i think you are being harsh on him personally.

he's played a lot of very good games for north. and i'm not suggesting he would be the right fit or player to fill that void for us, but to call him a dud, means that real duds have no where to go.

philip

not a friggin chance im prepared to trade tim elliott and caydn beetham and draft pick 107 for fevola but the baggers would need to pay at least $550,000 of his $750,000. the guy is a social misfit and there is a reason the baggers are trying to get rid of him... no, no, no and in case you were in a...

i support both... for the orginial or first GF, if it is tied at the end, 10 mins extra time each half (no time on). if it is still tied then replay. for the second GF, if it is tied at the end, 10 mins extra time each half and if it is still locked together, then the 18 players on the ground each t...

when chappy kicked the goal to put them 6 points up.

at that stage i thought these guys are too professional to let this slip now.

philip

We also have Jack Stevens! bingo...add a few kg's, a couple of seasons and he is our chappy. lynch looks like a s.johnson replica and heyne adds some toughness too, but they are at least 3 seasons away from producing week in, week outl. but, we don't have three seasons why i actually think ebert is...

the context of his post philip, is that he kicked a player on the day of a heart wrenching loss, on supporters forum - not the time or place imo. then he tried to justify it based on some form of closer tie - almost every poster here i'd warrant, has a closer tie to raph than he - an emotional tie ...

no need to eat our own, but those of you treating raph as a protected species don't want the following: - us to improve; - to raise the bar on acceptable performaces and decision making; - apply pressure on the coaching staff to get our bottom 6 better; and - to recruit players with good decision ma...

5. Gram 4. Hayes 3. Baker 2. Ball 1. Blake thought gram was outstanding today. people that follow the forum know i've been a critic of his this year for shoddy disposal but hats off to him. as to the norm smith issue, chappy clearly deserved it in a winning side and if we had got up, grammy would ha...

the reason we lost was because we did not take our opportunities. we should have gone in to half time 5 goals up, but misses by milne *2, mini and schneids were the difference. our loss had nothing to do with umpires, karma, the weather. as ross said now he knows how the doggies felt last week, when...

stinger wrote:ross was always going to play dempster in the grannie....imho.....stands to reason...he is an experienced grand final player.......

to quote from a legend of these parts..."yep, yep and yep."

philip

happy to trust the selection committee but max should have been made an emergency in stead of gwilt, and whilst i think there is huge upside for rob eddy the writing was on the wall three games back, which was when the club should have stuck with dempster!

philip

i'll tell you my smokey once i've got on the fixed odds

philip

1. Rooey
2. Hayes
3. Fisher
4. Mini
5. Montagna

Apologies to Sam Gilbert, Jason Gram and Clint Jones.

philip

dare to dream plugger, that's why we are sainters.

while i will settle for a 1 point win, i honestly believe we will serve it up to them. they will be competitive for one and a half quarters and then we will go up five gears and pile the pressure and goals on. even in the rain, our superior skills will see us home easily. them playing rocca only hel...

"Dawson dropped" "Hayes seriously injured" "Nick Dal Santo out" The only people who think these are funny are the ones that write them. Give them their own little forum where they can entertain each other. in that case, do you get three red cards for writing them :lol:...

i do actually happen to own a lucky 8 ball but rest assured this came from a better authority than that!

philip

5. S.Fisher 4. J.Gram 3. N.Riewoldt 2. R.Clarke 1. S.Gilbert i've been tough in previous posts on both gram and clarke but from what i saw today, they were both very good contributors. i know people have queries gram's % efficiency with his disposals, but his link play and running of the lines was q...

The folly of dropping Max is now apparent. Fancy keeping Dawson at Max's expense. Dawson looked like a big kid out there today, with no idea. you are closer than you realise in understanding why max was dropped. not is all as it seems. more was being tried today than people on the forum either unde...

The folly of dropping Max is now apparent. Fancy keeping Dawson at Max's expense. Dawson looked like a big kid out there today, with no idea. you are closer than you realise in understanding why max was dropped. not is all as it seems. more was being tried today than people on the forum either unde...

the op should be ashamed of himself putting such crap on the forum...anybody who seriously thinks that the saints brain trust would be entertaining trading one of its former captains and actively shopping him around 3 weeks before the most important finals series for the club this century has got t...

am i the only one who thinks giving the OP / report credence is embarrassingly pathetic and speaks very poorly for all of us. Facts: - we are first by a country mile - there are only a handful of games to win the premiership - trade week is at least 7 - 8 weeks away c'mon everyone, a little pride in...

I'm sorry.. but to throw in the racist call beacause of Raph is wrong. I think that has more to do with you than anyone else. Not good form by the other supporters either. you referring that comment to me.......i hope not...as i'm f****** certain that most of the abuse directed at raph is race rela...

5. Gardiner
4. Hayes
3. Riewoldt
2. Gilbert
1. Blake

stinger wrote:

philip wrote:

Eastern wrote:

MC Gusto wrote:where are the knockers?? superb today

They're around !!

Tom

I'm one of them for his game today, and you know i am no troll.

philip

i didn't call you a troll...

stinger

known you for a long time, and i promise was not referring to you.

philip