I thought he had a sold year Did he kick 30 goals? He’s our only true crumbing forward - without Gresham So is very important I thought Butts had an excellent year to be honest. He had the most pressure acts by a mile and kicked 30 goals for the season. Did anyone else in the league do that? Not ma...

Being a hybrid type of player ( a bit of this a bit of that) it's hard to predict what his ceiling is. Is he a Brendon Goddard type, is he a Nathan Buckley type, or is he more of a Tim Membrey type? He'll need to get more exposure to the in close midfield stuff to develop that part of his game. I h...

The kid hasn't even cemented his spot in the best 22 and you guys are acting like he is a God He did play every game last season, so he's obviously quite cemented in the eyes of the selectors. Although to be fair, I may have personally rested him a few times in favor of Billings. Phillipou reminds ...

It’s a lack of cattle imho . How many of our forward line would get a starting gig at a top 4 team ? King , and perhaps Mitchito ? We desperately need a 2nd tall. Jack Hayes is all heart and will keep presenting but he is a short term solution at best. Membrey our 3rd tall who plays as the 2nd tall...

We can replace Butts. As long as no one in our untouchable 5 gets injured we will be good to go...

The kid hasn't even cemented his spot in the best 22 and you guys are acting like he is a God

The Golden Greek...

We'd be better off switching a couple more home games to the MCG. Good experience for the players and not disruptive to supporters. Getting big crowds at the G would create more of a buzz, especially if we're on the rise Absolutely! Only getting 2 games per home and away season at the G is ridiculo...

Yes, we've had handouts, but the reason we've had them is that we were totally screwed for two decades in the docklands stadium deal. That contract cost at least $30 million dollars (compared to the clubs who play at the MCG and Essendon's sweet deal at docklands that we have subsidized for them). ...

New Zealand, Shanghai, Timbuktu - none have been in the past nor ever in future be happy hunting grounds for St Kilda. Emphasis must always be on getting the 4 points - sustained success brings crowds to the games and viewers to watch on Foxtel, plus headlines in the media. That will also force the...

New Zealand, Shanghai, Timbuktu - none have been in the past nor ever in future be happy hunting grounds for St Kilda. Emphasis must always be on getting the 4 points - sustained success brings crowds to the games and viewers to watch on Foxtel, plus headlines in the media. That will also force the...

The forward line can easily be fixed. Tell Ming and Membrey to lead to opposite flanks and leave Sharman in the square. Higgins needs to be at the feet of Sharman and Higgins needs to be running with the flight of the ball towards our goals. :idea: :idea: :idea: :idea: :idea: :idea: :idea: :idea: :i...

saynta wrote: ↑Mon 18 Dec 2023 6:38pm

NickyDal wrote: ↑Mon 18 Dec 2023 12:58pm Steele turned 28 last week. If a team offered say pick 7 and pick 20 would/should we take it?

no.

Keep this up and you will be moving onto my foe list...

New Zealand, Shanghai, Timbuktu - none have been in the past nor ever in future be happy hunting grounds for St Kilda. Emphasis must always be on getting the 4 points - sustained success brings crowds to the games and viewers to watch on Foxtel, plus headlines in the media. That will also force the...

.....What are we doing to rectify this? The AFL are A-Holes but we have also shot ourselves in the foot multiple times on this front. We have stuffed every venture we have tried. NZ is still available but I don't believe Western Springs has been rebuilt yet. We should still try and get that over th...

Steele turned 28 last week. If a team offered say pick 7 and pick 20 would/should we take it? a team wont offer that. I would not accept anything less. What do you think would be the best offer? And would you take it? I think if were to get pick 10 and 25 I would probably take it to be honest. Noth...

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Mon 18 Dec 2023 12:48pm OK, but Jack Steele is still the most handsome and Owens the strongest, Hill most aerobic over 120min and Rowan the best mark.

Steele turned 28 last week. If a team offered say pick 7 and pick 20 would/should we take it?

.....What are we doing to rectify this? The AFL are A-Holes but we have also shot ourselves in the foot multiple times on this front. We have stuffed every venture we have tried. NZ is still available but I don't believe Western Springs has been rebuilt yet. We should still try and get that over th...

If I understood the report correctly our debt has reduced from $9,990,504 to $8,489,324. FFS $8,489,324 Can you please put that into context with this statement. St Kilda has received $156 million dollars in AFL funding in the ten years between 2012-2021! Collingwood ?? ZERO! So we receive approxim...

.....What are we doing to rectify this? The AFL are A-Holes but we have also shot ourselves in the foot multiple times on this front. We have stuffed every venture we have tried. NZ is still available but I don't believe Western Springs has been rebuilt yet. We should still try and get that over th...

If I understood the report correctly our debt has reduced from $9,990,504 to $8,489,324.

FFS

$8,489,324

.....What are we doing to rectify this? The AFL are A-Holes but we have also shot ourselves in the foot multiple times on this front. We have stuffed every venture we have tried. NZ is still available but I don't believe Western Springs has been rebuilt yet. We should still try and get that over th...

.....What are we doing to rectify this? The AFL are A-Holes but we have also shot ourselves in the foot multiple times on this front. We have stuffed every venture we have tried. NZ is still available but I don't believe Western Springs has been rebuilt yet. We should still try and get that over th...

Next year, you won't mention NZ again for a while. But until then. Why not! Yes I will. It is another unfair advantage that other teams have. Their crowds and revenue don't depend as much on being a top side. Look at Collinfilth and the Druggies. No matter where they are on the ladder the ANZAC day...