress and he leaves out a better player for a worse player... I don’t think so?! He got some talent, and is prett...

Harvey also got the ball a lot more than his direct opponent and a damn site more than Sinclair. He also carried the footy a lot more.

Spencer ‘buddy’ White

Arryn BJ Siposs

Paddy Plugger McCartin

Tommy Walsh

Blake GOAT Acres

Nah, we never overrate our players

If he’s going to play, maybe he should have checked out TBBO

So he told AR in 2017 that he’s leaving at the end of 2018. That would be a good move for his 2018 season. If he said that in his 2017 exit, he would have been delisted.

I think it’s a much more simple reason

There is deficits in his game which keep him out

Most important thing you do as a mid Win the footy, find the footy Because if you ain’t, your opponent probably is... to be an AFL inside mid, you MUST win the ball 25 times a game at least, good games 30+ The second part of the equation is to use it effectively, Luke is not a great kick. Thirdly yo...

Just to remind you Impatient of one of his best games 45 disposals, 1 goal, five tackles, 3 Brownlow Votes This coming a week after 35 disposals, 8 tackles and 11 clearances. Couple of weeks before that he got 30+ and 2 goals NOT BAD FOR A C GRADER? In fact He has picked up 40 Brownlow votes, so num...

I call that

The Robert Harvey game

Do you really reckon he’s told the club he’s out next season? What benefit would that serve him?

I think the othe4 way round, the club has probably stamped his papers.

If he was as good as he’s claimed to be, he’d be in the side.

Never mind the fact that DMac was off the ground for two of Cameron’s goals. Twice he beat DMac in a one on one DMac isn’t the first and won’t be the last player Cameron beats in a one on one. Right now I have Cameron in the best 3 small fwds (if not the best?) in the AFL. He’s a gun! DMac is a Gear...

Good player, but not what we need unless we offload either Seb or Dunstan

We need Brad Hill, his brother would be nice as a FA as well

I thought it was just ARs fault White hasn’t played?

Now two coaches, let alone the line coaches and dev coaches input. Is it conceivable that he just ain’t that good?
If I had to guess, I’d say his offence is ok, but his defending work is a bit of a question mark

Gastro

24-48 hour bug

Who wrote he’s had a good year He was at a sandy for a chunk of the season. He still only get the pill around 20 times per game, he’s still a slow inside mid with average skills He is however Tough and courageous, win inside ball and has a good attitude For the right money I’d resign him With the ri...

In his interview on SEN this arvo, he said he was very happy at the GC and just moved into a place with J Lukocious. Is enjoying his footy.

I think he’s got the talent of an A Grader The output is far from Like Acres, B White and a few others he is mysteriously overrated... not to say he’s hopeless, he can play... he’s just not as good as Saints fans make him out to be. Big call, but at times he can be a liability defensively with his l...

Adelaide will still start warm favourites

Gold Coast aren’t going to get any better by picking up guys who couldn’t get a game at other bottom clubs.

They need AFL experienced players

And talent.

Hasn’t been a word on him for two months, I think he’s pulled the pin. Wonder what SC thinks Hickey is doing a job for a top 4 team, Longer is pretty much finished as an AFL footballer. If you had to say at the end of their two careers who was the better AFL player, Hickey would be, hands down ... b...