magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 13 Nov 2023 3:32pm I wonder if Mason likes GILFS.

Albeit articulate, educated Gilfs with red hair

One imagines our loris the fair maiden of the forum as leaner, fitter version than the demonstrated picture.

Mason Wood is now the Bud Annand of the 2020’s

At 29-30 next year is this what we really need a injury ridden player again. Wouldn't Brynn Teakle be better he is 24 204cm and 102kg played 6 games for Port he has been delisted as well. The club has decided that Dougal Howard is not the guy they want for full back, taking the oppositions tall for...

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 07 Nov 2023 10:03am James Stewart is rubbish

Wasn’t helped by the loss of a leg in a hunting accident.

How does the alignment differ atm Sandy is run onfield by StKilda coaches - Bachelor is employed by StK StK players get full priority in selection and positional I simply don’t think the alignment is the problem - it’s no different to Box Hill, Casey etc… we just look for excuses that aren’t actual...

Henry? Very hopeful, plenty of upside, vg pace. Will suit RTB game style. If he can tidy up disposal could be a good player. Dow? Most overrated player on this forum. Butt average player, ball butcher. Since we’ve recruited him he’s now a lightning quick clearance beast with elite hands that Carlton...

Bravo

I doubt the club rates Max King on tackles per game as long as he is competing fearlessly in the air and bring the ball to ground if he doesn’t catch it.

I don’t think RTB would be happy if his key forward is outmarked and didn’t apply pressure on the way out.

I support our Saints W team and I expect news and views on them to be fully a part of this website. They play in the W league, and just like with the M league, sometimes when something really big happens in footy, it comes up here, even if not Saints related. (We all do follow footy, after all) Eri...

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 01 Nov 2023 6:51pm Who is that?

A Carlton reject??

Yep, you betcha he is!

Hope I’m wrong but I will bet SOS has his eye on Lauchie O’Brien.

Definitely a prudent move to give another year to Tom Campbell, he's dedicated to the club and as someone else pointed out, he is a cheap ruck coach. All will be revealed whether or not Max Heath is AFL standard round about February next year when the squad is full steam into pre-season training an...

Highmore is probably cover for Wilkie, and with Wilkie playing what 100 odd in a row he has not had much opportunity. Not big enough or good enough one on one as a key defender, he reads it very well and has great hands but is behind Wilkie & Battle in the hybrid intercept style role. Average di...

Best clubman is an award that would be viewed very highly internally. Obviously Tom is selfless and assisting the development of Heath whilst providing solid back up if needed. There are different ways to stay on a list and purely on football ability, Tom probably wouldn’t retain a place. I really a...

I'm always confused as to how Geary being courageous, translated into good leadership. I'm not sure Geary was much good at all. Even hos courageous behaviour cost him dearly on the injury toll in the end. Nothing against Jarryn, but I think he is just another player we completely overrated. Persona...

Nick is genuinely a ripper bloke, he will have a chat to anyone, even the likes, of say, a Vortex type. And as said earlier, some autos are hit and miss, for eg after reading the Eric clapton auto I disliked the bloke, so couldn't help thinking it was an honest one. I'm sure this is impossible to o...

Depends on what your definition of what a great leader is? A good player? I know a few ex sainters that went back to local Three of them all preferred Jarryn over Roo as a captain I suppose everyone has a different pov I also know of players who weren’t RL fans As a young buck I was starting my fir...

I'm always confused as to how Geary being courageous, translated into good leadership. Looking back at the era he was captain and looking at the movements in leadership since, the football department review and the shocking player development that has gone on on the past, I'm not sure Geary was muc...

Good appointment.

Hard as a cats head, solid citizen, good leader and got everything out of himself as a player.

Hopefully he can turn these attributes into his off field career.

Melbourne would have been better off giving Bytel a go. Lol how did he go in trade week? Bytel will likely be picked up as a delisted free agent I hope you are correct Mike as he seems a ripping kid, just can't see a club handing a place to a guy who is purely an inside mid and is an average (at be...

B: Stocker, Howard, Wilkie HB: NWM, Battle, Sinclair C: Wood, Dow, Henry HF: Hill, Hayes, Sharman F: Butler, King, Membrey Foll: Marshall, Steele, Owens Int: Crouch, Phillipou, Windy, Clark, Sub : Hotton No room for Ross, Webster, Caminitti or Higgins? I think Webster, Stocker and Paton (Windy coul...

I’m changing topics. Sick of B.M and his ongoing rant of Billings. I’ve already forgotten about him. Tony has there been any news at the club? Has Liam Henry and Paddy Dow made their way down? Has Phillipou been training hard? Officially by AFL rules clubs are not allowed to have any formal trainin...

footynut wrote: ↑Fri 20 Oct 2023 8:29pm B: Stocker, Howard, Wilkie
HB: NWM, Battle, Sinclair
C: Wood, Dow, Henry
HF: Hill, Hayes, Sharman
F: Butler, King, Membrey

Foll: Marshall, Steele, Owens

Int: Crouch, Phillipou, Windy, Clark,
Sub : Hotton

No room for Ross, Webster, Caminitti or Higgins?

Courage on the footy field comes in many forms, however the fundamentals of the game demand that you sometimes need to focus on the ball at the expense of your own health. Nick Riewoldt attacked every contest as if his life depended on it. Jonathan Brown had to retire because he just didn't know ho...

Wilkie Howard Battle Webster NWM Sinclair Wood Crouch Henry Marshall Steele Windhager Hill Butler Higgins King Sharman Owens Clark Ross Caminitti Phillipou Sub: Jones EMG: Stocker Dow Byrnes Cordy Unknown: Membrey, young players Keeler, Hotton, Van Es, draftees or DFA we may take Who will be our win...

Scollop wrote: ↑Fri 20 Oct 2023 7:19pm He was a squibb on that occasion

There's a new sport in the Olympics where you run around and pass the footy without tackling...he should try out for that

Once again Scollop, your comments say more about you and your keyboard warrior status than they do about Jack Billings.