What's the point in getting him we do need a key forward but not another 193-95 cm player we need a 198+ KPP who can compete with the big defenders. We have Hayes 194cm Allison 195cm Sharman 193cm and what is the point of difference with this player will he play back but then we have Battle 193cm co...

If we loose Dougal this year and Battle is out of contract next year as a restricted free agent and walks who do we have to play KPD, Adams was doing ok and with a 3rd year under his belt should have slot into that spot but now we could be caught out with only Cordy as a KPD any young guy we draft n...

Did Banger not achieve much as a forward coach because King missed 16 weeks and Membrey missed 19 weeks Or because our mids weren’t dominant Not sure 🤔 Chicken or egg Why don't we try and get Arron Hamill as a forwards coach he is doing great things at Carlton don't know when his contract is up tho...

Keep him he could play like a Blake acres roll on the ball for short stints or forward at 191cm he could take Owens HFF position when he is in the midfield I would hate to see coff play really well for someone else after he has been out of action for so long we should keep him at 23 we could always ...

Richmond need a replacement for Jack Riewoldt. BTW. The longer that Richmond drag their feet on their new coaching announcement, the more I think mini will be at the Saints next season. In place of who? Don't we have a interim footy operations manager in David Mission or even help with forwards

I think we should get him he is a handy player can play ruck, forward, back will cost us next to nothing and if he doesn't work out he have lost nothing.
Really I think he would thrive in our environment he works hard and puts himself on the line a win win for us.

Allison is lucky that he got a contract extension when he did. Contracted until end of 2024. What a spud he has been on the list for a few years now and struggles in the VFL in any position they play him. If We wont Youth why get rid of 4 young guys I would have kept Peris I hope they rookie list h...

James Jorden did get a rising sun nomination I think as well and he is still only 23 with potential more opportunity at the saints he could really thrive.

If he is out of contract why not lets be positive he would fit in well and could be a real swing man if needed. He has games under his belt and in our program I really think he would thrive. Lets also look at Chol he wonts out of GC now that Hardwick is back not best of mates he knows what he is lik...

Keep Coffield if we start to either delist our youth and trade some other young guys we will not have a core of players coming through we have plenty of 27+
But not that many 18-23 especially after we delisted Adams,Connolly,Peris,Bytel

If they were really invested in Youth why did they delist Adams,2 year first year injured, Peris had a good season in 2s got positive write up and even played more games the Allison, Mackenzie, Cofield, and same as Hayes. Bytel, was a bit disappointed with he has good hands and was unlucky not to ge...

Trading picks for players didn't work for us 2018-2022 and it won't work now. The Hill and Crouch trades were short term options. We need to go to the draft, trade out players for picks, and put out soft cap into player development. I agree with you about spending more money on player development b...

How about fixing up the academy's for the Vic teams so that we don't have to wait to pick 40 before we can get one of our own players we have developed that would be a start the interstate teams get enough leg up its about time we stood up to the AFL about this.

Bytel, Peris, Adams and Connolly gone. We keep guys like Highmore the turnover king in the VFL McKenzie, hasn't played in over a year, 4 young guys I thought Peris, Adams were doing well in the VFL by all reports from the coaches really hope we get 4 more young guys in and get rid of some of the sp...

The G Train Legacy wrote: ↑Tue 12 Sep 2023 10:16am I like Chol, has enormous potential, however I reckon Hardwick may want to keep him.

chol wonts out of GC he was under Hardwick at Richmond and hardly played reason why he went to GC I here he is desperate to get out so would get him cheap if that's the case why not.

Chol would be handy as a forward to help out king and Sharman with Membery maybe playing more as a high half forward. Chol also can ruck and even play as a KD which he has been doing in the GC seconds. Hollands would be also a good pick up at 21 and only 12 games at GC with there very strong midfiel...

Its not a argument Cordy is so much better in reading the play less turnovers and has a good mark on him. But lets just change the narrative Cordy and Dougal as KPD with battle as a floating defender taking intercept marks could work and would be better against the bigger forwards. Take more pressur...

Source? FWIW, here is my opinion: Gresham - yes, let him go and hope we get a 2nd round pick via free agency. Clark - must keep him. fits our young core profile. Billings- keep him. has no trade value, would be cheap to keep, good depth, let him finish as a 1 club player. Coffield - must keep him. ...

Source? FWIW, here is my opinion: Gresham - yes, let him go and hope we get a 2nd round pick via free agency. Clark - must keep him. fits our young core profile. Billings- keep him. has no trade value, would be cheap to keep, good depth, let him finish as a 1 club player. Coffield - must keep him. ...

Why do we have a restriction on a NGA when the interstate clubs don't no incentive another situation were we get screwed.
Is the club addressing the problem with the AFL really hope they are.
We get no father sons so this is the only way we can look to get a even break.

I like cooper and has a lot of potential but he needs to know about working hard in AFL He is soft when it comes to tackles we was watching as Caminiti and Poo were all over players and they are kids, Sharman was a spectator he wasn't the only one but talk about bruise free footy. Well he is still i...

How is Sharman still in after last week every time he got close to a contest he would not tackle and couldn't hold his marks.
At least caminiti will tackle and puts in and do some ruck work Sharman is a passenger.

Adams doesn't really have the physique to play as a key back. He's built similarly to Nick Blakey. In fact, he reminds me a lot of a guy who used to play for us in the early 1990s called Tim Elliot, who was a kind of defender/back up ruck. He does some good things, but he has his fair share of howl...

Check out the big O Oscar Adams he has been getting a great write up from batch each week exciting prospect still only 19 and big unit at 198cm Still has a bit to go but will be pushing for a sport next season especially if like I hear clubs are looking at Dougal or a cheaper Battle next season if w...

Vortex wrote: ↑Wed 02 Aug 2023 8:49pm

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Wed 02 Aug 2023 7:37pm Onya Saynta!

Call out the big-noters that can't spell!

Ray is big on speling

Ray who?