No room for Ball?
C. Judd on the bench?

homework wrote:trade joey for judd

And the Clarkes for the Cornes boys.

And Armitage to go back home for Brown

Maguire and Giansiracusa to Carlton

Cox to Saints

Pick 9, Scotland and Bullies first pick to Eagles

Fevola and Carlton third round pick to Bulldogs

....

Well I can dream

Your best post ever without a doubt Rodger! You talk perfect sense and logic here. Very balanced and broad perspective that gives a good insight into how we REALLY are doing.

Poor decision about Sweeney. Should have been given a real go. Was impressed with his game v Hawthorn. Could have been that X factor we lack up forward.

Would he add something that we've been lacking? One thing he is though is a ball magnet. Even if he's having an ordinary day can still find a lot of the ball and win plenty of clearances. Could be handy at the right price, but would like to see us go for a pacy midfielder/wingman!

Shocking bloke though. Was with Didak on that infamous night, and a few other stories as well. At least he went home when the night was turning into morning...unlike our mate Alan... who coincidentally played a blinder on Friday!! I have also heard some less than encouraging (to be nice) reports ab...

I agree with you there Richter, but the player would have to be very good. Of the players you mentioned above, I wouldn't touch Davis, Lovett, Green or Sylvia, all for different reasons. You need to get quality ... I think Sylvia could be a good acquisition OWTS, if we get their 3rd rounder in retu...

Reckon we have enough slowish, hard-ball players (Bakes, Lenny, Bally) in the midfield. We need pace... Schammer could be an option for a 3rd rounder?

rightfully so too stinger.. Budge is one of the few opposition supporters who come here that I have a grain of respect for because of the way they handle themselves in this forum ...Babyblues, QueenC, Goalden Hawk and Lynch_Beast are the others that spring to mind. It is very useful to have oppositi...

STINGER!! wasn't a word of warning to you mate!! ps....do you speak for the mods these days..... in response to that, i meant, clearly i'm not a moderator or representing the views of many saints supporters here that would not like to see Budge repeat his outbursts! that's all! wasn't having a crack...

. Take it easy and I'm actually supporting your mob this coming week! i would think we all are... ...apart from b4e......seeing his friend (?) is a pussy supporter..... ps....do you speak for the mods these days..... :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: Just a word of warning Sting! pretty sure most of us h...

Never trade a first round pick unless the deal is heavily in your favour. Exactly. Why would the other team involved do that trade then? You gotta give up something to get something in return. Pick 9 could be an absolute superstar, but it could also produce an absolute dud who doesn't play a game.

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how? This is my guess.... Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6...

We all do things we regret from time to time. Good to see you back on the bike. speak for yourself..... :lol: :lol: :lol: :wink: :wink: :wink: ...oh...hang on......the first missus was a big mistake..... :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :roll: I was waiting for your response stinger.... Look Budgie i'll...

Sam23 wrote:Pick 9 for Brent Prismall.

Pick 9 for Colin Sylvia and Demon's 3rd rounder!

...the roos are fighters, aren't they.... ? ....we are certainly more talented than other teams in the finals......shows how much we underperformed this year.... I'm constantly amazed by the Kangas...a nothing budget..not much support..very well run organisation. Good luck to them. But still think ...

*applauds*

Top post Kaos! Well-researched and extremely convincing! I find myself agreeing with you on pretty much every point you raised...

there is no way eagles would trade priddis for baker and pick 9 baker isnt a required player for them and if judd leaves they need all the star onballers they can have and priddis is a star I never said that it was a realistic trade ... If it was offered to us, I would take it in a heartbeat, but i...

If most are willing to trade Primsall for pick 9 Just imagine what other players we could pick up. first round pick, you could almost get a top 10 in any club.... why go for a player who only played 4 games., yes he is good but not worthy of pick 9 I think Priddis would be worthy of that spot Saint...

Another thing is also, would the Blues be willing to trade their most likely replacement for Fevola?

Would definitely make a play for Moody. As mentioned in a few previous threads, can provide a lot of run and has played some great senior footy already! Does anyone else think Ben Fixter is worth a spot? For depth obviously, but a handy small backman who can do a defensive job up the field as well?

I would straight trade Pick 9 for Prismall not sure why not....he is exactly what we need and is a proven performer. Not so sure about "proven performer" tag. Would go with "shown a lot of promise" as a description myself. Pick 9 may be a bit much for Prismall - Pick 9 for Prism...

Brent Prismall is my #1 want. He wants out of the Cats i've heard to go to another AFL club, Essendon is the one going around....but if we offered enough, cats would trade him to us yes? 5 games this year @ 20 possessions per match. Quick and can get his own ball, would slot into our mid rotation. ...

Ben Cousins i want to see us go after ben cousins try offer him a 150k-200k a season contract i love his football skills not so much his personality but if we could give wce a 2nd round draft pick for him i would do it flat out Yep, and while we're at it, let's get the Cornes boys for a package of ...