savatage wrote:There is no way X Clarke should be signed to a 3 year deal - I would give him one year, tell him this season is make or break & make sure he earns another contract.

I would use him as trade bait to lure a more CONSISTENT performer.
If unsucessful then a 1 yr deal

Sydney for me

1.Plapp - dud of the highest order 2.Tim Elliot - see above 3.Clinton Jones - makes me extremely nervous seeing as though he cannot kick a football, plus lacks decision making abilities 4.Jason Trinidis - need i say any more 5.Mqualter (i hope i eat my words here, however) but atm simply does not cu...

Interesting to see Panozza in the best there, went to school with him, real natural talent, was very close to being drafted to richmond or north melbourne in the draft 2 yrs ago

I presume he looked good today?

Thanks Fraser

Its been a blast watching you go at it

I think he is a very selfish player and wouldnt want him at Stkilda!!

Watch him this weekend, good player and all but always thinks about himself

I would probably go for sydney

My dad played a bit of under 19s for South Melbourne so at least there is a little bit of a relation, although i would be no where near as passionate as i am for stkilda!

I like your theory, i guess it brings some positive out of the game.

Perhaps people who always seem to lose when they place money on things, could sacrifice a few dollars to the benefit of STKFC, it could be seen as a donation to the club

They didn't complain too loudly when they played Brisbane at the MCG in an 'away' Prelim though in 2004. Geelong sicken me.[/quote] Exactly right, hope the excuses come and bite them in the arse. If i remember correctly in 2005 the week we adelaide, they were already tring to organise a friday night...

I reckon Collingwood would be crazy to wanna play us....we seem to have the game that when on opens them up a little... Was just reading some of their Pie Board stuff at Bigfooty (tks JD for the access code etc) and some interesting quotes: "as long as the lions, saints & dogs arent in the...

Is it just me or is everyone starting to get sick of the same threads constantly appearing wanting collingwood to win.

Enough is enough imo

This is a St.Kilda Football club Forum!!

I cant wait for this game to finish, so there are some new topics brought up for discussion

Well this yr my tipping has been absolutely shocking for the first time in yrs. So i will sacrifice my tip and go with adelaide hoping my friday ngith form continues where i rarely pick the winner :wink: As for betting, sydney are currently at $2.10 playing hawthorn in sydney, and that probably has ...

Behind Play wrote:Rocca got a reprimand....IMO that should be better for us. I trust the big oath pulls his finger out and kicks 10.

But doesnt he have a prior record

If memory serves me correctly, he was suspended this yr when we played the pies.

Doesnt a record count for anything all of a sudden???

If i didnt have cricket training would have gone for sure

Since i cant go, i think ill watch it in the comfort of my own home so i can always change the channel if it gets bads and occasionly check the scores.

Go Pies

Buchanan got one, this surely is a joke..... \ Ive said it before and ill say it again Sydney are a bunch of koalas in that they are a protected species!!! As for Rocca getting off i am very suprised, coz he did hit an afl lovechild (also sydney player) in A.Goodes, im suprised that didnt come with...

0.11 by Stuart spencer for nth rd5, 1956 vs geelong
0.11 by tom allen for rich rd 14, 1949 vs north

These 2 goalscoring feats are the worst where no goal has been scored.

Im interested to see what are people think LeCras and Lynch both had set shots for goal, both time went across the face with cox waiting to smash it out of bounds denying us a kick in. The were able to keep it in their forward 50 from the 24 to 27 and 1/2 min mark by doing this. Does anyone else thi...

mad saint guy wrote:If Collingwood win they will finish 5th and we'd finish 8th.

We'd play Collingwood in an elimination final, then the winner would play the Kangaroos in a semi.

Love the optimism, but lets just get there first
Should we get there id like our chances to get to the last 4

If i didnt have cricket training i would go to the game next friday!!! I guess the benefit of their game being before ours means we know what is required on the saturday arvo, with ess playing at the same time, hopefully our spot is secured by 5pm on saturday Also with sydney losing last night, we a...

FFS you guys. The umps don't go into games with any intent to shaft one team or the other. If the Saints are good enough and want it enough they'll win. I agree with u there, BUT is it about being consitent with the frees in how they are awarded. I dont care if they are soft or well earnt, as long ...

F*** me!!!!!!!!!!!!!! dementrioiu...watch your bloody back! I wonder if he will be sitting with RB like he did a few weeks ago, cant remember who we were playing, think it was adelaide The dimwit walked str8 past me going into to get his party pies at HT. He wouldnt have the balls to enter the stki...

Shady wrote:I hate McBurney

Here here
Unfortunately we got the same moron umpiring us again this week

saintbrat wrote:I'll be there and thankfully no one sits in front of me as my voice gets used forcefully.

LOL, same here, im the members people seem to take it in turns to sit in front of me each week

Im absolutely pumped for the game

Cmon sainters 4 quarters of gold!!

Stephen Theodore wrote:On what evidence ?

thats exactly the reason i want to hear.
Will happily accept it if VALID

Tribunal is a joke for example Baker last year 2 weeks for attempted strike at stafford, he couldn't even reach him. 2 weeks Kerr hits Mitchel, i think? in the nuts and gets off then today all the evidence supports Baker and he gets rubbed out Farmer says he cant remember anything then give evidenc...