5. Lenny "The Man and the Heart and the Soul" Hayes
4. Adam Schneider
3. James Gwilt
2. Raph Clarke
1. Leigh Montagna

Apologies: Gilbert, Fisher and Dal Santo (who's last quarter was something special)

I think you will find the deal was structured before he left...

philip

Think about players or a player who may have had a 5 year deal!!!

Also, as has been suggested on another post, if you were to look north on a compass, you would likely find the whistleblower!

philip

Well I'm certainly worried. Very worried. Rightly so too. I have it on good authority that one players (retired) contract has already been identified for review and it was not Spider's (contrary to Caro's assertion in The Age this morning). Please don't ask me which player as I certainly will not p...

I still can't get my head around the fact that if you had a second set of player payments why this second set would be anywhere near a pre arranged visiting salary cap investigator. this. It is unbelievable, the stupidity of the fraudsters is incredible. not really apparantly there was a whistle bl...

I am pi$$ed off only for my son.... He is in his bedroom crying and the framed signed jumper I purchased for him as a Christmas present is now worthless... I would like to demand my money back, it cost me over $600 for the item and it was sitting proudly along last years St Kilda framed jumper and ...

saint66au wrote:They'd have to investigate Richmond too then?

you can be sure of it Michael.

philip

Alreay mooted by the warblers on SEN. Thought our SC's had been pretty extensively investigated. The bonus is that it over 5 years ago, and unless we are as dumb as Carlotn who sent the auditors the wrong set of books or the Storm who left them lying about the office, it would be hard to lay anythi...

I have a sinking feeling that this isn't good news for our club. I hope that Waldron only came up with this idea after he left our midst, but I fear that this won't turn out to be the case. I think during Waldron's time the club' fessed up to a couple of breaches with the salary cap. Maybe Waldron'...

Alreay mooted by the warblers on SEN. Thought our SC's had been pretty extensively investigated. The bonus is that it over 5 years ago, and unless we are as dumb as Carlotn who sent the auditors the wrong set of books or the Storm who left them lying about the office, it would be hard to lay anythi...

Given Brian Waldron has been implicated by the NRL and now SEN for his alleged role in the salary cap rorting, it is a fair bet that additional scrutiny will now be placed on the Saints player payement/contracts while he was our CEO. Expect there to be stories on this and on us in the papers over co...

5. Rooey
4. BJ
3. Joey
2. Jones
1. Dal

Apologies to Gram and Gilbert

i'm good for 17 shares so we are now officially under the 100 mark.

philip

99 shares left...get in quick!!!!

I posted below on bigfooty, in regards to queries concerning his ability to sue for unfair dismissal. can an employment lawyer run their eye over it, correct me where i am wrong and advise one and all. philip i don't believe he can sue for unfair dismissal, there is an exclusion if your remuneration...

look the result is disappointing, but it was a gamble and when you gamble, sometimes you win and sometimes you lose.

this time, we lost. but who's to say our pick 16 would have produced a champion?

philip

There is no comparison, the AFL membership with a club support package is way better. I had a normal saints membership for many years then changed to AFL with club support in 2001. You start off as silver and you can go to any 40 games at the MCG or Docklands. You sit on the wing at both grounds. Y...

Great value if you go to a pile of other games during the year. AFL Members sit L1 on the Wing near interchange at ES Finals: You cant buy with St Kilda allocation you have to buy AFL Members area You'll be a Silver member for a few years which should get you a GF ticket if Saints play but no chanc...

Winmar - good luck to the kid, but geez it sounds like a pick based on emotion not logic Hope you are kidding. Do you really think the Saints choose a young player on emotion??? F*** you dont think much about Lyon if thats the case :roll: with Joffa on this one. the one thing you can say after the ...

raph is a gun. he's not, but he could be if he can get the weaknesses out of his game. i like him better on or in front of the ball than in defence. Agreed. However with Max gone and reports Colm Begley is to get the flick - Raph seems destined for the backline. Mabye with Goose and Dempster steppi...

as for the prelim this year, i watched it, was even at the game, as for raph playing well, i can name you 5 guys that played well and raph was not one of them. what he did do was break even with his opponent, which i guess is something. philip As I said - you are clueless. Absolutely have no idea. ...

as for the prelim this year, i watched it, was even at the game, as for raph playing well, i can name you 5 guys that played well and raph was not one of them. what he did do was break even with his opponent, which i guess is something. philip As I said - you are clueless. Absolutely have no idea. ...

Philip the point of the OP was to make the point that while Raph may have not had the best of games against the Cats.....it was not he who missed gilt edged opportunities in front of Goal The coach has seen fit to give him the run in the team during which only three games were lost! It was a CHEAP ...

you need to spend more time with truly qualified professionals like chartered professionals :lol: as for the prelim this year, i watched it, was even at the game, as for raph playing well, i can name you 5 guys that played well and raph was not one of them. what he did do was break even with his opp...

you blokes are joking...i don't know bedwell and couldnt give a toss about him but he has no position at the club and all said publicly is what a large percentage of us have said on the board for a long time... that was: raph clarke is a liability on the ground. he is slow in thought, word and deed....

apparently i am missing something here, because by the sounds of what i am reading i am in the minority, so hear is my two cents... it is an official club function. it is not the players personal private time. it is repeat an official club function. they are not buying groceries at the supermarket o...