Guilty or Not Guilty.
Both will have their supporters.
Like usual it is the consistency that causes most angst.
Also very perplexing is that the broken jaw is deemed "medium" impact. I'd hate to see the result of high level impact! They'd be calling for the Undertaker (not the wrestler)!!

What's the definition of a good Ruckman? Possession, Cox Contested marks,? Tap outs, Sandilands Goals? Each have different strengths.... I'd say hit outs are the most overrated?... They often don't even correlate with clearances, let alone wins The guys like Cox, sandy, Otten, Nic nat, Goldstien an...

And Alby got suspended for kicking whilst playing with us.
Gee we're a bad influence on the competition.

"ban visible tattoos", "a sign of weakness", "tramp stamps" You guys must be joking?? Judging people because they have tatts = pretty poor effort. They are as such, a fashion statement. Just like long hair and sideburns in the 70's and earrings in the 90's. Were you ag...

Have to say I never noticed Sir Winston had a sleeve or JKF a neck tattoo! I'm not talking about some discreet little tattoo. I'm talking about major work like a sleeve or those hideous neck tattoos and abominable face tattoos. No way would there be 23,000 Australians with them much less 2.3 millio...

Yep, that's 2 out of a likely 2,300,000 Australian's who have tattoos. They must all be no good then! Oh, that's also 2,300,000 Aussies that are 'weak'.
JFK, Winston Churchill and Franklin Roosevelt must have all been of poor character and weak.
Sheeeesh.

"ban visible tattoos", "a sign of weakness", "tramp stamps" You guys must be joking?? Judging people because they have tatts = pretty poor effort. They are as such, a fashion statement. Just like long hair and sideburns in the 70's and earrings in the 90's. Were you aga...

Realists trying to justify or defend someone just because they were a saints player and Greening was a Collingwood player Bias that can't be overcome in the 'realistic' argument... Firstly those who can't accept what happened... And try to come up with unlikely alternatives... Which the tribunal ob...

Maybe if we all stop replying to BigMart the thread will go away.
That would be the best outcome.
The realists aren't going to change their mind and neither, I fear, is BigMart.

His objective was to hit him in the head,,anytime you hit someone on the head especially with intent and force you stand a fair chance of knocking them out! He we go, another one who both saw the incident and heard from O'Dea what his intent was. We all have some idea of the what may have transpire...

It's probably the most scrutinised incident in VFL history.... Do some research.... John Greening has an interesting take on it.... I think he believes it was callous and malicious, as do the reporters, supporters and players who have commented on it. And please do tell Why do you 'king hit' a pers...

The really was only one sad thing to come out of that incident. And only 1 victim.... The other was self inflicted... His object was to knock Greening out, illegally.... It was callous and malicious.... It's that simple really! Leigh Matthews incident was no different! Disgusting, and he's admitted...

With 18/19 I hope we get one or the other (Lewis/Hartung).
Don't need both at that size, but one would be great.

Don't know much about him, but just watched two goals from the '50', one on the right and one on the left. Who do we have that can do that?
I know kicking goals is not the only consideration of ability.

Believe 19 is also considered first round as the compensation pick comes before the start of the second round.

Would (probably) make a good assistant coach.
Tried to get him a number of years back. Went to Collingwood because Malthouse gave his coaches a day off. Lyon wanted 7 day weeks!

Believe I'd be happy with that.
We need a big lump in the back half and like Savage. Enjoys running with the ball and good kick.
Would also be awesome to gazump Carlton on a deal!

Gee, Dal's cousin, Marcus Bontempelli, is growing on me.
190cm solid body midfielder with sound attributes.
Today's update says he has sprung up another 4 cm.
194cm midfielder.
Would be some presence.
Pick 3 probably too high, and not likely to last past 10 or so.

Take a chill pill everyone.
Just let the trade period pan out and then we can see what actually happened, who went, who stayed.
Same hysteria every year around the trade period.

We haven't won a flag since 1966...huh...what...when did that happen. That's breaking news!!

Jim Krakouer and Steven Theodore as the enforcers.

The club only needs to be in touch with the AFL and the victim.
Tony Jones and the media can go fcuk themselves!!

Because "Vlad" has been made to look silly, he will ensure someone is punished at StKFC for this stupid prank!
Has backtracked at 100 mph, "I thought it was a joke" and "it's just reprehensible".
Don't ever make him look a fool. He is a vindictive SOB.

Surely it has been proven beyond doubt that Gilbert is one of the most important players on our list. He is 194cm tough as nails, lightening quick. He is a GUN. why give him away? Ridiculous Because like a number of our players, he has trouble hitting the side of a barn. Why do think Rooey gets so ...

In terms of giving it everything you've got, he is equal with Rooey and Lenny. Thank you Jason.