5 Marshall
4 Hill
3 Steele
1 Battle
1 NWM
1 Sinclair

Big Max wrote: ↑Thu 07 Sep 2023 7:45pm At the risk of stealing Curley's mantle ..

I'm not a fan of umpire #2 Nick Foot

I am not a fan of Nick Foot either as many on here would know, but his decisions over the last season or two have at least been a bit more balanced if still erratic.

Fingers crossed he is at least fair this Saturday

StPeter wrote: ↑Mon 04 Sep 2023 9:35pm AFL 360 doing and saying everything they can tonight to get them to appeal and get him off.

Of course Gerard Whateley never shows much love for St Kilda.

AFL 360 again lobbying to get him off last night. They won't let it go!

Gerard Whateley has spent a lot of time last 2 nights on AFL 360 lobbying VERY hard for Bedford to be cleared.

I presume he has been doing the same thing on SEN. Will not let it go.

Quizzing RTB about it and Kingsley showing replays of the vision over and over.

Going to the draft With pick 11 Pick 31 Pick 39 (Compo for Gresham) Pick 41 (Clark) 2 x Picks in 50s (one for Billings) That’s 6 picks But not exactly a strong draft hand You might get some good players from that, but not sure you’ll get many stars Others that will be looked at to get some capital ...

AFL 360 doing and saying everything they can tonight to get them to appeal and get him off.

Of course Gerard Whateley never shows much love for St Kilda.

Agree with all of this.

Perhaps to me the biggest mistake was giving Acres away (along with 2 high draft picks).

He obviously to me had up side to come.

Also Dal Santo huge mistake.

M 52 row W

Jack Sinclair has topped the ranking for the second season in a row with Champion data. To quote “It’s his ball use that just completely sets him apart.” Let's just hope that the umpires start to notice him more when casting Brownlow votes this year. Yes I have backed him again. Last year at 1000-1,...

MC Gusto wrote: ↑Mon 28 Aug 2023 7:49pmNas unlucky

All three deserving as is NAS but unlikely they name three Saints half-backs.

Also NAS's great year largely gone un-noticed by the media.

I'm not sure that I would put it in terms of the AFL screwing us. But I do think it's odd that 6 of the teams playing finals could have had games at their home ground (although Sydney and the Giants won't because of where they finished) and 2 (Carlton and us) can't. Kardinia Park is clearly too sma...

If we had lost by another 10 points or more we would be playing GWS in Sydney this week, so from a ladder point of view, almost as good as a win.

although if Carlton still lose, we would be playing Sydney instead of GWS at the MCG

Last week's wrong decision by the goal umpire in Adelaide is really looking bad for us now.

It is going to cost us a home final.

5 Sinclair
4 Marshall
3 Wilkie
2 Windhager
1 Crouch

meher baba wrote: ↑Sat 26 Aug 2023 8:32pm And if Sydney wins and GWS wins by 7 goals, then we get to play Carlton at the MCG. And I think we'd be in with a pretty good chance in that game. So nothing to get too bothered about IMO. TBH, I reckon GWS is the team I'd be least keen on us having to play ATM.

Not going to happen.

GWS need to win by at least 43 points to pass us on percentage. Carlton in the first column and the score GWS need in the second. BTW I did my first scenario based on us having a losing score of 60. In the words of Mike Williamson, "I tipped this" Car gws Margin 40 83 43 41 84 43 42 86 44...

I thought he was good, especially in the third quarter. If King and Ross are fit in two weeks time, I think he misses out, as does one of Sharman and Hayes: possibly Sharman. Clark to be the sub again. Clark had only 53% game-time today. There must be a doubt about his fitness or he is carrying an ...

Saints will stay clear of GWS provided they don't win by more than seven goals against Carlton following the Saints 12 point loss today.

This seems unlikely.

Now we just need Melbourne to beat Sydney to get a home final

Excellent program. Some progress has been made in recent years although not enough. We won't see again in the media such rubbish as the homophobic jibes that used to appear on programs like The Footy Show that used to masquerade as humour. The introduction of Pride Round for our club and the Swans i...

Wow!

They were discussing the appeal on SEN this afternoon and giving it no chance of succeeding, even suggesting they might add a week.

Sincs comes across as the very intelligent person he is, as his on-field smarts shows so often. I disagree with the comment that "he's turned into a really good footballer". He has shown he is a good footballer from his very first practice match as a few of us realised. Unfortunately the m...

It might have been nice for Caro to agree and admit being wrong about the Saints as she has hardly tipped us all year.

She has no respect for our team or players.

Demons unlikely to be flat out against the Swans as they know they are firmly placed in fourth place whatever their result. Though if Swans beat Melb, then they draw level on points. If GWS have a good win against them, Swans could possibly slide above them just as GWS can slide above us. If Swans ...

We are disadvantaged by the actual time we play our final match. The other teams playing after us will all know what they need to achieve to secure their best place. If we lose Carlton have no incentive to win against GWS, ladder wise, as home final certain for them. GWS will know exactly what they ...

I would like to see Jack Hayes get a game before the finals. RoMa had it fairly easy on Saturday but that won't be the case this week. After Brad Hill, he is our most important player. I would rest both. Brad Hill is more important than Sinclair? Hmmm not sure what matches you have been watching th...