Starting to really fear that Stanley won't make it. Can't complete basic plays and refuses to take the game on and use his speed and skills.

Gears! What a dependable, solid player he's become...

Decent game from Milera. He might be worth persisting with. Looks a much better prospect than Saad for mine.

I'm done after this. That bordered on cheating the influence the umpires had on the game. I won't be attending another game while Demetriou is CEO and Jeff Gieschen is umpires boss.

Wow, just terrible selections.

Warning bells should have gone off last year when he said Kosi and Blake were required players. A decent first up season provided some hope that he might have a shot at being a decent AFL coach. That's just a distant memory now after the embarrassment of the Bulldogs and North games. He now looks a ...

Wow, some of the posts in this thread are mind boggling.

I don't see nearly enough in Watts to think he will be anything out of the ordinary. He certainly looks like he's cruising most of the time and doesn't show nearly enough aggression or attack on the footy.

Watters playing Stanley in defence reminds me of I think Stan Alves or Tim Watson playing Barry Hall as a defender for a short time. Stanley is clearly not a defender in my opinion.

Ray out is laughable. Agree with Maister and one of Milera/Saad.

Rhys Stanley, hugely disappointing. Where is his so called pace, effort and hardness at the contest?

Saad makes far too many mistakes. Siposs should be on the ground, has way more ability than Maister. Stanley looks lost as a defender and might be wasted. Would like to see Siposs on for Maister and be a lead up forward. Swing Stanley forward if continues to struggle.

Goddard cried... He f****** cried to a television boundary rider, FFS. It was embarrassing. Quite happy he's no longer associated with St Kilda FC. Goddard is still the petulant child he's always been. We got our first glimpses this season Fri night when the Cats roughed the Bummers up. Him crying ...

Geary's aggression and attack on the footy is just what the team needs. If he took a few of his chances tonight he'd have been close to BOG.

Very happy that Farren Ray is in. He's a class above half our list.

Jaxons, do yourself a favour and ignore the resident flogs on here like joffaboy and plugger66. It's impossible to have balanced, sensible and intelligent discussions, or share opinions with clowns like them.

Milera should have come in for Saad and Hickey for Kosi.

For the good of the team, Kosi must play out the season in the senior side. For the good of Riewoldt, Kosi must play out the season in the seniors. For the good of our structure, Kosi must play out the year in the seniors. The game has gone past Justin and is quicker then ever but we can structure ...

TDL is dreadful.

Ray has been far from our worst and Siposs if fit should be playing. Good to see some new blood though. Kosi in is laughable. Terrible selection.

Make no mistake Goddards loyalty is to himself and to a lesser extent his wallet and the chance to win a flag. My opinion he is an arrogant and selfish person who acted on impulse and now has what I like to call traitors remorse. In my opinion His tears were for himself. He can cry a river of tears...

Was it really necessary to recruit all of Milera, Saad and TDL? All 3 were woeful tonight.

He isn't any good but he has plenty of heart. Ridiculous call.

They certainly weren't crocodile tears.

Still loves the Saints. That interview. Wow!